Aaron Ramsey Vs Jordan Henderson: Who would you prefer to have on your team?

[WhiskeyJar]

The versitile Henderson or the in-form, free scoring Ramsey?

[Guest LFD]

Henderson.

 

Close thread!

[Torvald Utne]

strange thread from a strange forumite

[WhiskeyJar]

Was thinking about it the other day.

 

Henderson is engine like midfielder versitile in everyway, he can even play at right back.

 

The problem is does he score enough goals, and with Ramsey scoring 5 goals already this season, perhaps its time we played him in a mroe advance position.

[fowler9]

Was thinking about it the other day.

 

Henderson is engine like midfielder versitile in everyway, he can even play at right back.

 

The problem is does he score enough goals, and with Ramsey scoring 5 goals already this season, perhaps its time we played him in a mroe advance position.

 

He has scored a reasonable amount since playing anywhere in a 3 in a 4-2-3-1

 

Ramsey's best is better than Henderson's best but Hendo more consistent imo

[DooooodekNo5]

You do this poll when Ramsay is in the best run of form in his career?.

 

I'ld stick with Henderson.

[Guest LFD]

Aaron Ramsey:

 

Previously = 91 games - 5 goals

 

This Season = 7 games - 6 Goals

 

I judge players over a long time, not 7 games. Henderson is a much better player and a few goals won't change that.

[Lario]

Henderson is boss and plays for us.

Ramsey is flavour of the month and plays for them cunts dan saff.

 

Can't understand where the question is coming from.

[Elite]

I'll reserve judgement for a few years,

[RobbieOR]

Personally always thought Ramsey was a decent player. Would probably have him over Henderson at the moment. 

[The Midnight Rambler]

Ramsey in a heartbeat.

[RedKnight]

If you held a gun to my head then Ramsey but I've no problem with Henderson at the club or in the team.

[Guest Numero Veinticinco]

I think Ramsey is fucking shite.

[Brigant Moloch]

Henderson of course, Ramsay is just shite

[Guest LFD]

Ramsey in a heartbeat.

 

Are you Welsh?

[RobbieOR]

Are you Welsh?

 

Dont see what that has to do with anything. Ramsey's 22, has captained his country, has played regularly at the top level in the champions league for the last 4 years.

 

Its not that surprising and it is no slight on Henderson's ability either. 

[Guest LFD]

Dont see what that has to do with anything. Ramsey's 22, has captained his country, has played regularly at the top level in the champions league for the last 4 years.

 

Its not that surprising and it is no slight on Henderson's ability either. 

 

The Welsh like to support their players, just interested to know if he is or isn't.  I know you're not Welsh, that's why I didn't ask you.

 

Redknight is though.  Just interested to see if the majority voting for Ramsey are Welsh.  If Henderson was Welsh maybe he'd get Redknights vote!?

[sir roger]

I have put Ramsey in my Fantasy Football team so the goals will dry up as night follows day. I think he is a little more seasoned than Henderson at this juncture but Jordan will be a better player over the respective careers.

[Babb'sBurstNad]

Ramsey, though there's not much between them. He was developing really well before his injury and now looks to be back where he left off.

 

Henderson's arguably a better fit for us right now though; fitness personified, more adaptable and happy to run all day. Different players really.

 

Disclaimer: I'm not Welsh.

[Guest LFD]

Disclaimer: I'm not Welsh.

 

Sound.

 

Seems more than the Welsh do rate him, which is fair enough.

 

I thought he was awful last season, haven't watch much of him this season, but I see he is scoring goals.  Will check him out to see if he has significantly improved.  

[Babb'sBurstNad]

To be honest, this recent run seems to have skewed perception of him a bit too positively. He's a good player, but this goal scoring form's just a purple patch.

 

Reminds me a bit of the one Meireles had for us, in the right place at the right time and everything seems to go in, but I wouldn't bet on him to break double figures in the league or anything.

[Pureblood]

Aaron Ramsey is better. He was excellent before that injury and i'm not surprised to see him in the goals again. I would expect more goals from him with the likes of Ozil loading the bullets. Just a matter of staying fit for Ramsey. With his quick feet and skill he might get clattered again.

[G Richards]

Ramsey enjoying  purple patch, but you have to go with your own player. Henderson is growing as a Liverpool player. Last summer he was offered in exchange for Dempsey. He put that behind him and kicked on. The way he works you would have to think there is yet more improvement to come from him. Henderson for me. 

[therevivalist]

But isn't Ramsey older? In which case you've a false comparison right there.

[Ne Moe Imya]

It's close enough in overall talent that there shouldn't be any question for a fan.  A neutral might have a more difficult time.  I've no doubt that most would say Ramsey at the moment with the form he's in, but whoever compared this run of form with Meireles' is spot on. 

 

Sometimes a player, particularly an attacking midfielder, just goes through a statistical anomaly where they get a bunch of goals all in a few games, and for a month they're on top of the world.  However, usually class being permanent and all, they return to their level soon enough.  Sergio Canales another that springs to mind as an example.