Quantcast
Hall of Fame - Class of 2017 - Hall of Fame - Articles - Articles - Home

Jump to content


FREE TRIAL SUBSCRIPTION with every new registration!

Register on the forums today and receive one month's FREE access to all subscriber only content, including match reports, the TLW Diary and Premier League Round Ups. Registration costs nothing and there is no obligation to continue with your subscription once the free month trial has expired. 

 

To register a FREE account with us, click here, and then be sure to check the box for 'the FREE Monty' to receive immediate access to the subscriber only content and exclusive Members Forum.


Support the site

Follow TLW




TLW Facebook TLW Instagram TLW Podcast TLW Youtube TLW RSS

Advertisement

Snack Media

TLW T-Shirts

Uncle Sam Sports

Sponsored Links




- - - - -

Hall of Fame - Class of 2017


Having decided on the four founding members of the TLW Hall of Fame (or the TLW ‘Mount Rushmore’ if you like), it’s now time to elect the next four inductees, or if you like, the ‘Class of 2017’.
  
HOW IT WORKS 
 
The voting process will be the same as before, with a committee which will consist of representatives from TLW, the media, the former players association and also a popular fan vote, which is where you come in, by voting below.
 
Each year there will be a group of ten nominees, four of whom will be voted in. The six who don’t get in that year will remain on the ballot for the following year and beyond, until they are eventually selected. Those voted in will be replaced by four new names for the following year. 
 
There will be a separate category for managers & coaches, but for now we’re just concentrating on the players. 

 


 

Narrowing it down to ten was a thankless task and there will no doubt be names not on the list who you feel should be, because let’s face it, very few of us would name the same ten. 
 
It was not just a case of picking the ten greatest players, which in itself would also have been incredibly difficult. Other factors come into it, although only great players will be considered. For example, few would claim that Phil Neal was one of Liverpool’s ten most talented players of all time, but nobody can match his medal haul so how could he not be in the ten? 
 
We also felt that it was important to have a mix of players from across several eras rather than just selecting the greats of the 70s and 80s for example. Some missed out on the initial ten as a result of this (Alan Hansen and Emlyn Hughes to name but two), but over the coming years they’ll all be added to the mix. 
 
While it’s easy to argue for the inclusion of some not on the list, we feel it’s not so easy to argue against those who are on it, with the notable exception of Graeme Souness, for obvious reasons. We could have left him out, but rather than make that call ourselves we decided to include him in the ten and leave it in the hands of the voters whether he gets in or not. 
 
We really appreciate your support and participation, both in terms of voting and spreading the word by telling your friends and sharing on social media, and hopefully this can pick up momentum and grow each year. 
 
So without further ado, here’s the initial list of ten along with the poll underneath to cast your votes. Simply select the four names you feel should join Shankly, Paisley, Dalglish and Gerrard in the TLW Hall of Fame.
 
 
 

JOHN BARNES

 


 

One of the greatest players of his, or any other generation, Barnes was the star on what is regarded by many as the finest team in club history, but he is as much a cultural icon as he is a footballing one. His early time at Anfield saw him crowned Footballer of the Year on two separate occasions, and but for a serious injury that robbed him of a yard of pace it would surely have been more. A marvellous ambassador, a voice of common sense and a thoroughly lovely bloke.   

 

 

 

 

IAN CALLAGHAN

 

 

Liverpool's all time appearance leader and one of the game's true gentlemen. Local lad 'Cally' made his debut for the Reds in 1960 and his final appearance came eighteen years later, in 1978. In between he racked up 857 appearances, scoring 68 goals and winning a whole host of silverware. He was also a World Cup winner with England in 1966. 
 

 

 

 

JAMIE CARRAGHER

 

 

Second on the appearance list behind Callaghan, Bootle's finest represented the Reds 737 times over a 16 year first team career, winning everything except the league title. Brave, loyal, committed and talented, Carragher's finest hour was his courageous display in Istanbul when he fought through severe cramp in both legs to help keep AC Milan at bay and secure number five.
 

