I'm slightly worried about some comments on here about RTK. Might I start by saying I have absolutely no affiliation or association with RTK, or indeed RAOTL, as some seem to think that RTK is an RAOTL thing - its not by the way, its supported by it, as I'd hope other LFC fanzines would be. I haven't bought RAOTL in about 2 years. I havent been to any RTK meetings, I only looked at the website for the first time yesterday.
I fail to see where RTK has come to be seen as an anti-OOT manifesto? I don't think its mentioned anywhere on the site or anything I've read that's come from them. In fact, all I've seen is stuff along the lines that "fans are fans, no matter where they come from". Also, RTK doesn't come from RAOTL - it started from one post on RAOTL, but that's it.
Chris, I think you're coming across as self-righteous yourself. Maybe read some of the stuff and you'll see there's a sh!tload of banners in the Kop and a mosaic which will be held up after the kick off for 6 minutes. It may not be a roaring success, but it will be seen by the media at large and at the very least it will let MacKenzie and the S*n know how Liverpool fans feel. As for telling people how to behave, they're not really are they? You're being facetious - its about trying to pass on education and values, not lay down the law. No one is trying to turn the Kop and Anfield into a group of non-individual superfans.
I was out of the country for most of December and havent been to a game since PSV so haven't been to the website that often, and I havent witnessed anything first hand at the match, so maybe I'm not best placed to be interpreting the ethos of RTK, but I've started so I'll finish. From what I can see its about trying to do something about getting back to being what fans should be - Loyal, supportive, noisy.
It's not really about jester hats, is it? They're just a symbol, rightly or wrongly, of what's wrong with football these days - the moaning, lack of knowledge of the songs and the traditions, Sky, "fans" with no clue where the Kop is or what the difference between a programme and a fanzine is. If you accept that that's the way football is going and think its fine, fair enough, the RTK will mean nothing to you. For me, the things I list above are slowly making me stop going the game. Simple as.
Therefore I'm right behind RTK. As long as it's done correctly - done with a smile and a laugh, not some "superfan prick" mouthing off and ordering some poor c*nt to sing properly. Again, to my knowledge, those leading RTK are pro-education, ant-vilification. You will get uppity gobshites screaming at jester hat wearing day trippers, but those are individuals, who probably would've done it with or without RTK.
The RTK aren't telling anyone not to wear replica kits - again this is individuals getting carried away.
No one is being told what to do - I'm damn sure no one's going to tell me. Some people are using RTK to make "rules" about what fans should be - not RTK, individuals! About what it achieves, there's a difference between Wigan away and a Liverpool - Arsenal FA cup game live on the BBC. We'll see, maybe you're right, but at least something is being done. Its better than just shrugging our shoulders and accepting it isn't it? Its very easy to do nothing. I don't see why its a bad thing to "mix" RTK and the HJC? In fact, isn't part of being a Liverpool fan, jester hat wearer or super fan prick or somewhere in the middle, that you support the justice campaign?
What are you saying here? The RTK are anti jester hats because their not official LFC products?
I'm rushing now as I gotta to do some work, but basically I think RTK is a good thing. I'm fed up with being in a Kop where you're stared at for trying to sing and create an atmosphere. When anti Chelsea and Manure songs get more of an airing when we're not playing them. Where EASEH is the biggest song of the day. It is getting to the stage where I beginning to hate the time in the stadium. Its forcing me out. RTK is setting out to address that. Therefore its a good thing. There is a belief among some that RTK is some kind of lynch mob after all OOTs, telling people what to wear and how to behave. Not so, in my opinion. As I said some individuals are laying down the law on the back of RTK, but is RTK to blame for that?
You asked Reclaim the Kop from whom? My personal answer is in bold above.
PS This debate is good. Long may it continue.