David Ngog

[SpeedyG]

Why is so much favouritism shown towards nemeth? If he has a stinker is he going to be one of those players that is exempt from criticism?

 

People want to give youth a chance but only the ones they have as a favourite or have decided are good enough. I find it strange.

 

I would start Voronin ahead of both of them as they are both raw and shouldn't really be used in a title run in imo especially as some fans want rafa's head if we come up short.

 

Because last season in the reserves, most of which was shown on lfc.tv, he was phenomenal. We wouldn't have won the league without him, our winning streak basically began when he came back from injury.

[silverlining]

Kid looks good. Just a younger, faster, technically superior version of Crouchy. Helps that you can pick him out amongst other players.

 

There are 22 words in the above post, and every single one of them is wrong.

[INTORRESTING]

Nemeth was fantastic but he is not available and has been injured before.

 

N'gog has been doing well in the reserves and provides another option.

 

I personally think we need to give them both a chance and i don't see how one hinders the other.

[hamstrung]

Nemeth doesn't play deeper really. He's a poacher essentially - at his best in the box.

 

Nor, 1 game aside when he scored a couple, has N'Gog looked good in the reserves. He's looked equally average at that level too.

[SpeedyG]

Nemeth doesn't play deeper particularly. He's a poacher essentially - at his best in the box.

 

Well in just about all the games I've seen in the reserves he's clearly played behind for example Brouwer. Yes, he is at his best in the box, but he has scored plenty from outside Everton, the one in the play-off game etc. He is definitely more than just a poacher and he definitely does not lead the line like N'Gog he's just not that type of player.

[Malarkey]

Focus on these words.

 

I HAVEN'T SAID HE IS GOOD ENOUGH. I HAVE SAID 3 STARTS IS NOT ENOUGH TIME TO JUDGE.

 

Stop it, you're killing me.

[ScottyT]

Well in just about all the games I've seen in the reserves he's clearly played behind for example Brouwer. Yes, he is at his best in the box, but he has scored plenty from outside Everton, the one in the play-off game etc. He is definitely more than just a poacher and he definitely does not lead the line like N'Gog he's just not that type of player.

 

He's a lead the line striker.

[hamstrung]

He's not the same as N'Gog because he's not playing with his back to goal - he's more likely to run onto the through balls. Additionally, he seems to have ability, which also sets him apart.

 

He doesn't play the Gerrard position though. He's more like someone like Owen.

[SpeedyG]

He's not the same as N'Gog in that he doesn't play with his back to goal.

 

He doesn't play the Gerrard position though. He's more like someone like Owen.

 

Let's put it another way, he's like Dalglish.

[hamstrung]

Compared to N'Gog, he might as well be. Not sure what the makes N'Gog. Sean Dundee maybe.

[SpeedyG]

Compared to N'Gog, he might as well be. Not sure what the makes N'Gog. Sean Dundee maybe.

 

Which was my point. He's not competing with N'Gog.

[hamstrung]

Which was my point. He's not competing with N'Gog.

 

Yes he is. Your point is wrong.

 

If/when Nemeth plays it won't be in Gerrard's position.

[SpeedyG]

Yes he is. Your point is wrong.

 

If/when Nemeth plays it won't be in Gerrard's position.

 

Either you are trying to play semantics (in terms of imprecise parallels) or you are suggesting that Nemeth will lead the line. Which is it?

[hamstrung]

Either you are trying to play semantics (in terms of imprecise parallels) or you are suggesting that Nemeth will lead the line. Which is it?

 

I can't be arsed anymore. Think what you like.

[05 Milan]

Pointless, stupid signing.

 

He's been shit and out of his depth since day one, yet Rafa is bigging him up more than any player. You could've saved some of that praise for your 20m striker.

[Torvald Utne]

I like him and think he'll make it here eventually, even if he doesn't he'll fetch way more than the 1.5 mil he cost.

[SpeedyG]

I can't be arsed anymore. Think what you like.

 

Didn't think you would, you were heading down a dead-end. FYI, I based my opinion on interviews with Gary Ablett where he described exactly the role that Nemeth was being developed for and countless blog posts by Nemeth himself where he has described his role and development, etc etc.

 

I realize my last "dissonance" post pushed you over the edge, but really.........

[ScottyT]

He's a lead the line striker.

[hamstrung]

Didn't think you would, you were heading down a dead-end. FYI, I based my opinion on interviews with Gary Ablett where he described exactly the role that Nemeth was being developed for and countless blog posts by Nemeth himself where he has described his role and development, etc etc.

 

I realize my last "dissonance" post pushed you over the edge, but really.........

 

Can't think why ANYONE would suggest you are a smug/patronising cunt.

 

I really can't.

 

FYI its nothing to do with "heading down a dead end", but everything to do with the fact that discussing this with you is about as enjoyable as prison rape.

[rebel23]

pretty sure Nemeth would show more movement and intelligence than N'Gog who just flicked it around with his back to goal in his premier league debut and was basically crap. lets hope he improves

[silverlining]

Can't think why ANYONE would suggest you are a smug/patronising cunt.

 

I really can't.

 

FYI its nothing to do with "heading down a dead end", but everything to do with the fact that discussing this with you is about as enjoyable as prison rape.

 

Worst. Interweb. Fight. EVER.

[aws]

He's clearly not got the attribites required for the level of opposition we face. He hasn't got a great touch, he lacks composure, he's not strong enough, his off the ball movement is average and his finishing looks like more luck than judgement.

 

but leaving those aside?

[SpeedyG]

Can't think why ANYONE would suggest you are a smug/patronising cunt.

 

I really can't.

 

FYI its nothing to do with "heading down a dead end", but everything to do with the fact that discussing this with you is about as enjoyable as prison rape.

 

Dissonance is rarely enjoyable ;)

[05 Milan]

N'Bog-standard.

[gkmacca]

He actually tried to handle the ball in the area AGAIN on Saturday - that's after trying to punch the ball in during a reserve game and waving a hand at a crossed ball on three or four other occasions - it's bizarre he hasn't been told to cut out the habit. It's as if he doesn't realise he does it. Otherwise I'm happy to give him enough time to build up some confidence. In pre-season games he quite surprised me with his movement and sharpness; he's looked pretty lost when he's played in the first team, but he's young enough to persevere with.