Rob Jones

[Fowler1972]

I was just having a discussion with myself over a coffee and ginger snap so thought I’d check in with you good people to settle a difference of opinion.

 

Rob Jones would make my all time Liverpool XI all day long v Poppycock, it’s obviously Phil Neal.

 

I’m old enough to have seen Phil Neal but couldn’t add anyone before him to the debate. How good was Chris Lawler? Steve Nicol was just too good in other positions, Marcus Babel didn’t play long enough. Carragher was better as a CB and Steve Finnan was just not quite at their level.

 

Who’s right! Me or Me?

[Barnesey]

In 3 years time you will settle for TAA

[dockers_strike]

I was just having a discussion with myself over a coffee and ginger snap so thought I’d check in with you good people to settle a difference of opinion.

 

Rob Jones would make my all time Liverpool XI all day long v Poppycock, it’s obviously Phil Neal.

 

I’m old enough to have seen Phil Neal but couldn’t add anyone before him to the debate. How good was Chris Lawler? Steve Nicol was just too good in other positions, Marcus Babel didn’t play long enough. Carragher was better as a CB and Steve Finnan was just not quite at their level.

 

Who’s right! Me or Me?

 

Chris Lawler was great. I think Neal eventually overtook him as the best scoring fullback although Chris did not take pens. I do not generally compare players from one era against another. They were great in their time and that is all you can ask.

[Fowler1972]

Chris Lawler was great. I think Neal eventually overtook him as the best scoring fullback although Chris did not take pens. I do not generally compare players from one era against another. They were great in their time and that is all you can ask.

You don’t do comparisons, even over a ginger snap! What do you talk to yourself about?

[dockers_strike]

You don’t do comparisons, even over a ginger snap! What do you talk to yourself about?

 

Life in the Galaxy or Universe usually.

[Dr Nowt]

Life in the Galaxy or Universe usually.

 

Have you ever met Ronnie Moran, d_s?

[dockers_strike]

Have you ever met Ronnie Moran, d_s?

 

Strange question. No I did not have that pleasure. Did you.

[Josef Svejk]

I'd move Konchesky over to the right to accommodate Dicks on the left of my all-time Liverpool eleven...

[magicrat]

I'd move Konchesky over to the right to accommodate Dicks on the left of my all-time Liverpool eleven...

 

No room for Babb ?

[VladimirIlyich]

No room for Babb ?

No,Ruddock every time.

[neopulian]

No room for Babb ?

 

He nailed down that central back spot, silly. Also closer to the goal post. 

[sir roger]

Chris Lawler was a lovely guy, an excellent player and one of the earliest full backs to add an attacking element to their game , but I don't feel he was at Phil Neal's level. Rob Jones could possibly have proved better but for all of the injuries he was plagued with.

 

Neal for me.

 

( Talking about constantly-injured full backs , I really liked Veggie Heggem )

[ZonkoVille77]

Me or me.

The narcissism is strong in this one.

[Guest]

There's only two Fowler1972s.

[scudger99]

You don’t do comparisons, even over a ginger snap! What do you talk to yourself about?

Blogging ?

[magicrat]

No,Ruddock every time.

good call

[Remmie]

Best ever Liverpool player that has played at right back? Steven Gerrard

[VladimirIlyich]

Best ever Liverpool player that has played at right back? Steven Gerrard

Stevie Nicol has every right to dispute this.