Quantcast
Report: Ranking the best and worst Liverpool signings of the decade. - Page 3 - FF - Football Forum - The Liverpool Way Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
TLW

Report: Ranking the best and worst Liverpool signings of the decade.

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, Aventus said:

I think Henderson deserves to be in the conversation... 

 

He's been a Liverpool player for most of the decade, longer than anybody else currently with us. We've got the most mileage out of his signing. 

 

He's the only one who will remember what it was like during the dark times under Hodgson.

 

Before this summer was the only current player to have actually won a medal at the club.

 

Took massive amounts of stick from the media and our own fans, Rogers tried to fuck him off to Fulham, but he had the determination to stick with us to prove he belonged here.

 

And of course from his humble beginnings grew to become our European Cup winning captain. 

So...

 

Worst or best?

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Aventus said:

I think Henderson deserves to be in the conversation... 

 

He's been a Liverpool player for most of the decade, longer than anybody else currently with us. We've got the most mileage out of his signing. 

 

He's the only one who will remember what it was like during the dark times under Hodgson.

 

Before this summer was the only current player to have actually won a medal at the club.

 

Took massive amounts of stick from the media and our own fans, Rogers tried to fuck him off to Fulham, but he had the determination to stick with us to prove he belonged here.

 

And of course from his humble beginnings grew to become our European Cup winning captain. 

I assume you mean one of our best?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see the arguments for Benteke and Carroll, but at least they tried on the pitch, and in their own limited way they occasionally had some effect on games.

Balotelli however was as predictable as night following day.  I remember laughing when I heard the rumours because I knew that no Liverpool manager in his right mind would even contemplate Balotelli.  Then the total shock that we had parted with £16 million to sign the stupid cunt.  He had all the talent in the world, just absolutely fuck all between the ears.  We got important goals plus money back at least out of Carroll and Benteke, Balotelli slunk out the door for fuck all.  We couldn't even give the cunt away.

However many other players mentioned here that just weren't the calibre that this club requires, Balotelli was the one that had fans shaking their head in disbelief.  He even under achieved on zero expectations, the total fucking twat.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, scudger99 said:

I see the arguments for Benteke and Carroll, but at least they tried on the pitch, and in their own limited way they occasionally had some effect on games.

Balotelli however was as predictable as night following day.  I remember laughing when I heard the rumours because I knew that no Liverpool manager in his right mind would even contemplate Balotelli.  Then the total shock that we had parted with £16 million to sign the stupid cunt.  He had all the talent in the world, just absolutely fuck all between the ears.  We got important goals plus money back at least out of Carroll and Benteke, Balotelli slunk out the door for fuck all.  We couldn't even give the cunt away.

However many other players mentioned here that just weren't the calibre that this club requires, Balotelli was the one that had fans shaking their head in disbelief.  He even under achieved on zero expectations, the total fucking twat.

 

He was also probably the worst fit. So much of the good stuff we'd done in the previous years was due to Suarez's workrate and speed of thought. To replace him with someone who is lazy and mentally 10 minutes behind the play was not a recipe for success.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sturridge until Summer 2014 looked like one of of the best signings.

 

I wouldn't necessarily agree, but I'm sure there's a few here who would count the post-2014 wage-sapping permacrock among the worst.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Captain Turdseye said:

One of the worst bits of business was selling Dirk Kuyt for £1m

Yep. Still had at least a year in him here. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Luis Alberto was an awful sale. Surely we could have given him games after 13/14 but we just sent him on loan, sold him for peanuts and now he's quite good/worth a lot of money.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 hours ago, VERBAL DIARRHEA said:

Best for the money VVD

Best for the resale Coutinho

Best for value Robertson.

 

Worst for the money Aqualani

Worst for the resale Markovic

Worst for value Carroll

Carroll scored the winner against Everton in an FA Cup semi at Wembley and also scored in the final (with goal-line technology he may have scored two and been the hero). He wasn't a good signing by any means, but in terms of value he gave us a lot more than the dozens of other flops I could name.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, dave u said:

Carroll scored the winner against Everton in an FA Cup semi at Wembley and also scored in the final (with goal-line technology he may have scored two and been the hero). He wasn't a good signing by any means, but in terms of value he gave us a lot more than the dozens of other flops I could name.

Opinions eh Dave. He was unlucky in the final. Not meant to be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
56 minutes ago, 3 Stacks said:

Luis Alberto was an awful sale. Surely we could have given him games after 13/14 but we just sent him on loan, sold him for peanuts and now he's quite good/worth a lot of money.

See also, Suso. 

 

And no no cunt can mention Aspas. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Daisy said:

Not having Suso and Alberto. Italian league is where they both belong.

Suso was given a decent go and wanted to leave anyway. There's not much more that could have been done with him.

 

But Alberto could have at least been given a chance. We were terrible the year after our title challenge, it's not like we had many obviously better players than him.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 minutes ago, 3 Stacks said:

Suso was given a decent go and wanted to leave anyway. There's not much more that could have been done with him.

 

But Alberto could have at least been given a chance. We were terrible the year after our title challenge, it's not like we had many obviously better players than him.

