Quantcast
Shelvey. - FF - Football Forum - The Liverpool Way Jump to content
Bogman

Shelvey.

Recommended Posts

Why is it a good move?

 

You would think if he was good enough to get as much playing time he got for us last season, the only option should be a loan to a Premier League club.

 

He will not improve much in the Championship if anything at all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He will improve by playing week in, week out.

 

The lad is only 19, so the Championship will be perfect for a season and then maybe the Premier League for him next season. He'll be about 21 then and hopefully well and ready to join the first-team setup permanently.

 

He's a player.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No point sending him to a prem team that gets bummed every week and he is there to keep the score down. Let him go and develop his expressive side. He has the physical attributes to worry about defensive stuff later in his career.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm just glad Houllier isn't here to jinx him with one of his odd comparisons like Murphy being the English Zidane or Cisse being the New Henry.

 

"Jonjo is the hairless Pirlo."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Why is it a good move?

 

You would think if he was good enough to get as much playing time he got for us last season, the only option should be a loan to a Premier League club.

 

He will not improve much in the Championship if anything at all.

 

Do you just disagree with everything for the sake of it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Do you just disagree with everything for the sake of it?

 

No.

 

Its probably a good move for Shelvey himself as the Championship is about his level.

 

When it comes to his development as a player I doubt it will make him any good as he will be pretty average and not stand out in any game, the players surrounding him will be of average quality as well and to blossom and actually develop its always better to play with better players something he would do every day in training with us.

 

At Blackpool he will not really be up against any quality players either so that will not really do anything for him either.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We don't even know how long the deal is yet Code, a few months competing to play week in week out is the right environment to sharpen the ambition to play.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
No.

 

Its probably a good move for Shelvey himself as the Championship is about his level.

 

When it comes to his development as a player I doubt it will make him any good as he will be pretty average and not stand out in any game, the players surrounding him will be of average quality as well and to blossom and actually develop its always better to play with better players something he would do every day in training with us.

 

At Blackpool he will not really be up against any quality players either so that will not really do anything for him either.

 

So how come the Liverpool coaches don't know this?

 

Perhaps they have weighed all the factors, including what you are saying, and have concluded playing time is better for him, as training, even with a better quality better, is still only training and can't match the intensity of a proper game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

So how come the Liverpool coaches don't know this?

 

Perhaps they have weighed all the factors, including what you are saying, and have concluded playing time is better for him, as training, even with a better quality better, is still only training and can't match the intensity of a proper game.

 

Is this The Reverend showing his frustration?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So how come the Liverpool coaches don't know this?

 

Perhaps they have weighed all the factors, including what you are saying, and have concluded playing time is better for him, as training, even with a better quality better, is still only training and can't match the intensity of a proper game.

 

It’s so painfully obvious that it’s a shame it had to be stated, but the Rev is correct. And the fact he seems slightly irked has had me checking the skies for 4 horse men……..

 

I think Shelvey has a real chance of been top notch. Any type of playing time now will be worth it and will stand him in good stead. Just look through history and you will see top notch footy players sent out to lower league clubs when they were young to get playing time. Beckham springs to mind when he was sent to PNE. Zidane to Hull is another example*

 

 

 

 

*I may have made that up

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

TBH I haven't seen anything from Shelvey that makes me think wow when you see some young players at times and you know they're going to be class throughout their careers. Don't get me wrong he has talent but if I was a betting man (and I am) I will predict now that I don't think he will end up anything more than a good Premier League player not the superstar some are proclaiming him to be. Hope I'm very wrong like.

 

I thought Le Tallec was going to be awesome after his debut at Gresty Road back in 2003 so what do I know?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Available Subscriptions

  • Last Match Report

  • Latest Posts

    • After the farcical player about 25 yards offside winning a ball and setting up a goal tonight for the cheats, i reckon it is odds on we will have what would have been a winner ruled out for an offside about 3 passes before goal that is the width of a boot lace measured by a wobbly line.
    • Both Madrid sides and Bayern knocked out of the cup by teams I've never heard off. What's this about, a freak occurrence or big clubs trying to free up the calendar?
    • Bloody Hell. Biden’s only been top dog for about an hr. I don’t like this at all.
    • All good points Ronnie. But I fear you're discounting the shitfest unfolding before our eyes as regards officiating of games.   Even if we were in last season's form this season, we wouldnt be running away with this league and Im not sure we'd hunt down any team either.   The officials aided and abetted by VAR, Mike fucking Riley's PGMOL, the PL and to a lesser extent FIFA \ IFAB, have completely fucked up the game I love. How can anyone in their right mind say that first goal against Villa is legit? Not suggesting for one minute you are by the way!   The game is supposed to be equitable for both sides, it should be 'fair.' Some will say life's not fair or fair is a word kids use. No, it's not. The rules of the game demand fairness for both sides. It's a basic tennant of the game and why teams are 11 a side, change ends at half time and why the ref is supposed to have no affiliation with either team etc.   That goal tonight is just criminal. An offside player has gained an unfair advantage by being yards offside allowed to run nearly 10 yards to the defender with the ball, blind side him, nick the ball off his toes and play a pass to a teammate leading to a goal.   Anyone in PGMOL, the PL or tv pundit saying that's legit is just talking shite. The defender playing an 'offside' player onside was never intended for that scenario, even more so now lino's are told to keep their flag down.   Offside was introduced to prevent that very situation of an attacker standing between the goal and last defender. With their absurd decision tonight, the officials have just overturned 100+ years of football history,   And that's why I think we'd struggle to retain the title even if we were as good as last season. Brighton last minute pen against us for that joke contact? Oliver saying Pickford should have been sent offbut they 'forgot' in the fog of the offside? One of Sadio pubes sticking out of his shorts and making him offside so Hendo's last minute winner is ruled out? We'd be lucky to be 4 or 5 points clear based on last season's performances with this officiating.   Sorry, Ronnie, Im not unloading on you. Ive seen lads on here saying they are almost finished with the game. Probably like you, Ive been a seassie ticket holder for more years than I care to remember but even Im thinking when the club send out seassie renewals, should I bother because it's not 11 v 11 players any more, it's which dickhead is ref or on VAR and what fucking insane interpretation of the laws of the game are they going to use to decide the result on the day.   This madness has to stop else only the cheats and nobs will bother with football any more.   As I said, not unloading on you but the game I love is being killed by the lunatics in charge.
  • Latest Round Up

  • Popular Contributors

  • top casino sites
  • new UK casino
×