Quantcast
Report: Proposal for fake fan noise to be part of Premier League broadcast - FF - Football Forum - The Liverpool Way Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
TLW

Report: Proposal for fake fan noise to be part of Premier League broadcast

Recommended Posts

There may not be fans allowed into stadiums but broadcasters are looking to bring the full experience to the lounge rooms of football lovers across the nation.

The Mirror reports that Sky Sports are one channel that are considering using crowd noise for games played behind closed doors.

But if you do not like that artificial experience, the same game can be viewed in its natural format on one of their complementary channels like Main Event.

The discussion of feeding in crowd noise to break up the monotony of hearing managers barking instructions from the touchline and general echoey sounds reverberating through the empty stadiums had come to the fore when German broadcasters decided to include it in their match feeds.

In the main the reception to the idea has been favourable with the NRL in Australia also following suite.

The premier Rugby League competition was the first sporting competition to resume in the country after the Covid-19 shutdown and Simon Fordham the head of broadcasting for the host channel explained how the process works.

“They’ve written a program where all the sounds go into a synthesiser and they have created a non-repetitive loop or a buzz track at a base level, which is what you hear during general play.

“As required there is an operator there who uses a foot pedal or a fader from an audio desk, that you would use to increase not only the volume of the crowd noise in the mix but also expand its intensity.

"As it goes up, more layers and files get added.

 

"It’s not just the same noise getting louder. It actually - the software that has been written - enables it to increase in intensity or density.

“Booing? Giving it to the referee? Yep, it's all possible. 

“The audio operator has the ability to add jeers, boos or whistles if he believes the "home crowd" would have thought a forward pass had been thrown or the away side was offside.”

 

image.png

Fordham also explained that the volume of the cheers for the designated home team were piped in at a extra level to add that extra reality for the viewers at home.

Back in England and League bosses have set up a special working group to look at several proposals including half-time interviews, dressing room access and post-match interviews which will be discussed at Thursday’s Premier League meeting between the 20 clubs.

Clubs understand the need for TV Companies to produce content, but several managers have voiced concerns about dressing room access and also half-time interviews especially as they see the dressing room as sacred turf and the battle maybe be extremely difficult for the broadcasters to win.

Match commentators have been given the green light to be at the stadium along with touch-line interviewers but studio pundits will be based at a location off-site.


 

 


View full article

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I watched some of the Bayern v Dortmund match a week or two ago, the only footie I’ve seen since it started back up, and the crowd noise on that worked fine.

 

id read people on here and elsewhere who had watched other matches saying it was weird and eerie and like watching a training match because of how quiet it was, but what I watched looked and felt like a football match.

 

im for it.

 

so long as its something that is never used again when crowds return.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, VladimirIlyich said:

One for the shitness of modern football thread. Fake noise.

Funny this, I tend to think like you but zi know a few lads who have had the fake noise on the German games and they say that it’s better than no noise at all and feels more like a league match.

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm all for it, just switch it off if you don't like it.  Even better if we can get the big screens in so the players have supporters to interact with, no it's not the same but better than nothing. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, Jimmy Hills Chin said:

Funny this, I tend to think like you but zi know a few lads who have had the fake noise on the German games and they say that it’s better than no noise at all and feels more like a league match.

Yeah, it's better.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Rotpeter said:

Welcome to the dawn of a new era.

 

The rise of the telly-clapper.

Probably the worst entry in the Terminator franchise to be fair.

  • Upvote 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"As required there is an operator there who uses a foot pedal or a fader from an audio desk, that you would use to increase not only the volume of the crowd noise in the mix but also expand its intensity."

 

The operator will be pretty bored for Everton's home matches.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shaking my head at myself here, but it improved the coverage of the German games considerably.

 

Still, an unfiltered ninety minutes of Hendo shouting at anybody and everybody would be pretty interesting too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm watching it with the sound off and AC/DC turned up loud. For the game that can seal the title for us I'm going to play YNWA on repeat for 90 minutes plus for an hour before and a month after the final whistle. Might even leave it on at half-time. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Jimmy Hills Chin said:

Funny this, I tend to think like you but zi know a few lads who have had the fake noise on the German games and they say that it’s better than no noise at all and feels more like a league match.

I've watched a few of those games and found the noise of the players shouting to each other and the coaching staff giving instruction was absolutely fine. What has struck me more than anything is the lack of home advantage given the seemingly large amount of away wins. Maybe this is what has provoked the fan noise debate?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fuck the fake noise shit. I just want to hear the players shout at each other 'fucking cunt!' and 'why the fuck didnt you spot my run, you blind fucking meff?' Would also be fun hearing them rip into oppo players when they score like 'where's your fucking 'null and void' now, cunts?!'

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 minutes ago, dockers_strike said:

Fuck the fake noise shit. I just want to hear the players shout at each other 'fucking cunt!' and 'why the fuck didnt you spot my run, you blind fucking meff?' Would also be fun hearing them rip into oppo players when they score like 'where's your fucking 'null and void' now, cunts?!'

