Alex McLeish Time

[Red Nick]

its time for a real manager to come to LFCs rescue.

[WrongIslander]

Oh just fuck off and die in a painful way will ya.

[dave]

Fucking hell

[G Richards]

McLeish is a good manager and it will be interesting to see how well he does if he gets a big job. Hodgson has only just started here so obviously we can't take this seriously Nick!

[RobbieOR]

McCleish is a cunt.

[Red Phoenix]

[Major Tom]

its time for a real manager to come to LFCs rescue.

 

What do you see that you like in McLeish?

 

What are his strengths and where is he better/worse than Hodgson?

 

But you have obviously written off Hodgson after 3 weeks.

 

I despair at this attitude shown by Liverpool fans. Embarrassing.

[Juan Galonso]

McCleish is a cunt.

 

Why Rob? I always thought he was pretty inoffensive to be honest. Comes across as a decent fella and a good manager to me.

[Lunatic]

Embarrassing.

[RobbieOR]

Why Rob? I always thought he was pretty inoffensive to be honest. Comes across as a decent fella and a good manager to me.

 

I just dont like his manner. He just comes across as a total snide and he did when he managed Rangers and Scotland. There are certain managers who I dont rate but you can take a liking to. He's not one of them.

[RedinSweden]

I like him, but I like Roy too. At least let him have ONE match with all his summer signings playing.

[manwiththestick]

He's doing well at a stable mid table club who's expectations are being met comfortably. Another example of this specimen would be that Roy Hodgson at Fulham. Oh wait.....

[MLB]

its time for a real manager to come to LFCs rescue.

 

 

Have a word with yourself.

[Kevin D]

Wouldn't be too pleased with him if I was a Birmingham fan - probably wouldn't be happy with life either because, well, I'd be from Birmingham - an unadventerous, predictable and vulnerable team in front of you and Birmingham more or less stopped playing. Given that we were giving them as many free headers as they wanted, it was strange he didn't bring on Zigic.

[diamondjoe]

Dosen't matter who comes in. FUcking Mourinho could come in and he'd probably play Lucas and Poulsen. I don't know what the fuck's going on there.

Right now I'd prefer that shit on a stick that yer man said we'd all cheer. At least the shitty stick might get the ball forward.

[Funkasy]

[Steve Holt]

He's doing well at a stable mid table club who's expectations are being met comfortably. Another example of this specimen would be that Roy Hodgson at Fulham. Oh wait.....

 

To be fair to him they aren't exactly a stable mid table club are they? They are a total yo-yo club. They only just came back into the Premier League last season and now you are describing them as stable mid table. Now I reckon that hints that he's done a pretty good job there.

 

He did a good job with Scotland as well and after me bemoaning his appointment I was gutted to see him leave and we've been stuck with a couple of really dire managers since.

 

He's definitely a good manager and I think he'd do well at a big ambitious club.

 

This thread is a fucking farce though.

[paddyberger15]

To be fair to him they aren't exactly a stable mid table club are they? They are a total yo-yo club. They only just came back into the Premier League last season and now you are describing them as stable mid table. Now I reckon that hints that he's done a pretty good job there.

 

He did a good job with Scotland as well and after me bemoaning his appointment I was gutted to see him leave and we've been stuck with a couple of really dire managers since.

 

He's definitely a good manager and I think he'd do well at a big ambitious club.

 

This thread is a fucking farce though.

 

While that rules us out, he was actually first choice to replace Rafa until the takeover at Birmingham happened and he had brass in his pocket to spend. Suddenly Roy became the much cheaper option....cheaper to buy out, cheaper to pay, cheaper to fund in the transfer market and cheaper to sack due to a much shorter contract.

[JaminKibbler]

What do you see that you like in McLeish?

 

What are his strengths and where is he better/worse than Hodgson?

 

But you have obviously written off Hodgson after 3 weeks.

 

I despair at this attitude shown by Liverpool fans. Embarrassing.

 

If only everyone was like this.

[manwiththestick]

To be fair to him they aren't exactly a stable mid table club are they? They are a total yo-yo club. They only just came back into the Premier League last season and now you are describing them as stable mid table. Now I reckon that hints that he's done a pretty good job there.

 

He did a good job with Scotland as well and after me bemoaning his appointment I was gutted to see him leave and we've been stuck with a couple of really dire managers since.

 

He's definitely a good manager and I think he'd do well at a big ambitious club.

 

This thread is a fucking farce though.

 

Are they going to go down this season? I don't think so.

 

Will they finish mid table? I think they will.

 

That to me is stable but it wasn't the point i was trying to make anyway.

[Captain]

This is what we've become. Some of our fans are longing for McLeish as our manager.

 

It is heartbreaking.

 

Thanks, DM.

[Red Nick]

What do you see that you like in McLeish?

 

What are his strengths and where is he better/worse than Hodgson?

 

But you have obviously written off Hodgson after 3 weeks.

 

I despair at this attitude shown by Liverpool fans. Embarrassing.

 

His treams play good pressing football and Hodgson is Houllier in Disguiise without the winning mentality

[Monster Masch]

Red Nick, your a bit of an tit aren't you?

[kojak]

It's Roy's time fans should support him unless he fails to achieve the minimum goal of champions league place next season.

[DT]

Nick, how can you start threads calling for sensible debate then post one liners like the above as if just to provoke an angry reaction?

 

Are you expecting people to engage in serious debate when all you seem to be doing is throw out more or less provocative statements certain to get you a reaction?

 

If you were to have started a thread discussing McLeish's qualities as a manager and why you thought he was a good option for us, I think you'd have found the reaction much more sensible.

 

Maybe people would disagree but you'd have at least posted something worth reading.

 

For the record, I think we're writing off Hodgson far too early and as someone else said, with the situation we're currently in, we could be managed by anyone and be struggling right now.