Fair points.
However the main reason we didn't finish above twelfth was because of the Europa League and Fa Cup run. That took a lot out of us. And when you consider that the average age of the Fulham squad is about 31, it's not really surprising that we didn't do great in the Premier league.
We also have a limited squad. We got injuries to Danny Murphy, Johnny Pantsil, Clint Dempsey, Bobby Zamora, Simon Davies, Damien Duff. All missed over 3 weeks of the season, we have no youngsters good enough to replace them.
As a result we underachieved.
Hodgson spends ages working on the shape of the team and it clearly pays dividends. When defending we have a tight back 4, a bank of four in midfield covering the defenders and the strikers defending from the front.
When attacking he has a playmaker in midfield, Danny Murphy, but he is also the essential to the defensive side of the game. He uses a target man and another playmaker (Gera) or a poacher (Johnson)
Roy deserves his chance, albeit I would be loathe to see him go, I would wish him well if he did.