All time Prem 11 - 442

[Bjornebye]

Just watched this. I'd personally swap Ferdinand for Adams and Lampard for Keane. good watch 

 

 

[aRdja]

De Gea

Ferdinand

Vidic

Walker

Cole 

Vieira

Scholes

Gerrard

Ronaldo

Henry

Suarez

 

Can’t really think of a better right back than Walker at the moment, but I’m sure I’ll change my mind in the next couple of hours or so.

[Lee909]

3 hours ago, aRdja said:

De Gea

Ferdinand

Vidic

Walker

Cole 

Vieira

Scholes

Gerrard

Ronaldo

Henry

Suarez

 

Can’t really think of a better right back than Walker at the moment, but I’m sure I’ll change my mind in the next couple of hours or so.

Better RBs than Walkers

 

Well here's three that could actually defend

Neville, Dixon and Rob Jones 

 

Schmeichel the best keeper too

 

And noway Suarez having 2 great years surpasses Shearer

[aRdja]

16 minutes ago, Lee909 said:

Better RBs than Walkers

 

Well here's three that could actually defend

Neville, Dixon and Rob Jones 

 

Schmeichel the best keeper too

 

And noway Suarez having 2 great years surpasses Shearer

 

Suarez was the best no 9 in the world for those two years. Shearer never reached those heights in husband career IMO. 

 

Walker is a more complete full back than Neville IMO. 

 

Yeah Schmeichel is a good shout.

[Lee909]

Walker is shite

Typical modern fullback, can't defend for shite and if he wasn't quick wouldn't be close to playing top flight football

[Ne Moe Imya]

Suarez vs. Shearer is the old debate of peak vs. overall career.

 

If you want "overall career," and you're only picking based on PL performances, well, it has to be Shearer. If you want who was better at his peak, it's easily Suarez, who for that two-year period dominated the league in a way that's rarely ever been seen. From about October 2013 to May 2014 you can make an argument he reached Messi-level of dominance. Never seen another player in the Premier League you could say that about.

[Elite]

If it has to be 442.

 

---------------------------Schmeichel

 

Neville----------Ferdinand-----Stam-------A. Cole

 

Ronaldo-------Gerrard--------Vieira-------Giggs

 

-----------------------Suarez--------Henry

 

Prime Suarez and Henry were better than prime Shearer.

[Mark M]

11 minutes ago, Ne Moe Imya said:

Suarez vs. Shearer is the old debate of peak vs. overall career.

 

If you want "overall career," and you're only picking based on PL performances, well, it has to be Shearer. If you want who was better at his peak, it's easily Suarez, who for that two-year period dominated the league in a way that's rarely ever been seen. From about October 2013 to May 2014 you can make an argument he reached Messi-level of dominance. Never seen another player in the Premier League you could say that about.

Henry ?

[aRdja]

18 minutes ago, Elite said:

If it has to be 442.

 

---------------------------Schmeichel

 

Neville----------Ferdinand-----Stam-------A. Cole

 

Ronaldo-------Gerrard--------Vieira-------Giggs

 

-----------------------Suarez--------Henry

 

Prime Suarez and Henry were better than prime Shearer.

 

Scholes was better than Giggs IMO.

[Elite]

Just now, aRdja said:

 

Scholes was better than Giggs IMO.

Not on the left wing he wasn't.

[aRdja]

1 minute ago, Elite said:

Not on the left wing he wasn't.

You could quite easily change the formation to accommodate Scholes.

[Elite]

Yeah but the thread says 442.

[Nolongerathletic]

4 hours ago, aRdja said:

De Gea

Ferdinand

Vidic

Walker

Cole 

Vieira

Scholes

Gerrard

Ronaldo

Henry

Suarez

 

Can’t really think of a better right back than Walker at the moment, but I’m sure I’ll change my mind in the next couple of hours or so.

Ah bloody hell Ardja....If you cant think of a better RB than Walker then I will light a candle for you!

 

Let me see...off top of head Dixon, Neville, Ivanovic, Lauren, Sagna, probably Azpliliecueta also...

 

Keane best midfielder, Berkamp closest I have seen to Dalglish... a personal favourite for me at the back was Carvallho...bailed the great JT out many a time! Schmeichel no brainer. 

 

I hate these and normally wouldn't post, but the Walker thing got to me! You are moving further and further away from your lady glove return!

 

 

[Tony Moanero]

Why do you hate them?

[Tony Moanero]

442

 

Schmeichel

Neville

Ferdinand

Terry

Irwin

Ronaldo

Keane

Gerrard

Giggs

Bergkamp

Henry

 

An all-time 70s/80s team would give any Premier League XI a run for their money, though.

 

 

 

 

 

[aRdja]

38 minutes ago, Elite said:

Yeah but the thread says 442.

My mistake

[aRdja]

36 minutes ago, Nolongerathletic said:

Ah bloody hell Ardja....If you cant think of a better RB than Walker then I will light a candle for you!

 

Let me see...off top of head Dixon, Neville, Ivanovic, Lauren, Sagna, probably Azpliliecueta also...

 

Keane best midfielder, Berkamp closest I have seen to Dalglish... a personal favourite for me at the back was Carvallho...bailed the great JT out many a time! Schmeichel no brainer. 

 

I hate these and normally wouldn't post, but the Walker thing got to me! You are moving further and further away from your lady glove return!

 

 

Put your team up then! Neville was an average player IMO. He was solid with a decent cross. Azpilicueta probably could’ve made it... he’s better defensively and okay going forward.

[Nolongerathletic]

28 minutes ago, Tony Moanero said:

Why do you hate them?

Because people write crap that I hate...

 

Your team works though!

[Nolongerathletic]

5 minutes ago, aRdja said:

Put your team up then! Neville was an average player IMO. He was solid with a decent cross. Azpilicueta probably could’ve made it... he’s better defensively and okay going forward.

Yes, but he was better than that flunk Walker! Irwin, played occasionally on the right was better than them all. 

[El Rojo]

Shearer was an animal of a striker and has to be included. Brilliant footballer, born winner. Would have been great for us at any stage in his career.  aRdja clearly on a wind-up with Walker. He's lucky to get into the current Manchester City team.

 

[aRdja]

34 minutes ago, El Rojo said:

Shearer was an animal of a striker and has to be included. Brilliant footballer, born winner. Would have been great for us at any stage in his career.  aRdja clearly on a wind-up with Walker. He's lucky to get into the current Manchester City team.

 

They spent close to £50m for him. Who would they play there instead? Happy to replace him with Azpi, but not Gary Neville or Ivanovic, as they’re both decent defenders but limited footballers.

[aRdja]

De Gea

Ferdinand

Vidic

Azpilicueta

Cole

Vieira

Gerrard

Ronaldo

Hazard

Henry

Suarez

[Jairzinho]

Schemeichal

Jones Stam Hyypia Cole

Ronaldo Gerrard Viera Giggs

Suarez Henry

[Jairzinho]

Need Code to name 10 right backs better than Walker.

 

To be honest, there have probably been about 30.

[VERBAL DIARRHEA]

Schmeichel

 

Jones   Ferdinand   Stam   Cole

 

Ronaldo   Gerrard   Scholes   Giggs

 

Henry   Bergkamp