Quantcast
If you could sign anyone outside of the top four, who would it be? - The Burning Question - Articles - Articles - Home

Jump to content


FREE TRIAL SUBSCRIPTION with every new registration!

Register on the forums today and receive one month's FREE access to all subscriber only content, including match reports, the TLW Diary and Premier League Round Ups. Registration costs nothing and there is no obligation to continue with your subscription once the free month trial has expired. 

 

To register a FREE account with us, click here, and then be sure to check the box for 'the FREE Monty' to receive immediate access to the subscriber only content and exclusive Members Forum.


Support the site

Follow TLW




TLW Facebook TLW Instagram TLW Podcast TLW Youtube TLW RSS

Advertisement

Snack Media

TLW T-Shirts

Uncle Sam Sports

Sponsored Links




- - - - -

If you could sign anyone outside of the top four, who would it be?


The days of the Reds shopping in Harrods appear to be over. Hell, even Marks & Spencers might be wishful thinking at the moment, but you can still pick up a good deal at Asda or Morrisons. Brendan likes shopping in the Premier League, so if, hypothetically, you had your pick of any player from a club outside of the top four, who would you go for? Three of our writers - reluctantly - took the challenge and here's what they came up with...

Asking what player I’d like to sign from a team that isn’t in the top four is like asking what type of Tesco Value product I’d like. Sure I can have any one I’d like, but it’s not exactly appetising compared to the other stuff around. Things are pretty drab around the club right now with Gerrard leaving, Rodgers clinging onto the precipice and the owners who are doing God knows what. The lack of commitment to spend big money on big players means we’re more likely to sign players from lower Premier League sides than top European clubs. 
 
I’ve thought about this and quite frankly I think most of the players at other teams in the Premier League are bums. Southampton has a few decent ones, Spurs have a couple and Everton has one and the rest? Not really, certainly nothing that excites me. Looking at our team you’d ideally want a significant upgrade on what we have and with that in mind, I’d take Hugo Lloris from Spurs. He’s an international keeper who has played at major tournaments with France and he’s probably one of the best keepers in the league. De Gea is better, Courtois is arguably better and that’s it. Mignolet has done well in the second half of the last season, which is to his credit considering he was dropped for Brad freakin’ Jones, but Lloris is the better player. He commands his area, his kicking is way better than Mignolet’s, although that isn’t hard, and he’s a terrific shot-stopper. 
 
Something modern Liverpool never learns is that you make you squad better by making your first team better. You’d buy Lloris to be number one because he is better than what you have and Mignolet could take a seat. Unfortunately he’s that good that he’s been linked with United to replace the probably departing De Gea and PSG have also been sniffing around. This is no knock on Mignolet but if you can buy better, you do, and if we’re having free swings at players outside the top four, I’m getting the player who’s the best in their position. 
 


Julian Richards

@Juleswithnoname

 
 
 
As tempting as it is for numerous reasons to say Ross Barkley, I’m going to have to go with Harry Kane. While there is still the small risk that he could be a one season wonder, based solely on what he showed last season I’d take Kane because he’s exactly what we are lacking.

He scores all kinds of goals, he leads the line well and his work rate is incredible. Maybe statistics will prove otherwise (I haven’t checked), but based purely on what my eyes tell me, there were times last season when Kane’s work ethic made Dirk Kurt look like Victor Moses. We’ve missed that since Suarez left and while Kane obviously isn’t fit to lace the boots of Luis, if I could take one player outside of the top four sides then right now it’s Kane by a distance simply because we don’t have enough goals and he’d be the one most likely to provide them.

Given all that he brings to the table I’d even be willing to overlook how much I dislike his face and how greatly his hair offends me. Of course there’s not a chance in hell of it happening as why would he swap Spurs for us? They’ve finished above us five out of the last six seasons so painful as it is to admit, Anfield would be a step down for him. If the question was who would you take that you could realistically get then it wouldn’t be Kane (or indeed Barkley), so I’d probably say Nathaniel Clyne or Morgan Schneiderlin.
 

Dave Usher
@theliverpoolway

 

 

 

Answering this question is a bit like that odd game where someone gives you two horrible options to choose from and you are expected to pick the least worst. Would you spend the night with Dot Cotton or would you buy another mediocre player from a mid-table Premier League side? Apparently doing neither isn’t allowed because you’re spoiling the game.

 

Given the amount of money that has just been dropped into the Premier League coffers the teams have much less need to sell their players and as such the value of anything you buy goes out the window. But, if I have to take someone then it is probably going to be Morgan Schneiderlin from Southampton.

