Bale & Wilshere - Correct choices?

[Fugitive]

I would never tire of repeatedly smashing pointy objects into Bale's fucking chimp face. I hate the little grinning prick and think he's overrated to fuck.

[Kozel9]

Parker should have got POTY.

[INTORRESTING]

Modric, Nani and Nasri have been excellent even though the latter two dropped off a bit.

Tevez has also been quality but was injured when the media were hyping things. Kompany and Parker have also been very good. I think all have been better than Bale

 

Wilshere is an immense talent

[Welsh]

Bale deserves it just as much as Wilshere, neither have done that much in the EPL.

 

Bale in the C.L was fantastic, but in the league he hasn't done much, Wilshere is a great prospect but he only won it because he's English and already being touted as the next big thing.

 

Player of The year: Adam

Young Player of the year: Nani

[1892-LFCWasBorn]

The PFA is absolutely flawed. It becomes a mockery even more when there is no stand out player in a season, like the Giggs farce last season.

 

Why the fuck would you takes votes half way through a season? It's the equivalent of Empire magazine running a film of the year vote in July.

 

Any player can have a decent few months, especially at the start of a season. Most of the players that were shortlisted have faded very badly.

[The Dude Abides]

No arguments with Wilshere. Think the age needs to be brought down on that to under-21.

 

Bale was flying at the start, got injured and hasn't done anything since. The voting is flawed though, why vote a few months before the season is over? How long does it take to count a few votes like? Wait until the league season is over and do it then.

 

Even then there wasn't any outstanding candidate. No one that's been consistently brilliant throughout the season.

[dennis tooth]

Modric, Nani and Nasri have been excellent even though the latter two dropped off a bit.

Tevez has also been quality but was injured when the media were hyping things. Kompany and Parker have also been very good. I think all have been better than Bale

 

Wilshere is an immense talent

 

I keep hearing them phrases and baffles me why, I genuinely haven't clue. I am less aware of Wilshere's talent than anyone else in the world it seems and it's a lonely place out here in the rain staring into a load of people dining on the knowledge of his skills. Aware me now I forbid such empty statements

[Funkasy]

Hernandes, nani and vidic have all had a very good seasons, dont know about the other teams because i only watch liverpool. and my friends are manc or arsenal fans and therefor i see some of their matches.

[Special K]

Wilshere is a decent player but he's not the second coming that we've been forced into believing he is.

 

He's the new Paul Scholes. Good, but dirty.

[Block109'er]

No problem with Wilshere, he's done well this year.

 

I recall watching the youth FA Cup final last season with Arsenal and he ran the show, it was obvious he was on the verge.

 

Bale won the award based on his early performances in Europe, which were excellent I might add but he's been performing at that level for quite for a while.

 

My money is for Suarez next season :-p

[aRdja]

Wilshere is a decent player but he's not the second coming that we've been forced into believing he is.

 

He's the new Paul Scholes. Good, but dirty.

 

I love (read: hate) how commentators just laugh it off whenever Paul Scholes stamps his studs into some guy's thigh.. "Oh Scholesy, it's never his stongest suit is it? But I'm sure he doesn't mean any malice.."

 

Fuck up.

[jmckenna]

I would not of chose Cornelieus.

I think Tevez deserved it more.

Wilshere , maybe.

[buffaloboy]

No way Wilshire, Hernandez comes from Mexico at the age of 21 and has scored 18 goals up to now for Man Utd. The culture difference between Mexico and England like the weather, language and then the fast pace of the Premier League means that Hernandez should have got the award for me. Wilshire is good but he isn't new to the English way of life or football which puts Hernandez above him.

[George Costanza]

How soft is Bale. He's another glass man. He's had a good few months but nothing more.

[aRdja]

No way Wilshire, Hernandez comes from Mexico at the age of 21 and has scored 18 goals up to now for Man Utd. The culture difference between Mexico and England like the weather, language and then the fast pace of the Premier League means that Hernandez should have got the award for me. Wilshire is good but he isn't new to the English way of life or football which puts Hernandez above him.

 

Wilshere is a regular starter in a top 4 team and looks to cement his place in the England team as well.

 

Hernandez despite his impressive scoring feat isn't a regular for United.

[Reacher]

How soft is Bale. He's another glass man. He's had a good few months but nothing more.

 

Is he injured again? Schezchzchzy went into him competing for the ball and got subbed later on.

 

 

Wilshere is a regular starter in a top 4 team and looks to cement his place in the England team as well.

 

Hernandez despite his impressive scoring feat isn't a regular for United.

 

 

Seems to be taking alot of Berbatov's time off him.

[buffaloboy]

Looks like a regular in United's team to me. Obviously there is a big squad and rotation but these days in United's most IMPORTANT games like both legs of the Chelsea Champs League tie Hernandez started. Berbatov Did not. He plays more than Berbatov.

[dennis tooth]

Apps Goals

Total (Club) 58 3

 

 

This season Apps Goals

Total (Club) 44 2

 

Wilshere's stats for an attacking midfielder who has just won an award.

I have barely seen a sniff of him admittedly but surely there are more deserving players?

Saying that, every year they fuck it up.

[mlwilliams]

Is he injured again? Schezchzchzy went into him competing for the ball and got subbed later on.

 

His knee this time.