The very reason why they want to use it...…..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If it helps the players then why not give it a go. It’s going to be weird enough for many so if this means the games have even a fraction more edge to them then that’s better for the players and better for the fans. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, YorkshireRed said:

If it helps the players then why not give it a go. It’s going to be weird enough for many so if this means the games have even a fraction more edge to them then that’s better for the players and better for the fans. 

I’m pretty sure the players won’t be able to hear it, unless someone puts the telly on really loud in one of the corporate boxes and leaves a window open.

 

Its only on the telly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Bob Spunkmouse said:

I’m pretty sure the players won’t be able to hear it, unless someone puts the telly on really loud in one of the corporate boxes and leaves a window open.

 

Its only on the telly.

Ah, probably should have read it in more detail. Assumed they were piping it out from the stands. In that case, I’m against it. It’ll be like canned laughter on a sitcom. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Available Subscriptions

  • Last Match Report

  • Latest Posts

    • Hahahaha.    I'm sure you'll be over the moon as long as we win the 'FSG are best owners' cup.
    • Do you understand the concept that money does not equal cash?   If they put in $100m in tomorrow, they won't actually be putting their hand in their own pocket. They bought a club for 300m (or so) and its currently worth 1.5bn (or so). Asking them to invest in the playing squad beyond the proceeds of player sales is no act of fucking benevolence, it is asking Liverpool to spend within its means. If you are a club worth 1.5bn, how the fuck can you not afford to spend a penny on transfers in four transfer windows?   When they sell the club they will make a fucking windfall. The fact that they are unwilling to invest money into a club that has already guaranteed them a fortune is absolutely something they should be dragged for.
    • We must win!! It will be an anti climax if we don’t.
    • Jurgen Klopp says Liverpool will have a extra sense of purpose as they look to correct a mini blip of form and end the season in a positive fashion next Wednesday evening at Anfield.

      The Reds produced an uncharacteristically sloppy defensive display against Arsenal with mistakes by Virgil Van Dijk and Alisson gift wrapping both goals for Alexander Lacazette and Reiss Nelson.

      The North London outfit offered precious little in an attacking sense throughout the rest of the contest and had Liverpool had been on their A game, the scoreline could have been anything.

      But the truth of the matter was the champions were sloppy on the ball with countless missed passes and wasted opportunities in the final third.

      After the frustrating draw against Burnley where the team did play well, many felt the Reds would put this beleaguered Gunners outfit to the sword.

      The fact that it didn’t happen left many connected to the club extremely frustrated and you sense if given the opportunity, Klopp and the players would have thrived on then opportunity to play another 90 minutes on the spot.  

      As is his way, Klopp did not look to dwell on the negatives, instead casting his mind to next Wednesday’s clash with Chelsea and highlighted what a special occasion it will be as the Echo reported.

      “We have all been waiting ages, some of us 30 years, and we will finally get this Premier League trophy and it will be a big moment for all of us and our families,” said the Reds boss. “That’s 100%.

      “Before that, we have to play a game. For five millions reasons, we will try to win it.

      “I have had this situation twice in my life where we have got the trophy on the day.

      “It will be difficult, especially when the other team is Chelsea and they are fighting with all they have to get in the Champions League.”

      Despite the opponent, Klopp is confident that they play to their optimum level, they will be able to celebrate the moment in fitting style.

      “I saw tonight that my boys want to win it. They made two wrong decisions, but they wanted to win the game.

      “I don’t think I ever played a game with 24 to three shots against Arsenal, I can’t remember that. There are a lot of goals usually when we play against each other, but not that many tonight – at least on our side. But that dominance we never had before, I can’t remember it at least. So I’m happy about that.

      "They made two wrong decisions, but they wanted to win the game.

      “And that’s what will happen next week, 100%. We will try with everything we have to win the game.”

       
      View full article
    • Well that's these people faults. It's pretty clear we've been sell to buy. I've still not heard why that's a bad thing, though. I mean the whole point of building a team is keeping the good players who are happy to play for you and to replace the ones who don't want to play for you. You can't tell me anyone good has ever been sold when they still wanted to be here. The difference now is players want to be here, so there's less room in the squad and less money to spend. Oh well.    And the difference between us and Manchester United is they've always been the richest club, they could buy anybody. That's just not realistic when we were mediocre for 25 years and started to lag behind. FSG are our owners because they think they can compete in a world where there are financial regulations. The problem is, there aren't any and so now their crime is basically that they're broke and don't/can't spend their own money because the supposed rules say they shouldn't. That's just not really a fair criticism, to be honest. It's bad faith.    I've always just enjoyed that they're competent for the most part at owning a sports team. That's it really. And it's enough for me I guess, not for some. 
  • Latest Round Up

  • Popular Contributors

  • Football Betting Site Betway
×