 

The main focus of the summer should be to get goals into the team. That’s priority number one.  The problem is that there isn’t really a wealth of good options for that that I can choose from here so sorting out the other, much smaller, issue of having a decent shield for the back four that is mobile, technically decent and of a level that can improve us is what I’d do. The fact that he’s played with some of last season’s signings and that he’s been coached to play in a team that presses are very much bonuses on top of just his basic range of abilities being ones we could do with.

 

Whether it would be in any way sensible to pay someone £30m for him is a totally different prospect though, and one that isn’t at all appetising. That £30m is probably going to put a lot more points on the board if you direct it towards someone that is offering the possibility of lots of goals. There are other lads in Europe that can probably do the same job as the most German sounding Frenchman ever, and for a fraction of the cost.

 

As we’ve seen recently, players that have a good record in this league can carry just as much risk of failure as players that have never set foot here, so you have to ask why you’d be paying double the price for them, if that’s the case?

 

Stu Montagu

@SimianJustice


  • 0


48 Comments

Danny Ings
    • 0
We need goals. Kane.
    • 0
Kane's a one season wonder, he'll be lucky to score 12 league goals next season and like Benteke is nothing like the forward we need.

Lloris by a mile.
    • 0
Coleman.
    • 1

Morgan Schneiderlin.. would provide so much stability as a proper DM.

    • 0
James McCarthy
    • 0
I'd have Mirallas
    • 0

Morgan Schneiderlin.. would provide so much stability as a proper DM.

Is right.

He is the player we should have got from there last summer instead of the slowest striker in the league, or the show pony we didn't really need, or the defensive bomb scare.
    • 0

I'd definitely take Lloris, Kane, Stones or Schneiderlin, but for me the best player of the lot would be Victor Wanyama.

 

Not that Brendan would ever play him, but I think he's one of the main reasons Southampton are so solid defensively (though Schneiderlin next to him certainly contributes as well).  We bought Lovren because he looked a good defender, and the reason he looked a good defender was the pair of them ahead of him.  I still go back to when he was at Celtic and played against Barcelona and was one of the best players on the pitch at age 20 or so with all of Barca's worldies up against him.  Still young as well with a big future in front of him.

 

Play Wanyama and Can in the 2 of a 4-2-3-1 and you'd sort out about 75% of our defensive problems.  It would allow the fullbacks to get right up the pitch (meaning you could play players like Ibe and Markovic in those positions without worrying about their defensive frailties) and we would be a much better side.  Of course all of this is meaningless because Rodgers won't ever play with a destroyer type in midfield, but that would be my vote.

    • 1

I'd have Mirallas

I'd sign him too just to stop the veins in my head popping out every time he plays against us in a Derby the little shit bag.

He's a proper cunt, a cunts cunt. Not bad either
    • 0

We need goals. Kane.


This.

We saw before Sturridge was signed, and then again last season, that without a hard working forward Rodgers' sides look lethargic.
    • 0
Based solely on gut feeling about his full potential, Ross Barkley. He's the closest thing to a young Gerrard since, well, a young Gerrard. I'm not sure we'd use him properly or that he plays in a position that's a priority. However, I think he could become world class.
    • 0
I wouldn't sign any of them. Nobody is bigger than the club.
    • 3
Has to be a DM. Dont watch much English footy apart from us but it seems Scheiderlin fits the bill.
    • 0
Anyone but a defensive midfielder.
    • 0
Anyone from the Southampton
    • 0

J-Punch not your boy any more Dave?

    • 0

Wanyama has gone backwards a bit. Still think he would do a job with us though.

    • 0
I'm surprised no one has mentioned Christian Eriksen yet.

I know he wasn't world class last season but he's going to be a bloody footballer.
    • 1

Has our transfer committee put you up to this?

    • 3

I'm surprised no one has mentioned Christian Eriksen yet.

I know he wasn't world class last season but he's going to be a bloody footballer.


Yeah but if we bought all the Spurs team we'd be as far down the league as they are.
    • 0

I despise Kane, Schneiderlin, Lloris, Barkley, Clyne and someone else/don't want anyone from the PL already.

    • 2
I've got it down to 3.

Defender = Clyne (Southampton)
Midfielder = Schneiderlin (Southampton)
Attacker = Diafra Sakho (West Ham)


I like that Sakho, he's just a cunt who loves to bust a gut to get on the end of a cross or a through ball.
    • 1

John Stones. Bargain for them lot at £3 million and would walk into our team at centre back at the moment.

    • 1

I'm surprised no one has mentioned Christian Eriksen yet.

I know he wasn't world class last season but he's going to be a bloody footballer.

 

 

Eriksen for me too.

 

Bit of guile and craft to add to our Graft

    • 0