Pepe Reina

[The Golden Eel 3,915]

3 hours ago, Code said:

Not saying this is  proof or anything but its certainly an indicator.

 

A keeper finishing 4th has had a pretty good season, no ifs or buts about it.

 

 

 

Sturridge and Coutinho only signed in January that season so that skews it slightly. 

[redinblack62 325]

23 hours ago, The Golden Eel said:

Sturridge and Coutinho only signed in January that season so that skews it slightly. 

What does this prove?

Who voted?

In his final season I can only remember him waving shots into the net that he couldnt bother his arse diving for.

He might have been a nice chap but when we got rid he was rubbish.

[The Golden Eel 3,915]

8 hours ago, redinblack62 said:

What does this prove?

Who voted?

In his final season I can only remember him waving shots into the net that he couldnt bother his arse diving for.

He might have been a nice chap but when we got rid he was rubbish.

People on here and elsewhere voted match by match, so Reina had twice as many games roughly to get votes. 

[Pidge 3,716]

On 10/03/2020 at 11:14, dockers_strike said:

Bang on. Id put him 4th in our list of great keepers behind Clem, Brucie and Lawrence and that's before you consider Alisson.

So 5th then. 

 

6th when you consider Scott.

 

Maybe 7th behind Jerzy just on the basis of Istanbul.

[Kevin D 7,418]

Actually come out against the cancerous ownership of this club when it mattered.

 

Not when it was convenient, en vogue, or when Ricky Tomlinson and other big match beauts did, but when it cost him something.

 

He was a proper Liverpool player in terms of skill and character. It's a shame his trophy cabinet doesn't reflect it, because he was the best goalkeeper in the world for 3 years and the best we had seen from '81 until August 2018.

[VladimirIlyich 7,371]

On 05/07/2020 at 19:21, Kevin D said:

Actually come out against the cancerous ownership of this club when it mattered.

 

Not when it was convenient, en vogue, or when Ricky Tomlinson and other big match beauts did, but when it cost him something.

 

He was a proper Liverpool player in terms of skill and character. It's a shame his trophy cabinet doesn't reflect it, because he was the best goalkeeper in the world for 3 years and the best we had seen from '81 until August 2018.

Yes,he was a very solid goalkeeper in his first few seasons under Rafa. The fact that Alisson is already considerably better than Reina ever was is testament to Alisson's brilliance.

[Kevin D 7,418]

25 minutes ago, VladimirIlyich said:

Yes,he was a very solid goalkeeper in his first few seasons under Rafa. The fact that Alisson is already considerably better than Reina ever was is testament to Alisson's brilliance.

 

Alison is absolutely boss.

[Trumo 13,950]

His form started to wane after Rafa and his coaching staff left the club. He seemed to spend more time bulking up and it impacted on his agility.

[Antynwa 23]

He just stopped saving things, and if I recall correctly didn't save a penalty again after the 2007 CL Semi Final.

 

His problem also was that he was behind one of the greatest goalkeepers of the generation in Iker Casillas so was never really able to rise to the level that Allison has done whilst at Liverpool. Although he was clearly well thought of. 

 

On his day he was absolutely brilliant, more error prone than Allison, and unfortunately whether it was himself or the impact of circumstances around him, he just became a little bit shit.

 

Also I am now viewing Reina in the context of the greatest goalkeeper I've ever seen and in my opinion unquestionable the best goal keeper in Europe in AB. 

 

Still love him though, wish he got an ovation this week.

[Code 748]

A load of nonsense is posted in this thread.

[VladimirIlyich 7,371]

6 hours ago, Code said:

A load of nonsense is posted in this thread.

And this post is the start of it?

[Code 748]

2 hours ago, VladimirIlyich said:

And this post is the start of it?

Fine.

[John102 517]

 

He still takes his Cheer leading duties seriously (Not meant as a dig)

[Stickman 6,893]

Once a red ....

 

[Section_31 19,488]

Love Reina, Rafa's first batch of signings and Rafa himself will always be really special IMO, I loved that team.

[AngryofTuebrook 17,873]

His form tanked for a while, but as Rodgers' first season went on he kept improving; not to the levels of his peak, but certainly to a level as good as most keepers in the league.  He was certainly no worse than Mignolet. 

[Code 748]

When Reina hit 50 he will still be a better keeper than Ming in his prime ( whenever that was).

[VladimirIlyich 7,371]

I liked Reina but I think his downturn in form was linked to not being arsed for a while when the club was in a mess. Replacing him with Mig wasn't really an upgrade.

[The Guest 1,768]

He was absolutely shocking at the end.  As error prone as Mignolet was he was a far better keeper at that point.  Reina had empty crisp packets for hands those final 2 or 3 seasons at the club.

