who would suit our team more keane or villa

[spider-neil]

without it turning into a popularity contest who would improve our team and current formation more?

[Woo]

Well Villa is a better player.

 

Keane is proven in the Premiership.

 

For me I think Villa would suit the team more than Keane.

[Section_31]

Villa, people can discuss tactics and formations all they want, but you just can't turn you nose up at that level of sheer quality.

[spider-neil]

villa.

I think he movement and pace would aid us more

[dirty_sanchez]

In terms of style of play I don't think Villa and Keane are that dissimilar, it's just that Villa is better.

[spider-neil]

we also have a great set piece taker in villa

[El Rojo]

Villa is a superior player, but either would improve us considerably.

[Guest TK-421]

Sorry Neil but this is one private poll too many, a man of your poll making experience ought to know better by now. I have imparted negative reputation.

 

I would go with David Villa, I'm not sure he would work better in our system than Robbie Keane but I think he's a better player so I'd rather we signed him. I think he'd work well either side of Torres as he is strong with both feet.

[Woo]

Weres the Gulliermo De Maria El Silva Marco Militio Benzemaresma option for Xabi D?

[Guest PaddyBerger15]

Weres the Gulliermo De Maria El Silva Marco Militio Benzemaresma option for Xabi D?

 

I think thats the 'meh' option.

[Ian Sea]

Tough one, but Keane for me. I just think he would be the perfect partner for Torres and they would both bring the best out of each other wereas Villa and Torres don't. They are both class players so they would both score goals, but I don't think they reach their full potential individually playing as a front two.

[DUFF]

Keane

[Paul]

To be honest I think it's over-complicating things discussing whether or not so-and-so would fit our system. The best players - Torres, Gerrard, Carragher, etc - are able to adapt to the needs of the team and still excel. I think both Keane and Villa are top quality and either would adapt. However, as Villa is the better player in my opinion, I'd take him.

[spider-neil]

Sorry Neil but this is one private poll too many, a man of your poll making experience ought to know better by now. I have imparted negative reputation.

 

I would go with David Villa, I'm not sure he would work better in our system than Robbie Keane but I think he's a better player so I'd rather we signed him. I think he'd work well either side of Torres as he is strong with both feet.

 

I don't know how to make a private poll.

please post instructions.

[Guest TK-421]

I don't know how to make a private poll.

please post instructions.

 

There's a check box at the bottom of the Poll page which gives you the option of making it private or public.

[robbief]

rediculous idea. how on earth can fucking keane compare to villa?

[Woo]

Because they are both consistently 20 goal a season strikers.

[spider-neil]

There's a check box at the bottom of the Poll page which gives you the option of making it private or public.

 

what's the difference?

[Thants]

Either.

[Section_31]

To be honest I think it's over-complicating things discussing whether or not so-and-so would fit our system. The best players - Torres, Gerrard, Carragher, etc - are able to adapt to the needs of the team and still excel. I think both Keane and Villa are top quality and either would adapt. However, as Villa is the better player in my opinion, I'd take him.

 

Spot on that, it's not like we're wighing up right backs vs centre mids, you're talking about two strikers. One is good, the other is potentially great - AND already has an understanding with our best attacker.

[Spy Bee]

Keane

[Guest TK-421]

what's the difference?

 

Is that a trick question?

 

You can see who's voted for which option on the public one. When it's private you tend to get a lot of posts like "I voted Keane".

[spider-neil]

Is that a trick question?

 

You can see who's voted for which option on the public one. When it's private you tend to get a lot of posts like "I voted Keane".

 

I mean when its a private poll who see the poll and who doesn't.

[spider-neil]

Is that a trick question?

 

You can see who's voted for which option on the public one. When it's private you tend to get a lot of posts like "I voted Keane".

 

so why would you want the poll to be private the public one sounds better.

[Unrighteous]

Similar players but Villa has more skill.