Jump to content
tlw content
tlw content

Carragher: Mane is Liverpool's best wide player in 30 years

Jamie Carragher has lavished Sadio Mane with high praise, comparing him with a Reds legend of the past and saying he is more irreplaceable in terms of Liverpool's title prospects than Mo Salah.

Carragher was speaking on Sky Sports' Monday night Football and left no one under any illusion to how highly he rates the Senegal international.

 

The Liverpool Echo reported Carragher as saying;

"I think sometimes he goes under the radar. 

"You talk about Salah and the goalkeeper (Allison) and the impact these players have had, he's (Mane) the best wide player Liverpool have had in 30 years. You have to go back to John Barnes since Liverpool have had a player like Mane.

 

"That is big because John Barnes is in my top five or six players to have ever played for Liverpool."

His fellow pundit Gary Neville then asked the legendary Liverpool defender that if he had to choose one of Salah or Mane to miss the key games of the title run-in, which one would it be.

Once again Carra did not hesitate.

"Salah. They have the same amount of goals. I'm a massive fan of Mane.

"Mane is the one that got Liverpool back. 

"He was Jurgen Klopp's first big signing. He's been there from the very start."

 

mane3_600.jpg
 

Carragher knows first hand about the pressure of a title run-in, having lived through it in 2008/9.

In that season, just like this current campaign, the Reds proved a very tough team to beat losing just two games. The current side have lost just once and have some pretty good football betting odds to win the title this season.

However, in 2009 it was the inability to break down well organised defences which led to costly draws that was the main issue, and they eventually finished four points behind Man United.

Carragher said that Mane was just the type of player which would have proved the difference during that season.

"We didn't have a wide player in 2009. 

"If you look at the teams that win the title, the wide players stand out massively. If we'd had Mane in 2009, I think we would have won the league."

Carragher is also a big believer of setting the tone in matches. It's all very well getting a double when your team is already 3-0 up, but which player is going to do the hard yards in putting your team on the path of victory.

Carragher said Mane has been the main man in that regard.

"Going through Liverpool's last eleven games and in the first four, Mane got the first goal." 

"There are only two other Liverpool players who have scored the first goal in those eleven matches (Roberto Firmino vs Burnley and Tottenham and Naby Keita against Southhampton).

"That's how vital Mane is."

While the overall impact of Salah over the past two seasons is indisputable, without Mane's goals over the past two months, City would be home and hosed in the title race.

Once an unsung hero, Sadio is now getting the recognition he truly deserves.

 

Edited by tlw content

User Feedback

Recommended Comments



Some of our best teams have had no natural wide players in. 

 

Mane is a massively improved player, his tactical awareness has developed this season, and his work rate, which was always solid, is now prodigious. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, stringvest said:

Just in case I further upset dockers strike, watching Salah tracking back and making decisive interceptions was gratifying too.

I love how some of you twist posts to suit your agendas. Go back and re read my original post. (No wait, that's a rhetorical statement by me.) In that, I posted I wasnt always on the Sadio bus but, I consider he has improved exponentially.

 

The only comparision I made between Sadio and other players, was to the songs sung about him, Mo and Bobby. Yet you seem intent to turn it into one player vs another and quotes such as 'it's not like Mo has made some wayward passes' or similar.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, dockers_strike said:

I love how some of you twist posts to suit your agendas. Go back and re read my original post. (No wait, that's a rhetorical statement by me.) In that, I posted I wasnt always on the Sadio bus but, I consider he has improved exponentially.

 

The only comparision I made between Sadio and other players, was to the songs sung about him, Mo and Bobby. Yet you seem intent to turn it into one player vs another and quotes such as 'it's not like Mo has made some wayward passes' or similar.

 

 

Ok.  I suspect we have issues of communication between us.  It’s not you, it’s me. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Jairzinho said:

Thanks to Rafa we're still in a title race.

Thankfully he’s still one of the best in the business at shithousing results in one off games against better teams.  The fact that he’s managing Newcastle shows how far football and has moved on since his heyday.  I’m glad we don’t employ a manager who does that any more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, The Guest said:

I think the point Carragher was making and I agree with him is that we are more reliant on Mane.  If you take Mane out of the team we lose so much creativity.  How many times has he been the guy to break the dead lock by providing the width we need?  He’s the only forward we have who tries to get to the byline consistently.  Dave puts it in his reports nearly every week.

 

Mane is much more consistent with his overall game.  When his finishing is off he’s still great at winning headers, holding the ball up, creating for other players and occupying defenders.  When Salah isn’t scoring his whole game seems to suffer.  He does still give you work rate but you don’t get anywhere near the effect on the game that you get from Mane.


Mane has 1 assist all season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Single handedly pulled us through our sticky patch has been in great form and consistent all year . However think the 30 years includes Barnes he was something else bit like Ali in his prime beautiful to watch and admire.

 

Sorry may bad best since Barnes he said statement of blindingly obvious give me that pundits job 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who mentioned assists?  When creativity is defined by getting fouled and winning a penalty I think the conversation is over.

 

Read the post above again.  I couldn’t be clearer on why I agree with Carragher and it’s got fuck all to do with the “assists” stat which means fuck all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, The Guest said:

We’ve had this conversation about “assists” before.  Maybe you should go back and read it.


Some more PL stats.

Key passes pr game + total:
Salah: 1,8 (62)
Mane: 1,1 (36)

Dribbles pr game sucsessful + total:
Salah: 2,1 (70)
Mane: 1,7 (47)

Through balls pr game + total:
Salah: 0,3 ( 8 )
Mane: 0,1 ( 2)

Crosses pr game + total:
Salah: 0,5 (7)
Mane: 0,2 (3)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I loved Carra as a player, but he was as annoying on the pitch as off it. Some of the shit you could hear him giving to lesser players, but never said a word to the main men in the teams. He’s a bit of a tit, truth be told.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

He had a pop at Arbeloa once and there’s still people crying about it today.  He also mentioned having to stop speaking to Enrique because he was driving him mad.  The revisionist shit people come up with in their heads is fucking comical.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting stats from Frode there, I'm a little surprised by them to be honest as my eyes are telling me that Sadio is having a better season than Mo, but the numbers clearly don't back it up.

 

I'm definitely being influenced by the fact Mané is playing better than he did last year while Salah has dropped off. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stats are always a load of bollocks.  You don’t know who is compiling them, how they’re judging them and how consistent it is.  Frode is doing his classic selective stats trick as well.  He’s not telling you anything about where they come from or what period they cover.  If it includes last season then I think everyone would accept Salah was on a different stratosphere to Mane and everyone else in the prem.

 

Carra put up a load of stats on MNF as well about Mane scoring the first goal in about 80% of the games in 2019 commenting on how when the big teams score first they tend to nearly always win and almost never lose.  It was his main point about why Mane has been so vital since the turn of the year and why in the run he would rather have Mane if there was a choice.  Even that though I’m not bothered about because it’s out of context.

 

I’ll trust my own eyes and judgement over some Opta nerd who’s probably never got off his couch and been given some cushy job because his dad knows one of the directors.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, The Guest said:

He had a pop at Arbeloa once and there’s still people crying about it today.  He also mentioned having to stop speaking to Enrique because he was driving him mad.  The revisionist shit people come up with in their heads is fucking comical.

Revisionist shit? I was sat there listening to him you condescending idiot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites




Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...