 

 

 

ROBBIE FOWLER

 

 

The most natural goalscorer to pull on the famous red shirt. Toxteth born Fowler burst onto the scene as an 18 year old and for the next few seasons took English football by storm, becoming the quickest Liverpool striker to reach 100 goals when he achieved the milestone in only his 165th game. A succession of injuries prevented him from sustaining that blistering form, but in two spells with the club Fowler amassed 183 goals and is one of the most loved players in club history.
 

 

  


ROGER HUNT

 

 

Dubbed 'Sir Roger' by the Kop, Hunt formed a lethal pairing with Ian St John to help inspire the Reds resurgence under Bill Shankly in the 1960s. He was part of the England squad that won the World Cup in 1966 and left the club in 1969 as Liverpool's record goalscorer with 285 strikes to his name.  

 

 

 

 
KEVIN KEEGAN

 

 

When Bill Shankly paid fourth division Scunthorpe £33,000 for an unknown 20 year old in 1971, no-one could have foreseen that within a few years Keegan would be one of the biggest stars in world football. Described by some as Liverpool's answer to George Best, Keegan became the club's first superstar and helped inspire the Reds to their first European Cup win in 1977 before departing for Hamburg, where he was twice named European Footballer of the Year.

 

 

 

 

BILLY LIDDELL

 

 

The Steven Gerrard of his day, Billy was an iconic figure who spent his entire professional career with Liverpool after joining as a 16 year old in 1938. World War II delayed his debut until 1946 but he soon made up for lost time, amassing 534 appearances and scoring 228 goals before his retirement in 1960. The Scot was held in such high esteem that the Reds were often referred to as "Liddellpool" for a time when he was in his pomp. 
 

 

 

 
PHIL NEAL

 

 

Phil Neal was a Liverpool player for 11 years, making 650 appearances and chipping in with 59 goals, many of them vitally important penalty kicks. A solid, dependable right back who rarely missed a game and even played with broken bones, Neal is the most decorated player in club history, having won eight league titles, four European Cups, one FA Cup, one UEFA Cup and four League Cups.   

 

 

 

 
IAN RUSH

 

 

The scourge of defences at home and abroad throughout the 1980s, Rush is Liverpool's all time record goalscorer having eclipsed the mark set by Hunt. He's also sixth on the appearance charts and scored five goals in three FA Cup finals, all of which Liverpool won. In his latter years he unselfishly took a step back from being the focal point of the attack and used all of his experience to help bring Fowler though as his successor.


 

 

 
GRAEME SOUNESS

 

 

In the halcyon days of the late 70s / early 80s, Souness was as big a factor in Liverpool's dominance as his fellow Scot Kenny Dalglish was. Unfortunately his return to the club as manager was not as successful and his catastrophic error with the S*n on the anniversary of Hillsborough has tainted him in the eyes of many. Liverpool have had few better or more influential players, however, than the hard as nails Scot.       
 

 

 

 

 

 
 


  • 0


34 Comments

I didn't vote.

Nobody is bigger than the club.
    • 0

I didn't vote.

Nobody is bigger than the club.

 

Translation: Rafa and Lucas aren't on it so I swerved it.

 

I actually think this one is pretty straightforward and finalising the shortlist of ten was much more difficult than picking my final four.

    • 0

The player one is a tougher poll, and I had to omit long-serving stalwarts like Callaghan and Carragher, as well as my all-time fave Barnes, and popular players like Fowler. I went with Liddell, Keegan, Souness and Rush in the end. Liddell was the standout player when the team was inconsistent pre-Shankly, and some older fans rate him as the club's greatest ever. Keegan was like the marquee player at a time when the club was establishing itself as a European superpower. Souness had immense will-to-win and a never say die attitude as well as being a perfect blend of silk and steel. And Rush was Rush, the greatest goalscorer the club has ever had, period.

    • 1
I voted twice for Barnes, and once each for Cally, Liddell, Carra, Fowler, Neal and Rush.

Might vote for Barnes again in a bit.
    • 0

Would be interested to know people's thoughts on the inclusion of Souness?

