Should Carra be cropped?

[Red Nick]

Id love to know on what grounds were appealing Carra's red card

[BENIRL]

Yep, time for a rest.

[Red Nick]

Only for one match.

 

© PLAYERS SENT OFF UNDER LAW 12 (4) and (5)

A Player who is dismissed from the Field of Play for denying a goal or an obvious goalscoring opportunity by physical means or by handling the ball, will be suspended automatically from all approved First Team matches commencing forthwith, until such time as his Club's First Team has completed its next match in an approved Competition.

 

[source]

 

In that case id drop him for one match only

 

Always thought a straight red was 3 game ban

[zigackly]

In that case id drop him for one match only

 

Always thought a straight red was 3 game ban

 

It can be extended for up to two extra games for violent conduct.

[WaltonRed]

In answer the original question.

 

No.

[Guest LFD]

In answer the original question.

 

No.

 

Fair enough.

 

Care to explain why?

[Red Nick]

Poll reckons Degen Red card was wrong and Carra's was debatable do its likely Degen will get his overturned but not Carras

[DomL]

This may well be the biggest thing Rafa will have to do for this club, i feel it is time for a change and it may well take time to settle which may be what settles Rafa's future here but its a risk i think he should take especialy for the future of this team.

 

Agger has gained a great amount of experience with Denmark in terms of leadership and knowing how to be a strong character, he has enabled Kajer to develop as a CB and considering Kajer's age i think it shows Agger's ability to guide him through a match and enable him to show his skills.

 

I feel Agger is the type of person that would relish the challenge, their was a moment in the manc game which showed aggers character, Carra had put him in an akward situation with the ball and Agger delt with it as best he could and it resulted in more pressure on us.

 

Carra's reaction was straight away to shout at Agger, Agger wasn't having any of it he went straight back at him and it seemed to actually put Carra in his place somewhat, This is the type of skills that are all important in a leader, Its also a quality i think many people don't seem to think he has, he is a very aggressive defender, he impressed me immensely with his ability in the air at that Game.

 

Skrtel has alot of ability very much like Carragher he makes that last ditch challenge and has the aggression to get at forwards, i always remember the man city game ware he did somewhat illegal flying kick into I THINK Benjani's back, now i know it was illegal but that aggression is necessary i feel.

 

Both would also be a very balanced partnership one left one right, with Skrtel and Carra, Carra has to normally cover the left possition and with Insua their its currently a problem due Insua still learning his craft, Agger would have the pace and ability to cover these mistakes.

 

Wether we like it or not a time will come ware Carra will go and maybe now considering we may well be out of the title race is the best time. (we may well not im just speculating)

[Carlos Durninio]

I thought he played well on Saturday and was unlucky to get sent off. Yet again he was trying to hold together a makeshift defence as he has done all season.

 

He's the least of our worries at the moment and we won't see the best of him until we regain some semblance of consistency in selection and performance.

[Dracco]

This may well be the biggest thing Rafa will have to do for this club, i feel it is time for a change and it may well take time to settle which may be what settles Rafa's future here but its a risk i think he should take especialy for the future of this team.

 

Agger has gained a great amount of experience with Denmark in terms of leadership and knowing how to be a strong character, he has enabled Kajer to develop as a CB and considering Kajer's age i think it shows Agger's ability to guide him through a match and enable him to show his skills.

 

I feel Agger is the type of person that would relish the challenge, their was a moment in the manc game which showed aggers character, Carra had put him in an akward situation with the ball and Agger delt with it as best he could and it resulted in more pressure on us.

 

Carra's reaction was straight away to shout at Agger, Agger wasn't having any of it he went straight back at him and it seemed to actually put Carra in his place somewhat, This is the type of skills that are all important in a leader, Its also a quality i think many people don't seem to think he has, he is a very aggressive defender, he impressed me immensely with his ability in the air at that Game.

 

Skrtel has alot of ability very much like Carragher he makes that last ditch challenge and has the aggression to get at forwards, i always remember the man city game ware he did somewhat illegal flying kick into I THINK Benjani's back, now i know it was illegal but that aggression is necessary i feel.

 

Both would also be a very balanced partnership one left one right, with Skrtel and Carra, Carra has to normally cover the left possition and with Insua their its currently a problem due Insua still learning his craft, Agger would have the pace and ability to cover these mistakes.

 

Wether we like it or not a time will come ware Carra will go and maybe now considering we may well be out of the title race is the best time. (we may well not im just speculating)

 

Good post. The thing with Kjaer is debatable, cause they play for national squad where they play maybe every 2 months, not every week like in club. And considering Agger´s injury record in last seasons,and Kjaer´s low ageI think he hardly helped Kjaer to develop as a CB. I am not danish and don´t know exact number but I would guess that they did not play together for more than 10 times in their lifes.

[DomL]

Good post. The thing with Kjaer is debatable, cause they play for national squad where they play maybe every 2 months, not every week like in club. And considering Agger´s injury record in last seasons,and Kjaer´s low ageI think he hardly helped Kjaer to develop as a CB. I am not danish and don´t know exact number but I would guess that they did not play together for more than 10 times in their lifes.

 

I think maybe develop was the wrong word but Agger seems to have certainly help allow Kjaer to express himself in the correct way without looking a fish out of water and that is something i think can be credited to Agger,

 

It's something i dont like about Carra he is a defender you have to think about because he is clumsy on the ball as well as rather slow on the turn, Agger would'nt really have these problems with Skrtel