Best All Time Premier League XI - Cast your votes

[Stu Monty]

I love how people are voting based on how they performed in the Premier League even though that's explicitly not the point of the game. The point is that you get them at their peak level, wherever that was, because it would make it more interesting.

 

You people.

[James Dean]

Stu's one edges it for me, but unfortunately I was always going to vote for the team with Xabi Alonso in it.

[Nunavut Patrick]

Stu's one edges it for me, but unfortunately I was always going to vote for the team with Xabi Alonso in it.

 

Me as well, plus Ravinelli in Serie A in its pomp he was scintilating.

 

Also can't believe Stu awarded the West Coast train contract to FirstGroup as well.

[Stouffer]

No Tony Yeboah, oh dear.

[Guest The Big Green Bastard]

Woo's team is not disabled, it has a decent spine.

[KMD7]

Woo's team for me.

[Vivaldo]

Paul gets my vote easily the most fluid out of the lot. Some great players here though!

 

If Kewell was replaced with Barnes, Pique with Hyypia and Toure with Gerrard then boy this team would rock n roll all over the place.

 

PS there is no mention of Juninho in here? Surely he should have been given an opportunity?

[Rafiagra]

Stu's team is head and shoulders above any other.

 

Woo's team is basically a Manc/Cockney XI. I ain't voting for that. Some decent players but not many proven world class.

[Red_or_Dead]

For me it's between Stu (only 2 mancs and ones which pissed pisscan purple nose off) and Dan's (good overall balance) teams.

 

Some of the selections from others are insane - but that's what makes us all different, as you all see different things in players.

 

Surprised there was no Torres (cunt that he is), Berger or Morientes.

[Red_or_Dead]

And, before I vote, Dave you should consider making it a knock-out comp. Cull the lowest three from the vote above, then re-open the poll as a semi-final, then final.

 

Apologies if already suggested, a bit half-cut to check up.

[Iceman]

Voted for Usher. Weah all the way baby.

 

[YOUTUBE]Bs2xEACR9og&feature=related[/YOUTUBE]

[Phoenix]

On an objective level, Alex Woos team for me despite the mancs

 

No weaknesses in any position.

[.G.]

Couldn't pick Dave's cos of Stuart Pearce and no way Agger and Skrtel are the best two players in that position,Woo's team is far too much of a Manc lovefest. Neil's team was good except for the 2 on the right side of defence,good players,the best to have played there? don't think so.None of the other teams really grabbed me so Stu's team for me

[Stu Monty]

Can't believe how many votes Usher is getting with his weak defence and absolutely no width.

[diving headers]

woo wins

[Ronnie Whelan]

Got to be alex woo's team. Too much power and class with Scholes and Keane. Can''t beat that midfield pairing. Zola, Pires and Silva offer so much attacking creativity and it's hard to get a better striker than Van Nistelrooy. Very solid keeper in Seaman marshaling a very solid defence..hate having to vote for a team with Neville in it, but to be fair to him he was a very solid full back.

 

Some great sides and players on the other teams. Great to see guys like McGrath getting a mention. I remember one time when I was working in Birmingham and ending up at a lock in with him on a Friday night with a game at 3 the next day. The guy was out boozing until 7 with us and enjoying the scouse banter about playing with the Mancs and told us to come along and he'd get us into the executive box at Villa Park the next day. We thought he was taking the piss, but went along. Sure enough we were all let in and watched him have Shearer in his pocket. What a gentleman and what a player!!

[cochyn]

Stu & Alex's teams are beautifully balanced. Stu's team edges it for having a magnificent back four and the inclusion of the - sadly forgotten - Mendieta. He was sublime at Valencia and I always hoped he'd rekindle that flame. That front four is the sex.

[Unrighteous]

Neil's team v. Woo's team for me.

 

I went for Neil's.

[magicrat]

Went for Dan on the basis he picked Schmeichel. You can make a case for all the other positions but I reckon he was in a class of his own . Fuck knows how many points he was worth to Utd over the years.

[Dan]

Its Between the Fürher Usher and Mellor for me, daves team slightly edges it on the basis that he picked George weah in his team. Gerrard,macca,drogba and gazza too. Some team that

[Ezekiel 25:17]

Stu banging on about Mendieta but he did next to nothing at Borough, would not even make a premiership top 100.

[Red_or_Dead]

Jesus Christ. I would say how they hell is Alex's team winning, but then again seeing some of the arseholes who seem to hate LFC who post this isn't surprising!

[tcb]

My team of players left over would be

 

Cantona - Klinsmann

 

Kinkladze - G.Silva - Okocha - Kanchelskis

 

Evra - Pallister - Bruce - Salgado

 

Jaaskelainan

 

And for what it's worth I'd fancy my chances against any of the teams above. :)

 

Stunned! Absolutely stunned that You would Bruce (and Pallister) in your team. Remember thinking in the early 90's that the best evidence of how weak the PL was, was that man utd could win the league with that pair. Got shred to bits everytime in the CL

[Baltar]

Alex Woo's team looks the strongest on balance. A strong central midfield, lots of creativity with the 3 players behind RVN, and the horse himself will bang in loads of goals. Very solid and consistent defence too.

[Stu Monty]

Got to be alex woo's team. Too much power and class with Scholes and Keane. Can''t beat that midfield pairing. Zola, Pires and Silva offer so much attacking creativity and it's hard to get a better striker than Van Nistelrooy. Very solid keeper in Seaman marshaling a very solid defence..hate having to vote for a team with Neville in it, but to be fair to him he was a very solid full back.

 

Some great sides and players on the other teams. Great to see guys like McGrath getting a mention. I remember one time when I was working in Birmingham and ending up at a lock in with him on a Friday night with a game at 3 the next day. The guy was out boozing until 7 with us and enjoying the scouse banter about playing with the Mancs and told us to come along and he'd get us into the executive box at Villa Park the next day. We thought he was taking the piss, but went along. Sure enough we were all let in and watched him have Shearer in his pocket. What a gentleman and what a player!!

 

The idea that his front four comes anywhere near my front four is one that you should be comitted for putting down here. Ronaldo. Barnes. Shevchenko. Litmanen. Soak that shit in baby!

 

Far too much mentalism going on here.