Where are you now?

[PadreDougal]

there's fuck all wrong with garcia - given me some brilliant moments watching the reds not least his fucking screamer against chelsea - people are too quick to jump on his back (especially round me) when he gives a stray pass which does happen from time to time but u can't doubt the quality of the man! he's a quality finisher and does a better job than kewell even in his one season when he stayed fit!

[Rashid]

Also the best header of the ball at the club!

[Stu Monty]

Also the best header of the ball at the club!

 

No he's not. He's good in the air though; especially for a little dude.

[Sangria]

No he's not. He's good in the air though; especially for a little dude.

 

Who would you say is Stu. For the size of him he gets up very well, not saying he is the best but I am thinking myself who is.

Kuyt looks a possibility and Fowler aint bad.

Big Sami ?

[Stu Monty]

For me it would be Sami and Gerrard at the top of the list. Watch the hangtime that Hyypia gets sometimes, that's technique is that.

[Hermes]

The most erratic player I've ever seen in an LFC shirt. Capable of great goals but gives the ball away too much and commits more fouls than any other LFC player.

 

His inconsistencies mean he will never be considered as a first choice, but would be brought on in desperate situations in the hope that he produces something special.

[Sangria]

I would agree on Sami. He has the hieght but he also has the technique to go with it.

[Sangria]

I do not think there is another player that splits the fans as much.

Was he a good or bad signing. Was he value for money.

 

I would say he was a good signing - not a fantastic one but a good one.

So the first for me answers the second. He has scored some truly vital goals and more than proved his worth.

[zigackly]

28 goals in 108 appearances.

[CWD82]

28 goals in 108 appearances.

How many starts?

 

Although in Luis' case that shouldn't really be a factor, he plays better coming off the bench generally

[zigackly]

How many starts?

 

Although in Luis' case that shouldn't really be a factor, he plays better coming off the bench generally

 

Dunno how many starts but it's a good rate for a midfielder however you slice it.

[Monkeywool]

I love li'l Luis me.

 

Fact is everyone gives the ball away at some point, you just notice it more with Garcia because he does it when trying off something tricky instead of a standard pass that happens when Alonso gives the ball away. Alonso by the way has probably given away more ball than Luis but he has full backing of the fans and no divide.Yes Luis is a luxury player, yes sometimes you want him to do the simple thing instead of the magical, but thats the way he is. When the magical pays off it's outstanding though and I for one would love to keep him in the team just for that.