Well - who would you rather have in your midfield at the moment? The Brazilian player of the year 2006 is making me pine for the days of clumsy Big Igor - anyone remember his first game at Old Trafford, or the performance he gave at Deportivo? I can't remember Lucas ever giving a similarly dominant performance in over 2 seasons now - when he's good he's average, and when he's bad, he's b-a-a-a-d! . Igor may have been occasionally hapless, but I fear that Lucas makes him appear a world-beater.