 

 

We had quite a lot of slow average players like him

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Available Subscriptions

  • Last Match Report

  • Latest Posts

    • What? What the fuck is this clown talking about in the Guardian comments section on Ronay’s Silva dissection? They love to give themselves more relevance than they have,  
       
    • It's great news that we have two players fit and raring to go. 
    • A bullish Xherdan Shaqiri has said that he is ready for more game time after his star showing against Everton in the Reds 5-2 victory on Wednesday evening.

      The Swiss star was a surprise selection in the starting lineup especially when you take into account that he had not started a league game since the end of January and his last start in all competitions came on that memorable night on the 7th of May against Barcelona.

      Before Wednesday night, Shaqiri played a grand total of 25 minutes in all competitions with his longest run-out coming in the Community Shield against Man City.

      A long running battle with a calf injury has been the main reason for his lack of regular first-team action during this campaign, but after scoring his first goal in nearly a year and displaying his sublime skill, Shaq has made it known to all concerned including his manager that he is well and truly back.

      The Echo reported the popular utility player as saying:

      “ I’m ready, I think the coach saw that too in training,"

      "I trained very well and today he gave me the chance and I think I played very well.

      “ At the end of the day it’s important to win games with my team, we won it as a team, and obviously when I can contribute it’s always good. 

      “Let’s hope for more games!"
        Shaqiri said despite the lack of minutes, rust was never a issue and he felt at home on the pitch.  

      “ You know me and how I play, so it’s nothing new!

      “I’m an instinctive footballer, so I like to play good football if I feel good. I felt good so I tried some things and it went well.

      “ I was very happy to score after a long time. It was a good feeling."

      While the injury was undoubtedly a frustrating time for the 28 year-old, he counted his blessings that it was not something more serious like a ligament injury.

      “ I’ve been injured [but] thank God I don’t have knee problems or something. I had some muscle problems so I just needed a few weeks to recover well.

      “The calf is very dangerous to get another injury and I had this so obviously it was not nice but I stayed positive and tried to come back. 

      “I worked very hard in the gym and with the fitness coaches to come back and be ready when the coach needs me. I’m feeling good."

      Shaqiri was a player that Jürgen Klopp turned to around this time last season and he certainly did not let his manager down turning in some special performances against Man United and Arsenal in particular.

      He is well aware of the jam packed fixture list during this month and says it is great to be option for his manager again.

      "Everybody knows that it’s a busy period now with a lot of games coming up, [so] I’m very happy to be back. I’m feeling fresh, feeling good, and I think you saw that.

      “We know each other very well, we train every day together, the team stays like last season even when the coach makes some changes - five changes, I think.

      “He changed the formation a little bit so it was not simple but we managed that very well today against a good side.

      . [It’s] a derby obviously so we wanted to keep the city red, so it was a very important win.
       
      View full article
    • A bullish Xherdan Shaqiri has said that he is ready for more game time after his star showing against Everton in the Reds 5-2 victory on Wednesday evening.

      The Swiss star was a surprise selection in the starting lineup especially when you take into account that he had not started a league game since the end of January and his last start in all competitions came on that memorable night on the 7th of May against Barcelona.

      Before Wednesday night, Shaqiri played a grand total of 25 minutes in all competitions with his longest run-out coming in the Community Shield against Man City.

      A long running battle with a calf injury has been the main reason for his lack of regular first-team action during this campaign, but after scoring his first goal in nearly a year and displaying his sublime skill, Shaq has made it known to all concerned including his manager that he is well and truly back.

      The Echo reported the popular utility player as saying:

      “ I’m ready, I think the coach saw that too in training,"

      "I trained very well and today he gave me the chance and I think I played very well.

      “ At the end of the day it’s important to win games with my team, we won it as a team, and obviously when I can contribute it’s always good. 

      “Let’s hope for more games!"
        Shaqiri said despite the lack of minutes, rust was never a issue and he felt at home on the pitch.  

      “ You know me and how I play, so it’s nothing new!

      “I’m an instinctive footballer, so I like to play good football if I feel good. I felt good so I tried some things and it went well.

      “ I was very happy to score after a long time. It was a good feeling."

      While the injury was undoubtedly a frustrating time for the 28 year-old, he counted his blessings that it was not something more serious like a ligament injury.

      “ I’ve been injured [but] thank God I don’t have knee problems or something. I had some muscle problems so I just needed a few weeks to recover well.

      “The calf is very dangerous to get another injury and I had this so obviously it was not nice but I stayed positive and tried to come back. 

      “I worked very hard in the gym and with the fitness coaches to come back and be ready when the coach needs me. I’m feeling good."

      Shaqiri was a player that Jürgen Klopp turned to around this time last season and he certainly did not let his manager down turning in some special performances against Man United and Arsenal in particular.

      He is well aware of the jam packed fixture list during this month and says it is great to be option for his manager again.

      "Everybody knows that it’s a busy period now with a lot of games coming up, [so] I’m very happy to be back. I’m feeling fresh, feeling good, and I think you saw that.

      “We know each other very well, we train every day together, the team stays like last season even when the coach makes some changes - five changes, I think.

      “He changed the formation a little bit so it was not simple but we managed that very well today against a good side.

      . [It’s] a derby obviously so we wanted to keep the city red, so it was a very important win.
       
      View full article
  • Latest Round Up

  • Popular Contributors

×