I don’t think there is a right or wrong answer on Robbo or Tsmiskas.
Robbo is the better player, IMO, his race is run, unfortunately. Tsmiskas has been the better player this season, he won’t ever be good enough long term.
However, as others have said, Robbo is part of the leadership group. As it looks like only Trent is leaving from that group now, is it really that detrimental?
Both seem popular players.
Neither are classed as home grown.
I think Robbo will do all in his power to win his place back, would push whoever the new left back is and make him earn his starting spot. I think Tsmiskas would be happy to remain 2nd place, again.
If either are only being kept for another season, would we risk Robbo’s legs completely going?