Should it be captains only?

[Lofts]

The events of the last seven days have stirred the debate as to whether talking to officials should be restricted to captains.

 

Javier Mascherano's dismissal against Man Utd for alleged dissent followed angry scenes at White Hart Lane last week involving Ashley Cole and a number of other Chelsea players.

 

Now some are calling for a 'captains only' rule to be introduced – but what do you think?

[dave u]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

[Cardie]

If we start taking on the ideas of Rugby then we should also be able to punch, bite, stamp and gouge the cunt Ronaldo without punishment.

[wiiksie]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

:D funny and true, all rolled into one.

[Spy Bee]

Did you notice Gerrard tell the ref "You're taking the fucking piss!" and still nto get booked. Consistency is what is needed.

[ottawa_lfc]

Now some are calling for a 'captains only' rule to be introduced – but what do you think?

 

I've no problem with that, but it has to be properly explained and introduced - making a unilateral decision like that cock Bennett did is unacceptable. He's been on a major Liverpool downer ever since he was punching the air when he allowed an advantage for us (against Leeds, years back, I think). It's as if he has a point to prove.

 

In fact, I haven't got a problem with players being shown a red for telling the ref to fuck off. But it has to be consistently applied and include everyone - not just us.

[Rashid]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

 

Correct - and that man for me is Mascherano.

[Uncle Travelling Matt]

It should be Captains only and the respect for refs should be the same as in Rugby, personally I think there is no point at all in arguing a decision but until they bring those rules in for everyone, the refs can't make them up as and when they feel fit.

[Juan Galonso]

Now some are calling for a 'captains only' rule to be introduced – but what do you think?

 

I've no problem with that, but it has to be properly explained and introduced - making a unilateral decision like that cock Bennett did is unacceptable. He's been on a major Liverpool downer ever since he was punching the air when he allowed an advantage for us (against Leeds, years back, I think). It's as if he has a point to prove.

 

In fact, I haven't got a problem with players being shown a red for telling the ref to fuck off. But it has to be consistently applied and include everyone - not just us.

 

I don't mean to come across as a know all but that was Mike Reed who punched the air v Leeds. Sorry.

[JohnnyH]

As has been said. If this happens then Gerrard would be of no use. I'm not just saying this on the back of some other threads, but Carra would be the man for that job.

[G Richards]

I'd like to see this come in. We all want consistency, but when 22 players can have their say, consistency will be elusive. I don't think for one minute we'll see an end to refereeing mistakes, but it will hopefully enable better communication on the pitch, as the ref will only be dealing with two players on that score.

 

I'd also like to see punishment come in for managers who comment about referees in public in the days leading up to the game. If managers have anything to say it should be done privately and through the right channels. Commenting in the media only adds to the vast pressure that is already on referees.

[Lofts]

I'd like to see this come in. We all want consistency, but when 22 players can have their say, consistency will be elusive. I don't think for one minute we'll see an end to refereeing mistakes, but it will hopefully enable better communication on the pitch, as the ref will only be dealing with two players on that score.

 

I'd also like to see punishment come in for managers who comment about referees in public in the days leading up to the game. If managers have anything to say it should be done privately and through the right channels. Commenting in the media only adds to the vast pressure that is already on referees.

 

totally agree with this, mouriho was very good at this aswell, doesnt help the refs one bit and can make the difference in big games

[Lapskaus]

Correct - and that man for me is Mascherano.

 

yes because he has respect among the corrupt referees right? He got booked for mouthing off against the scum last year also you know. And he also speaks proper English?

 

Masch is ace, but having him speak to the ref would only harm us

[zigackly]

Captains only is a bollocks rule. If any change is needed then make it that only one player from a team is allowed to approach the ref at one time.

[ashfire]

we already have one thread about who it should be etc, please dont turn this into another......

[ottawa_lfc]

I've no problem with that, but it has to be properly explained and introduced - making a unilateral decision like that cock Bennett did is unacceptable. He's been on a major Liverpool downer ever since he was punching the air when he allowed an advantage for us (against Leeds, years back, I think). It's as if he has a point to prove.

 

In fact, I haven't got a problem with players being shown a red for telling the ref to fuck off. But it has to be consistently applied and include everyone - not just us.

 

I don't mean to come across as a know all but that was Mike Reed who punched the air v Leeds. Sorry.

 

Bollocks. They all look the same to me.

[Trucker Paddy]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

 

Agree 100%

[Newport]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

 

True. And I nominate Xabi Alonso. He's a true gentleman who doesn't go off at the refs in a maner that can get him in trouble. He's also a hard working professional who always is a good example to follow for other players.

[Cunny]

If it is introduced then we need a new captain.

 

never a truer word written

[Hermes]

No player should be allowed to question the referees decision. I've never known one to change his decision so what's the point in questioning it? The referee should make the decision and state what the decision was based on - "hand ball...offside...shirt pulling etc", maybe over a PA system to let the crowd know.

 

Then they all get on with the game.

[Dicko]

If we start taking on the ideas of Rugby then we should also be able to punch, bite, stamp and gouge the cunt Ronaldo without punishment.

Spot on in the sense that I'm fucking sick of this fucking love in with Rugby Union. RU players are more disciplined. Are they fuck that whole fucking sport is one of the most snidiest ill disciplined fucking shite I've ever had the misfortune to be involved in, what they don't take out on the ref they take out on each other.

 

The two New Zealand thugs including the captain almost killed Brian O'Driscoll and the ref lets them get away with it and the authorities let them off with a fine fucking despicable.