Does Rodgers deserve another season.

[Dicko]

Its all about opinions.

 

Rafa > Rodgers..... and its not even close.

Anyone that argues otherwise is silly

[Pureblood]

In terms of record yeah there is no argument but it would end badly. 

 

It would probably start pretty badly, too.  The middle bit might be okay?

[BCM]

In terms of record yeah there is no argument but it would end badly. 

 

Why would it. Geniune question.

 

If he wins the Europa League this year. He has consistently shown he can win silverware no matter where he goes. No matter which Chairman he works under.

 

Im pretty sure he's experienced enough to work under any structure FSG see fit.

Im not sure Ian Ayre would survive, but then don't we all think he should be demoted anyway.

[Nightcat]

Major Cunt is right, let it go. Prepare for a few more marque signings from Southampton and Swansea, as well as a JWH transfer window letter from his boat somewhere out in the ocean.

[zigackly]

90% of the respondents on that telegraph poll are blaming the manager to some degree despite Rodgers' party line Bascombe's opinion. 

 

There may be trouble ahead.

[Major Tom]

Im pretty sure he's experienced enough to work under any structure FSG see fit.

.

Yeah.

 

He doesn't have a long history of taking on owners when he doesn't get his way. Not at all.

 

Rafa isn't the answer. And, if he is, the question is wrong.

[Lario]

Right so.

 

182 pages. Does he deserve another season?

[Brownie]

90% of the respondents on that telegraph poll are blaming the manager to some degree despite Rodgers' party line Bascombe's opinion.

 

There may be trouble ahead.

Hang on, are you suggesting that it's not actually Chris' opinion?

[zigackly]

Hang on, are you suggesting that it's not actually Chris' opinion?

 

I was having a mild joke at the expense of some of the replies in the thread Brownie, I always look forward to his articles as it happens.

[RobbieOR]

Why would it. Geniune question.

 

If he wins the Europa League this year. He has consistently shown he can win silverware no matter where he goes. No matter which Chairman he works under.

 

Im pretty sure he's experienced enough to work under any structure FSG see fit.

Im not sure Ian Ayre would survive, but then don't we all think he should be demoted anyway.

 

Because I don't see how he's going topple four clubs that have infinite resources when he can't do it in a league where there is only one team. 

[JermainePennant]

Well apparently if a manager has won trophies and is available it will be criminal not to at least sound said candidate out to see if they're up for it. What are we waiting for?

If we have to sack a manager when a manager with a better cv is available then indeed Rafas name should be right at the very top of the list out of those available.

 

In those circumstances the next manager is not important for the long term future anyway as when Abramovich gets fed up of Joses football and sacks him in a couple of years we will surely be getting rid of our current manager and getting him in.

 

For those of you who are saying it would be unlikely Jose has said he will not leave the prem after Chelsea, considering Manu, arsenal or city wouldn't have him due to his football I'd say it would be between us and Spurs.

 

If it's an unmissable chance now with Klopp then it certainly will be when Jose becomes available.

[Jairzinho]

Why would it. Geniune question.

 

If he wins the Europa League this year. He has consistently shown he can win silverware no matter where he goes. No matter which Chairman he works under.

 

Im pretty sure he's experienced enough to work under any structure FSG see fit.

Im not sure Ian Ayre would survive, but then don't we all think he should be demoted anyway.

 

Never go back.

 

It would split the fanbase.

 

He's had his time.

 

Football is a game of two halves.

 

Life is like a box of chocolates.

[Dr Nowt]

I don't do requests. 

 

It's almost like you're frozen in time with the Rafa thing.

[Brownie]

I was having a mild joke at the expense of some of the replies in the thread Brownie, I always look forward to his articles as it happens.

Haha okay mate.

 

Work on the routine, yeah?

 

;-)

[zigackly]

I do still have a soft spot for Rafa despite thinking his time was up when it was, and I do think he's a better football manager than Rodgers by a long chalk, but you only have to look at this forum to see why it would be an extremely divisive move to get him back. Better to open a clean page.

[Pureblood]

You didn't say that when Kenny came back for a second spell.  

[zigackly]

You didn't say that when Kenny came back for a second spell.  

 

No I didn't because I didn't think half the support would be gunning for him at the first mistake. I'll also happily admit my heart overruled my head on that occasion.

[Lario]

Because I don't see how he's going topple four clubs that have infinite resources when he can't do it in a league where there is only one team.

 

Ah come on Robbie. What manager has a chance if that's the case?

 

Do you honestly think the man that brought Alonso, Torres, Mascherano, etc to the club, as well as getting the very best out of Gerrard, wouldn't be able to do it again?

 

Take names out of it and look at the stats of both managers. There really shouldn't be an argument.

[Pureblood]

I wonder what would happen if, say, Rodgers went to Spurs and they won the league.  Stranger things have happened (not many, admittedly).  Would people then want him back or is he in the forbidden bin with Rafa?

 

Shit, let it go.  

[Lario]

No I didn't because I didn't think half the support would be gunning for him at the first mistake. I'll also happily admit my heart overruled my head on that occasion.

Well then half the support would be acting like cunts.

[zigackly]

Well then half the support would be acting like cunts.

 

So what's new.

[Major Tom]

Ah come on Robbie. What manager has a chance if that's the case?

Do you honestly think the man that brought Alonso, Torres, Mascherano, etc to the club, as well as getting the very best out of Gerrard, wouldn't be able to do it again?

.

Do what again? Win the CL? No chance.

[Pureblood]

No I didn't because I didn't think half the support would be gunning for him at the first mistake. I'll also happily admit my heart overruled my head on that occasion.

 

One Andy Carroll later and he's history. 

[zigackly]

One Andy Carroll later and he's history. 

 

Yep, them's the rules.

[Lario]

Do what again? Win the CL? No chance.

No. Topple 4 clubs that have infinite resources.