The clause which Gordon Taylor has been widely quoted on, referencing 40 million and Champions League qualification, did not drop from the sky into Suarez’s contract.
There were talks, there has to have been, so Suarez is telling the truth about that much. As the 40 million sum would have been negotiated, so talks were held and an agreement would have been reached about the clause that was to be added to the contract.
Suarez and/or his agent would have intended the clause be a release clause. They would not have held talks in the hope of having an essentially meaningless clause added to his contract. We can’t say anything else with any certainty but we can deduce that much.
So it is clear that the following has to have happened.
1. There has to have been talks
2. Suarez has to have let the club know he wanted a release clause
3. He has to have been on the level with LFC and given a full season’s notice that he required something written into his contract to let him leave for CL football this Summer if we didn’t qualify.
If the above at an absolute minimum didn’t happen, there would be no clause for Gordon Taylor to talk about.
So, it is probable on balance that Suarez believes a verbal agreement was reached between all parties and that his contract reflected that. He and his agent have acted in a way that is 100% consistent with a total belief that, that was the case.
He now finds it is not. That the contract which would have been drafted by LFC and its lawyers does not contain a release clause that reflects what he believes was verbally agreed.
Yes, he’ll be angry at anyone on his side responsible (the clause will be in english and so he would have needed to rely upon expert advice) for the failure to pick this up but his anger will be strongest towards LFC because he will genuinely feel they’ve breached his trust & good faith and it is possible that we have.
Why should Suarez be so slated by so many in the fan base, looking at this objectively there is a reasonable likelihood that Suarez has some genuine grounds for grievance.
None of you can say with any certainty that the club didn’t give certain assurances during talks and hasn’t conveniently distanced themselves from them now.
So as I said, Brendan is insisting Suarez must apologise, well I don’t think we should hold our breath and I’m not even sure an apology is owed
One other thing, Suarez did not lie when he said he would like to leave England and the English media specifically behind him. He would. It’s the truth.
He also wants to play CL football, he told the club of this over a year ago.
These are not mutually exclusive concepts. The one statement doesn’t make the other a lie.
He wants to leave England, he hates the English media and he wants to play CL on the continent preferably.
However, he hasn’t been able to get that.
If he must remain in England because he has zero option then he still wants the second part of his wish list, he wants CL. It’s really fucking simple.
He admitted he said Negro. He admitted he dived. His honesty has been problematic. However, we are now meant to believe he has turned into a machiavellian style man giving interviews to the Telegraph & Guardian consisting entirely of a web of lies? Hmmm, yeah, right.
Why would a bloke from Uruguay who was loved by the Ajax fans but left there, why would he have any special loyalty to us? Even Carra says we aren’t a good enough side for a guy of Suarez’s ability. CL is his dream and he wants to improve as a player. He has a finite career. And the obvious irony is he is being called selfish and some kind of childish cunt for wanting the very thing, that we want him to stay and help us to get. How fucking ironic.
I don’t think Suarez is blameless but I won’t call him all kinds of names either as I think this matter isn’t as simple as many make out. I don’t think a formal apology should be requested.