Quantcast
Liverpool 4 Cardiff City 1 - Player Ratings - Opinion - The Liverpool Way Jump to content


tlw content
tlw content
Sign in to follow this  

Liverpool 4 Cardiff City 1 - Player Ratings

Not the most fluid or dynamic performance but in flashes we saw more evidence that the frontmen are regaining their collective mojo.

 

At times it was too easy and that resulted in a lack of urgency, but Cardiff’s goal provided the jolt that was needed. Or maybe it was Shaqiri who did that?

 

The good

 

Another three points and more goals for Mo and Sadio, as well as a terrific first Anfield strike for Shaqiri. 

 

The bad

 

The flukey goal conceded took a little of the shine off the win. The defensive record is something to be proud of and giving up a soft goal like that is irritating to say the least.   

  

Player ratings out of 10:

 

GK Alisson Becker, 6 -- Didn't have anything to do. No saves, no crosses to deal with, nothing. Conceded a goal from the only effort he faced, but had no chance with it as it was a total fluke.  

 

DF Trent Alexander-Arnold, 6.5 -- Steady enough, but had one or two near uncomfortable moments against the pacy Murphy. Crossing not at his best but generally a decent performance.

 

DF Dejan Lovren, 7 -- Presumably brought in for his physical presence and he didn’t disappoint, battling hard against Cardiff’s big frontman Paterson. Amusingly, tripped over his own feet in front of the Kop when trying to get back after going forward for a corner, and was mocked on twitter afterwards by Milner. 

 

DF Virgil Van Dijk, 7 -- Not exactly overworked but exuded machismo and authority with everything he did, the big smooth bastard. Except when he didn’t clear the cross for their goal, that wasn’t cool.

 

DF Alberto Moreno, 6.5 -- Enthusiastic as always and channeled it in the right way, for the most part anyway. He did give away one needless free-kick but other than that he was fine.   

 

MF Fabinho, 7.5 -- Not quite as masterful as he was in midweek, but still pretty good. Some class tackles again and used the ball well. I like him.

 

MF Georginio Wijnaldum, 8 -- Seemed to be everywhere, probably because he was. Always available for a pass, always in people’s faces trying to win the ball back, and generally just a top all round performance from the in-form Dutchman.   

 

FW Adam Lallana, 6 -- Surprise selection to start the game. Did ok, some nice touches and very unlucky not to score just before half time with a back post header. Slowed the game down a bit too much for my liking though and I never really like seeing him playing wide. Should benefit from the playing time though.

 

FW Robert Firmino, 6 -- Not much went right for Bobby. Gave the ball away loads, won it back quite a bit too but overall he’s been a little bit unconvincing in this new number ten role. If Klopp persists with it I expect he will get better, but the truth is we looked better after he was subbed today. The back heel nutmeg as he lay o the floor in front of the Kop was glorious though.

 

FW Sadio Mane, 7 -- I’ll be honest, I didn’t think he played too well but the goals were different class. His first summed him up. Looked like he’d messed it up and then produced a stunning finish out of nowhere. His second goal was a brilliant run and classy finish. Seven goals for him now this season, which is all the more impressive considering the barren run he had between his first four and last three.

 

FW Mohamed Salah, 8 -- Sharpest he’s looked all season, even though Cardiff actually played him quite well for most of the game. Sol Bamba stuck to his task really well but Mo just wore him down eventually. Good finish to open the scoring and then two nice assists to wrap things up. Looks like he’s back on track now.

 

Substitutes:

 

FW Xherdan Shaqiri, 7 -- Rested after a hectic couple of weeks for club and country, but wasted little time in making his presence felt when he replaced Lallana after an hour. Always on the move, always wants the ball, always wants to do something positive. His goal was boss. I love this little guy.  

 

MF James Milner, 6 -- Sent on to replace Bobby as Klopp went back to 4-3-3 for the closing stages. Did exactly what you’d expect him to do.

 

Manager Rating:

 

Jurgen Klopp, 7 -- Took the opportunity to freshen things up a bit and brought in Lovren, Moreno and Lallana. Many won’t have been happy about it, but we all accept the need for rotation so why do we get so annoyed when it happens. With all due respect to Cardiff, if you’re going to make changes then this is the type of game to do it.

 

Dave Usher

Edited by tlw content


Sign in to follow this  


User Feedback

Recommended Comments



9 hours ago, Scrump said:

No way Lovren deserved a seven. Skinned too easily for one of their chances and frequently looked like giving away silly fouls. 

Yeah, he was brutal. 

 

My my biggest problem was giving Lallana 1 point less than Shaq. Shaq channel the game, everything broke down with Lallana. Get a 3 from me and Shaq an 8. 

  • Upvote 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, ZonkoVille77 said:

Lovren was no more than a 6. He just brings panic to every occasion even though he did little wrong. 

I don’t think your feelings should be taken into account in awarding players ratings.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, Numero Veinticinco said:

My issue with Lovren isn’t how he makes me feel, it’s the mistakes he makes and the positions he takes up. 

That’s fair. I’d imagine Dave would take those into account as well. I just didn’t think Zonkovilles reasoning made a whole lot of sense, and was very unfair.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
Just now, aRdja said:

That’s fair. I’d imagine Dave would take those into account as well. I just didn’t think Zonkovilles reasoning made a whole lot of sense, and was very unfair.

Yeah, it’s not unusual for him to be honest. 

  • Downvote 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

In such a one sided game it's hard to pick out individuals. They all kept the ball pretty well and worked hard to get it back quickly. Defence had virtually nothing to do but made one error for their goal. We could have created more clear cut chances and been more clinical going forward. The only individual that really stood out was Salah.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lallana didn't have a great game but I don't think he was all that bad, he had a pretty demanding tactical role of constantly being alert to Salah and Firmino's movements to go forward every time they dropped deep and/or rotated and otherwise play on the right, where he is not particularly effective. He played a couple of intelligent one touch passes early on, had one good run into the box unspotted and came close to scoring, but it's true he didn't do enough on rare occasions when he did manage to get involved and got the ball.

Shaqiri on the other hand played with more freedom, more centrally, and did inject a lot of energy when he came on as he was constantly looking to make himself available, plus the constant scampering of those little feet in small yellow boots must make the opposition nervous.  But he didn't actually do all that much before Milner came on, later he played some great and quick passes and took his goal extremely well. However watching him, it may still be some time before Klopp starts fully trusting him to be tactically up to the task.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, VERBAL DIARRHEA said:

Lallana was shite. Another player we’ve outgrown.

I still think he can play a part this season, but his lack of pace is glaring in the context of everyone else being a jet-powered racing snake (c. RedKnight 2018). 

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
Just now, Paul said:

I still think he can play a part this season, but his lack of pace is glaring in the context of everyone else being a jet-powered racing snake (c. RedKnight 2018). 

Yeah he is so slow, slows everything down for us. Bit part player at best for me, when Shaqiri came on the difference was night and day.

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, stringvest said:

How quickly we forget.  An in-form and fit Lallana moves the ball forward more quickly than any of our midfielders.

I haven’t forgotten at all. He’s technically superb. However, since he was last a first team regular we’ve added more speed merchants to the point where every single outfield player is at least quick and most are lightening. We’ve changed our game a lot over the last year and he looks like much less of a fit now. 

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pace isn't everything.  Fabinho isn't exactly greased lightning but he's got enough of everything else to suggest he's going to be in the first team more than he's out of it.  Speed of thought is just as important as speed of foot.

  • Upvote 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites



Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×