[AngryofTuebrook 17,873]

16 minutes ago, The Guest said:

He was absolutely shocking at the end.  As error prone as Mignolet was he was a far better keeper at that point.  Reina had empty crisp packets for hands those final 2 or 3 seasons at the club.

Nah. He was shocking up until about 6 months before the end.  He then improved markedly. His shot-stopping was at least as good as Mig's and his distribution was infinitely superior, which would have made him a great asset for that 2013/14 team.

[dockers_strike 1,946]

32 minutes ago, The Guest said:

He was absolutely shocking at the end.  As error prone as Mignolet was he was a far better keeper at that point.  Reina had empty crisp packets for hands those final 2 or 3 seasons at the club.

This. He was actually shocking in the Gerrard FA Cup Final (apart from the pens), spilled that shot for Ramires' opening goal in Kenny's FA Cup final, spilled that one from 25 yards against Hearts in the Europa League, the massive fuck up performance against the shite at woodison etc. Mig would rightly get slaughtered for any of those.

 

I dont even rate him in the top 4 all time Liverpool keepers.

[Alex_K 837]

Mignolet saved a penalty at home on his debut in the league. I distinctly remember the euphoria of thinking we may well have a half decent keeper again. Of course, that would be very short lived, but I really don't think anyone during that summer or at that time was ruing Reina's departure -- as others have said he'd been a shadow of his early self for a while.

 

That video is a bit sad in its own right. Not so much because its Reina personally, but as a commentary on the transience of a footballer's career. From dancing on the stage singing to hundreds of thousands in Madrid celebrating Spain's world cup with Torres, Villa et al to something of a dad-dance all alone with those brummy Villa no marks. Here today, gone tomorrow.

[The Guest 1,768]

5 minutes ago, AngryofTuebrook said:

Nah. He was shocking up until about 6 months before the end.  He then improved markedly. His shot-stopping was at least as good as Mig's and his distribution was infinitely superior, which would have made him a great asset for that 2013/14 team.

I don’t know why people try to revise history like this all the time.  So many people get so defensive about players that used to be good.  The clubs form took an upward curve because we signed Coutinho and Sturridge.  Reina was still shite, conceding goals pretty much every time a half decent shot went at him.  It was a running joke how often he was beaten at his front post.

Mignolet saved a pen in his first league game to win us it in the last few minutes.  Reina hadn’t saved a pen for years.  It set us on the road that season which turned out to be a pretty good one for Mignolet.  People still had their nose out of joint at the time because they wanted Rafa back to bore us into a miserable mid table finish playing Suarez at right back and Reina throwing it in his own net every week.  Mignolet didn’t turn out to be great or anywhere near Reina’s best but he was far better than Reina’s worst which is what we had been seeing for years.  We’d have never been in a title race had he been in goal.

[Code 748]

26 minutes ago, Alex_K said:

Mignolet saved a penalty at home on his debut in the league. I distinctly remember the euphoria of thinking we may well have a half decent keeper again. Of course, that would be very short lived, but I really don't think anyone during that summer or at that time was ruing Reina's departure -- as others have said he'd been a shadow of his early self for a while.

 

That video is a bit sad in its own right. Not so much because its Reina personally, but as a commentary on the transience of a footballer's career. From dancing on the stage singing to hundreds of thousands in Madrid celebrating Spain's world cup with Torres, Villa et al to something of a dad-dance all alone with those brummy Villa no marks. Here today, gone tomorrow.

In the same game he almost did a Pickford from a terrible shot from around 25 m out.

 

If you took a shot from outside the box against the clown we bought from Sunderland, it was almost a guarenteed goal.

 

Reina saved more shots from outside the box almost every season, than what Mignolet did in his Liverpool career all together.

 

Fuckin abysmal keeper, on par with the fuckin useles fraud that bought him. Fuck them both.

[Alex_K 837]

5 minutes ago, Code said:

In the same game he almost did a Pickford from a terrible shot from around 25 m out.

 

If you took a shot from outside the box against the clown we bought from Sunderland it was almost a guarenteed goal.

 

Reina saved more shots from outside the box almost every season than Mignolet did in his Liverpool caeer together.

 

Fuckin abysmal keeper, on par with the fuckin fraud that bought him. Fuck them both.

Yeah no debate that Mignolet was awful, more so just highlighting that at the time I think it was pretty widely considered that we needed a new keeper, we just fucked up the recruitment of the next one. Reina went out on loan to Napoli was it? He then spent most of the following seasons on Bayern's or a very poor A.C. Milan's bench. He wasn't good enough to be a number 1 'keeper for a top side anymore, I think that's pretty fairly evidenced because none came in for him. Would he have been a more able deputy for Alisson than Karius in 2018? That probably goes without question ..