Picking a team like at school

[Remmie]

If the Liverpool 1st XI was a class at school and they had captains, who would they pick in what order (not including keepers) i.e.

 

Team A

Gerrard, Finnan, Morientes, Sami & Sissoko

 

Vs

 

Team B

Carragher, Alonso, Riise, Cisse & Garcia

 

The idea is who are our best players and what order are they in?

 

Top 3 is easy

Carra

Gerrard

Xabi

 

but who after that?

[Beni]

Doh,

[Ronnie Whelan]

If the Liverpool 1st XI was a class at school and they had captains, who would they pick in what order (not including keepers) i.e.

 

Team A

Gerrard, Finnan, Morientes, Sami & Sissoko

 

Vs

 

Team B

Carragher, Alonso, Riise, Cisse & Garcia

 

The idea is who are our best players and what order are they in?

 

Top 3 is easy

Carra

Gerrard

Xabi

 

but who after that?

 

I'd go for Carra,Gerrard and Xabi straight off.Cisse would be a definite too.He'd be a right legend in a schoolyard.Maybe Stevie F because Xabi and Gerrard would get forward enough to support Djibbers.

[redrosetints]

If the Liverpool 1st XI was a class at school and they had captains, who would they pick in what order (not including keepers) i.e.

 

Team A

Gerrard, Finnan, Morientes, Sami & Sissoko

 

Vs

 

Team B

Carragher, Alonso, Riise, Cisse & Garcia

 

The idea is who are our best players and what order are they in?

 

Top 3 is easy

Carra

Gerrard

Xabi

 

but who after that?

 

intersting question Remmie, and i dont know the answer, but to flip it over, who would be the poor runt who cant play who'd be picked last do you reckon ? (You know there was always one or two who'd be left over noone wanted) Kewell cos noone likes him ? or would he be picked 'cos he can play' to leave ..... as the last one. Who would that be ? I suppose f it was for spazzyness, which i=t often is at School it would be and finally, i'll HAVE to have Peter then...

[xabi the red]

If Josemi's left standing by the wall, one team would rather play with a man down

[redrosetints]

If Josemi's left standing by the wall, one team would rather play with a man down

 

Ah Thanks Xabi, thats the one, exactly what i was looking for. He'd only get picked if he'd agree to play in goal AND get the ball when it got kicked miles away. :yes:

[Remmie]

I reckon 2 random forumites, I don't know say Rashid and Hermes(!) are captains and get to pick a five-a-side team and then do a poll on who's team is better. Whoever picks 2nd gets to pick 2 i.e. if rash gets first pick and goes for, I don't know - Gerrard then Hermes gets 2 picks, then back to 1 each. At leasty that's how I used to pick teams to make them fair

[xabi the red]

Ah Thanks Xabi, thats the one, exactly what i was looking for. He'd only get picked if he'd agree to play in goal AND get the ball when it got kicked miles away. :yes:

 

and you know cisse would be up for giving him a wedgie at any opportunity.

[Remmie]

I'm a mother bumper

[Stephen Adams.]

Would Robbie have to stand in the corner with the teacher askin if he can play?

[Chocoholic]

Robbie would be one of the lads picking a team!

[kop]

Robbie would stand in a corner with a smug smile saying fuck this, I'm calling Didi and take Dirk and him out for a pint.

[Stu Monty]

I reckon 2 random forumites, I don't know say Rashid and Hermes(!) are captains and get to pick a five-a-side team and then do a poll on who's team is better. Whoever picks 2nd gets to pick 2 i.e. if rash gets first pick and goes for, I don't know - Gerrard then Hermes gets 2 picks, then back to 1 each. At leasty that's how I used to pick teams to make them fair

 

What? Mentalism.

 

You go like this: 1 pick, 2 picks, 2 picks, 2 picks, 2 picks.....etc

 

It's the only way man.