Jump to content
  • Sign up for free and receive a month's subscription

    You are viewing this page as a guest. That means you are either a member who has not logged in, or you have not yet registered with us. Signing up for an account only takes a minute and it means you will no longer see this annoying box! It will also allow you to get involved with our friendly(ish!) community and take part in the discussions on our forums. And because we're feeling generous, if you sign up for a free account we will give you a month's free trial access to our subscriber only content with no obligation to commit. Register an account and then send a private message to @dave u and he'll hook you up with a subscription.


Morse
 Share

Recommended Posts

In your opinion, Jules. It's been a season of injuries so anyone that's been consistent and present would stand out. We'd be in far worst position if he had been injured like 99% of his colleagues.

You could argue Reina has been better but often he's only had a few things to do in each match.

 

He deserves it and people need to take a step back and stop this Alonso nonsence.

 

I disagree with this mate. I think we'd be in a far, far, far better position. Rafa would have been forced to play Stevie deeper and put a better standard of player than Lucas in a more advanced role. It's pretty much what everyone has been calling for all season. This vote thing is a sympathy/support type of thing. Nothing more, because there is no way he has been one of our best players, even in this total underachieving season

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In a season of disappointment Lucas has stepped his game up- even his "haters" have to admit he is a lot better now than he was (check my previous posts- I am not a Lucas lover).

 

It's a crap season- but Lucas, Insua, Ngog and Paheco are stepping up and showing this club has a great future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mascherano Reina, Carragher and Kuyt should be ahead of him. He hasn't even scored a fucking goal for christs sake. Unbelievable.

 

Masch was pretty shit for the first few months as was Carra. Kuyt has been atrocious for long spells. No way they deserve to be ahead of him.

 

And as for Lucas not scoring a goal it hardly compares badly to Carra and Masch's grand total of 1 goal between them.

 

Reina has far and away been our best player this season, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Result: Game 35 - Everton - Home - PL

 

 

1. Kuyt....................................................582 votes....................................5 points

2. Mascherano.....................................420 votes....................................3 points

3. Carragher.........................................207 votes.....................................1 point.

 

 

All sites voted as above except Est1892. They had Lucas in 3rd.

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano....................4 first..........5 second.......5 third........40 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......4 third.........39 points

3. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

4. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........3 third.........31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Carragher......................2 second......4 third...............................10 points

12.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

13.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

14.Skrtel.............................1 first......................................................5 points

15.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

16.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

17.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

18.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

19.Babel.............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Result: Game 36 - Arsenal - Away - PL

 

1. Mascherano........................................295 votes................................5 points

2. Skrtel....................................................190 votes................................3 points

3. Lucas...................................................137 votes.................................1 point.

 

 

Est1892 and TLW had it as above.

ST and 6CM had Lucas 2nd and Skrtel 3rd.

YNWA had Skrtel 2nd and Agger 3rd.

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano....................5 first..........5 second.......5 third........45 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

4. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........3 third.........31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Carragher......................2 second......4 third...............................10 points

12.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

13.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

14.Skrtel.............................1 first...........1 second...........................8 points

15.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

16.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

17.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

18.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

19.Babel.............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It speaks volumes on the season when two defensive midfielders, a right back who has been largely injured and our goalkeeper are the top four. Not to mention that our striker who has probably missed half the season with injury is 5th.

 

Just shows how poor virtually every player has been. Shameful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Game 37: Unirea - Home - EL

 

 

1. Mascherano....................................................198 votes................................5 points

2. Babel................................................................150 votes................................3 points

3. Carragher..........................................................85 votes.................................1 point.

4. Gerrard...............................................................77 votes.....................................Zero.

 

 

Low scoring match this one.

YNWA and 6CM had it as above.

ST had Gerrard 2nd and Babel 3rd.

Est1892 had Babel as MOM, with Ngog and then Mascher and Carra tied for 3rd.

TLW had Babel as MOM, with Mascher then Gerrard.

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano...................6 first..........5 second.......5 third.........50 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

4. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........3 third.........31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Carragher......................2 second......5 third...............................11 points

12.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

13.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

14.Skrtel.............................1 first...........1 second...........................8 points

15.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

16.Babel.............................1 second......1 third................................4 points

17.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

18.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

19.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Game 38 - Manchester City - Away - PL

 

 

1. Skrtel.............................................351 votes.......................................5 points

2. Mascherano.................................221 votes.......................................3 points

3. Reina.............................................139 votes.......................................1 point.

 

 

YNWA, ST and Est1892 voted as above.

6CM had Gerrard in 3rd.