 

Spoke to a lot of people prior to finalising this and the general consensus was that he should be on the list of ten and people can then make their own mind up about whether they think he should get in or not.

 

I'm a little conflicted about it though, I won't be voting him in this time anyway as I already have my four, but next year is a different matter. All things being equal I'd definitely be voting for him next year, but all things aren't equal, and selecting him over someone who didn't do what he did doesn't really sit right. Then again, the man has apologised for it so should it be held against him for ever?

 

Tommy Smith is another difficult one, because he'd come into contention to be in the ten either next year or the year after maybe, but obviously there are, shall we say, 'character issues' there as well. His contribution to LFC is huge though and he paid a heavy price for that in later life. Brucie is another complicated one.

 

I think the right policy is to include them based on playing merits, and then if people don't want to pick them for other reasons that's down to the individual, but I'm keen to know what you, the TLW community, think.

    • 0
Won't be voting for Souness too young to remember him play but old enough to remember him as our manager.
    • 0
I can understand his inclusion on the list

I'll be voting for Parry, Konchesky and Sean Dundee before him, though.
    • 0
Tough one but I went for Liddell, Cally, Barnes and then Rush by a nose in front of Sir Roger.
    • 2

As this seems to be a poll for players it's only right that Souness is there. He's the best midfield player the club has had in my time watching and a terrific captain as well.

Keegan was another pick. I can't think of another player who has transformed the team as he did. The season before he arrived we scored 42 goals in 42 league games and the fottball was often terrible to watch, especially against teams that came to shut up shop (some things never change). Keegan inspired more or less the same team to come within a whisker of the title in his first season and then win it the next season, our first trophy for seven years.

If Keegan transformed the team, Barnes transformed the support. Before he arrived there was a nasty racist undertone to our support. Sometimes it was embarassing to be in the ground and listen to some of the chants. Barnes' brilliance, and his character, as Dave identifies, changed that almost overnight. Great player; significant man.

    • 2

Went for Callaghan, Carra, Fowler and Rush. 

    • 0
Liddell, Barnes, Callaghan, Rush
    • 1

Tough one but I went for Liddell, Cally, Barnes and then Rush by a nose in front of Sir Roger.

 

Very similar thought process but as my monicker would suggest, Sir Roger edged Rushy.

    • 1

Liddell top choice for me, stuck with the club through thick and thin. Then Barnes.  Then Cally.  Then Rush.

 

Emlyn would've probably made the cut.

    • 1
Liddell
Barnes
Callaghan
Souness
    • 1
Liddel
Barnes
Cally
Rush

As a few have already said i see. Souness gets in to every all time Liverpool XI in my opinion but the poor decisions he made mean he's not as loved as players like Cally etc. There also seems to be a lack of defenders. Hansen should be included ahead of Carra for example, maybe Emlyn Hughes too.

Missed the bit in Dave's post about them.
    • 0
    • 0
Went for Liddell, Hunt, Callaghan, and couldn't decide between Fowler and Barnes, so eventually went with Fowler.

Sorry, John.
    • 0

As good as he was, Souness shouldn't be near this. s*n loving r*ngers prick 

    • 0

As good as he was, Souness shouldn't be near this. s*n loving r*ngers prick 

 

What if he was a S*n loving C*ltic prick?

    • 0

What if he was a S*n loving C*ltic prick?

 

The fact he did it so soon after wouldn't change my opinion. He should have fucking better known better. 

    • 0

My boy Rush rightly walking this.

    • 0

Cally, Keegan, Rush and Barnes.

    • 0
Souness is rightfully there. That said I voted for Liddell, Hunt, Keegan and Callaghan.
    • 1

I forgive Souness a stupid post-playing act... because he was an absolutely brilliant, inspirational captain and servant of Liverpool and right up there with a chance of getting a spot in LFC's best-ever XI.

 

Forgive and forget for me.  

    • 2
Barnes, Callaghan, Liddell & Rush

And an extra vote to impeach Dave for finding the shittiest survey app in existence
    • 0