Where's Carragher?

[Street Preacher]

The nominations for the PFA Player of the year award have been made.Cech,Lampard,Terry,Johnson,Henry and Gerrard.Where's JC?Steven Gerrard's had a good season in parts,but Carragher has been brilliant in pretty much every game he's played.I suppose when you have idiots like Bowyer,Dyer,Ferdinand and the whole of the Chelsea squad voting you have to expect these things.

[Captain]

That's a complete joke. The end.

[Original202]

Not wanting to start another anti - Gerrard thread, but has he been that great this season? By most players standards he's had a good season, but by his own standards he hasn't done anything special.

 

As far as making an impact goes, he's been miles behind Carra. Would still expect Carra to be in the PFA XI though.

 

Lumplard and Terry will be the top 2, and you can't really argue with that can you?

[DT]

Gerrard???? FFS!

 

Who makes these nominations? The Chelsea press?

[Red Nick]

Alonso-carra-makele-ferdinand-cole-garcia

[The Party Boy]

I think Terry's won it hasn't he, you can't really argue with that. Andy Johnson in the top 6, what a joke

[Guest Brian Stewart]

Cech,Lampard,Terry,Johnson,Henry and Gerrard? What are Johnson and Henry doing there? They're not Chelsea players. ;)

[Bamo]

Thought it must be Glen Johnson - this probably means IHFC are after Henry as well

[Bob]

I think Terry will get it, and he has been great, but did Sami get a nomination in the Treble season when he was equally good, if not better??

 

Its the hype surrounding the chelsea squad and the fact that he is english that will have influenced a lot of the players decisions.

[kop]

As for "young player of the year" the nominees are:

Scott Parker, Arjen Robben, Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney, Shaun Wright-Phillips, and Steward Downing

 

Scott "3 games all season" Parker!

WTF?

[Original202]

As for "young player of the year" the nominees are:

Scott Parker

 

Fuck off! No way?! :lol:

 

Robben will probably pick this one up, but Wright-Phillips has been quality, and Downing has come from nowhere.

[Stu Monty]

Absolute joke.

 

Gerrard and Parker!!!! One has been very mediocre and one hasn't even fucking played!

 

What about Heinze? He's been outstanding in almost every game i've seen him in. What about Finnan? Complete class all year.

What about Carra? No need to say any more really, ask John Terry.

 

Absolute Joke.

[chorlton]

agree with Heinze, he's been quality.

 

Carra not being nominated is a joke.

[Original202]

My PFA XI

 

Cech

 

Finnan Carragher Terry Heinze

 

SWP Lumplard Cahill Downing

 

Henry Defoe

 

I'd have Alonso in there if he hadn't been assaulted on New Years day and subsequently missing for 3 months.

[Agent Smith]

As for "young player of the year" the nominees are:

Scott Parker, Arjen Robben, Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney, Shaun Wright-Phillips, and Steward Downing

 

Scott "3 games all season" Parker!

WTF?

I'm pretty sure Scott Parker's thinking the same thing.

Fabregas of Arsenal should be on the list aswell, can't believe he's only 17.

[Agent Smith]

Carra should definitely be on the list and Alonso would be on it aswell if he wasn't injured for a big chunk of the season.

[kop]

I'm pretty sure Scott Parker's thinking the same thing.

Fabregas of Arsenal should be on the list aswell, can't believe he's only 17.

 

Yeah, Fabregas is a 100% better candidate than Parker.

[Agent Smith]

kop, just checked the FA website and Parker's not on the list, he won it last year.

[kop]

kop, just checked the FA website and Parker's not on the list, he won it last year.

 

Sorry about that then. I read it on http://www.liverpool.no/cda/storypg.aspx?id=4441&zone=1

 

So if you know norwegian you can check it out, just so you see I'm not a liar like :whatever:

 

Steven Gerrard er blant de seks spillerne som de profesjonelle selv har nominert til å bli Årets Spiller for 2004/05. En av disse vil få tittelen: Frank Lampard, John Terry, Petr Cech, Steven Gerrard, Andy Johnson, og Thierry Henry. Blant de unge spillerne er dette kandidatene: Scott Parker, Arjen Robben, Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney, Shaun Wright-Phillips, og Steward Downing.

[Hermes]

So that's 4 England managers, the nations press, opposing fans and now his fellow professionals who don't rate him.

 

All this time I thought it was only me.

[Stu Monty]

Who don't rate him....as one of the top six players this year...ooh the shame!!

[Hermes]

Who don't rate him....as one of the top six players this year...ooh the shame!!

 

So what was the point of this thread then Stu?

[Stu Monty]

So what was the point of this thread then Stu?

 

The point was that someone thinks that he is in the top six, and he apparently isn't.

 

I must have missed the suggestion that only six players in the league are rated by thier colleagues.

 

And by the way, loads of the media have been praising him this year and since when have national managers selected people they don't rate for thier squads?

[Hermes]

The point was that someone thinks that he is in the top six, and he apparently isn't.

 

 

Someone? Count them Stu. The thread was started because of shock that he wasn't nominated I presume. That's what I find unbelievable, the idea that somebody was expecting him to be nominated.

[Stu Monty]

I actually though he had a chance of being nominated, not shocked he isn't though.

 

Your point is valid but the way you went about it was to try and say nobody else in the world apart from liverpool fans rate him, that's not the case.