Was it a red?

[robslappa]

Maybe Aquilani will get a game now.

 

The starting line up against Wolves will be very interesting.

[Unrighteous]

I dont care. It happened.

[Moe Town]

Red card without question, you do not and cannot within the laws of the game go over the top of the ball like that. Masch could have won that ball without that sort of tackle.

 

Brown is a wanker by the way, demanding a red the way he did.

[odris]

The first thing i did when i seen Masch go for it was shout "FUCK" as i knew it was a bad tackle and he's lucky he didn't snap the lads leg.

[Malarkey]

I know it's done now like and it's a 4 game ban and whatever but to me it was definitely a red, he could of broke the lads leg if he had connected.

 

It's Tal Ben Haim.

 

Stupid, dirty, unibrowed, Islraeli twat.

[ReddOrDedd]

That was soft as shite. Was it a straight red? If so, that's disgraceful.

[Lucky Pierre]

Worse happens on a Thursday night at TLW footy. Mason gave us fuck all yesterday. Torres' booking was a joke too.

[WaltonRed]

Yes it was for me.

[Juan Galonso]

Definite red for me. I have a feeling we would be foaming at the mouth on here of the same tackle had been done on one of our own players. Selective myopia.

 

Regarding the Torres booking. Michael Turner was sent off yesterday for more or less the same thing so either both were deemed worthy of cards or none of them were.

[J-V]

Was a yellow at most, Genuine attempt for the ball. Browns tackle on Lucas was a lot worse.

 

This

[Guest simon]

Was a red 100% very dangerous tackle.

[The Dude Abides]

The first thing i did when i seen Masch go for it was shout "FUCK" as i knew it was a bad tackle and he's lucky he didn't snap the lads leg.

 

Absolute horseshit. He doesn't go over the ball, he simply misses the ball. His studs aren't raised, and it was practically a standing tackle, not a lunging diving one.

[Herp McDerp]

Never a red.

[ZonkoVille77]

Prob a bit high going in, but it was a tough red to give. Seen a lot worse over the years.

[GJM]

Red for me. He went over the top of the ball. didn't really connect much with the player but that's not the point - Mascherano couldn't be sure of that when he went for it.

[Tom R]

he didn't touch the player. At all. And he only just missed the ball.

 

So fucking what?

 

player goes for ball and misses and it's a red card now??

 

Fucking bollocks. Football is fast becoming as fucking gay as all American sports.

[Baresi]

Strange one this. I thought it was a terrible decision and I'm not even sure it was worth a yellow. I spoke to Brownie at half time and he agreed, but two other mates were disgusted with him and thought it was a really bad challenge.

 

I didn't think there was any force in his challenge, although he left his leg in a bit and was a bit high. There was no way he was going to injure anyone with that challenge though, and I reckon Ben Haim's reaction got him sent off.

 

 

That cunt Brown came over screaming to that cunt Mason, 'That's a red'. The horrible little cunt.

[Barrington Womble]

Not in my view. It was late and reckless but never a red card.

 

If you give red cards for challenges like that then you would have multiple sendings off every game.

 

brownie - you've said it was late and reckless, what more do you think you need to do in football for something to be a straight red. I'm pretty sure "wreckless" is enough on it's own for straight red. And all that is forgetting he was over the ball and studs up. Awful challenge from a player who was happy to get christmas off.

[Barrington Womble]

he didn't touch the player. At all. And he only just missed the ball.

 

So fucking what?

 

player goes for ball and misses and it's a red card now??

 

Fucking bollocks. Football is fast becoming as fucking gay as all American sports.

 

 

i don't think he played the ball.

[Tom R]

His foot ended up between the legs of another player, missing the player himself by approximately sixteen fucking miles.

Both of their respective momentums then brought them together and they crashed in to each other, one of whom then screamed a fake scream and pretended to cry like a little bitch.

 

Big. Fucking. Deal.

 

If we're heading towards a game were virtual non-challenges like this are deemed as straight reds then I don't want any part of it.

 

It's fucking bollocks.

[Barrington Womble]

His foot ended up between the legs of another player, missing the player himself by approximately sixteen fucking miles.

Both of their respective momentums then brought them together and they crashed in to each other, one of whom then screamed a fake scream and pretended to cry like a little bitch.

 

Big. Fucking. Deal.

 

If we're heading towards a game were virtual non-challenges like this are deemed as straight reds then I don't want any part of it.

 

It's fucking bollocks.

 

masch went over the top of the ball, even if he get the top of it i've seen sendings off for that. as for screaming like a little bitch, masch did a fair bit of that once he realised he might have given himself a sore knee for his sunshine holiday in argentina.

[Tom R]

masch went over the top of the ball, even if he get the top of it i've seen sendings off for that. as for screaming like a little bitch, masch did a fair bit of that once he realised he might have given himself a sore knee for his sunshine holiday in argentina.

 

Mascherano is actually injured though.

[Barrington Womble]

Mascherano is actually injured though.

 

i know, didn't stop him screaming though. and it's his own fault for such a shit challenge where he played the man and missed.

[Tom R]

Not a red card.

Barely even a yellow.

 

Teh End.

[Barrington Womble]

Not a red card.

Barely even a yellow.

 

Teh End.

 

as long as your happy. red all day for me, don't even know why it's being questioned.