TLW had Reina 2nd and Mascherano 3rd.

 

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano...................6 first..........6 second.......5 third.........53 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........4 third.........32 points

4. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Skrtel.............................2 first...........1 second...........................13 points

12.Carragher......................2 second......5 third...............................11 points

13.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

14.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

15.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

16.Babel.............................1 second......1 third................................4 points

17.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

18.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

19.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Game 38 - Manchester City - Away - PL

 

 

1. Skrtel.............................................351 votes.......................................5 points

2. Mascherano.................................221 votes.......................................3 points

3. Reina.............................................139 votes.......................................1 point.

 

 

YNWA, ST and Est1892 voted as above.

6CM had Gerrard in 3rd.

TLW had Reina 2nd and Mascherano 3rd.

 

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano...................6 first..........6 second.......5 third.........53 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........4 third.........32 points

4. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Skrtel.............................2 first...........1 second...........................13 points

12.Carragher......................2 second......5 third...............................11 points

13.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

14.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

15.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

16.Babel.............................1 second......1 third................................4 points

17.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

18.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

19.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

 

Shame he got injured when he finally looked getting back to his best.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm disappionted with our season, as are we all. The points Lucas has does surprise me, but then again he has started every P.L match this season, as has Pepe who has kept us alive time and time again which is memorable, I dont remember once this season thinking after a match that Lucas was amazing!

After Masch and Pepe you could give it to anyone, particularly anyone who has played every match, which only make Masch's points all the more valuable(?) considering his poor form early-on and his suspensions.

Pepe is mostly immense.

But Lucas???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't believe that Reina is fourth. It just shows how easy it is for the contributions of goalkeepers to be overlooked. Even on here where Pepe is incredibly popular. Something is wrong.

 

He's ace, but he hasn't had to make important contributions to every game we've played. Sometimes, unfortunately, he's just had to catch a couple of crosses and pick the ball out of the net.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Result: Game 39 - Unirea - Away - EL

 

 

1. Mascherano...............................................210 votes...........................................5 points

2. Babel...........................................................151 votes...........................................3 points

3. Reina.............................................................82 votes............................................1 point.

 

 

6CM had it as above.

YNWA had Benayoun 3rd.

TLW had Reina 2nd and Babel 3rd.

ST had Babel as MOM, Mascher 2nd and Benny 3rd.

Est1892 had Babel as MOM, Gerrard 2nd and Mascher 3rd.

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano...................7 first..........6 second.......5 third.........58 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Reina.............................5 first...........1 second........5 third.........33 points

4. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

7. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......2 third..........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Skrtel.............................2 first...........1 second...........................13 points

12.Carragher......................2 second......5 third...............................11 points

13.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

14.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

15.Babel.............................2 second......1 third................................7 points

16.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

17.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

18.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

19.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Result: Game 40 - Blackburn Rovers - Home - PL

 

 

1. Reina......................................................373 votes....................................5 points

2. Mascherano..........................................329 votes....................................3 points

3. Gerrard.....................................................91 votes.....................................1 point.

 

Mascherano continues his excellent form.

First point for Gerrard in ages.

 

Est1892, 6CM and TLW had it as above.

YNWA had Mascher as MOM with Reina 2nd.

ST had Rodriguez in 3rd.

 

 

Current table:

 

 

1. Mascherano...................7 first..........7 second.......5 third.........61 points

2. Lucas.............................4 first...........5 second.......5 third.........40 points

3. Reina.............................6 first...........1 second........5 third.........38 points

4. Johnson.........................5 first...........2 second...........................31 points

5. Torres............................4 first...........1 second.......2 third..........25 points

6. Gerrard..........................1 first...........5 second.......3 third..........23 points

7. Benayoun.......................2 first...........2 second.......6 third........22 points

8. Ngog..............................2 first...........4 second............................22 points

9. Kyrgiakos......................3 first...........1 second............................18 points

10.Kuyt................................2 first...........2 second.......1 third........17 points

11.Skrtel.............................2 first...........1 second...........................13 points

12.Carragher......................2 second......5 third...............................11 points

13.Degen............................1 first...........1 second............................8 points

14.Insua.............................2 second......2 third...............................8 points

15.Babel.............................2 second......1 third................................7 points

16.Kelly..............................1 first.......................................................5 points

17.Agger.............................4 third......................................................4 points

18.Dossena.........................1 second..............................................3 points

19.Aquilani.........................1 second.................................................3 points

20.Riera..............................1 third.......................................................1 point.

 

 

 

Thanks for taking part.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


×
×
  • Create New...