Jump to content
tlw content
tlw content

2016/17 Season Report Card: Nathaniel Clyne

Nathaniel Clyne’s season went very much the same way as the team as a whole. Terrific before New Year but found it tough going after that and just didn’t look anywhere near as effective when Sadio Mané wasn’t there.  

 

Clyne is a full back whose biggest strength is defending, which is a rare commodity at top clubs these days. That’s not to say he doesn’t offer anything in attack, but he’s very streaky in that respect and more accomplished defending than he is attacking. He should be better than he is going forward though. I always feel like he doesn’t back himself enough and if he did he’d be much more of a threat. 
 
In the closing months of the season he just seemed to be a momentum killer. So many times the ball would go out to him and the attack would grind to a complete halt, as he looked to pass it back or inside, rather than carry it down the line and commit the opposing full back. Often his first touch would automatically take him back towards his own goal, and that demonstrated his mindset to me. 
 
In fairness, the loss of Mané had a bigger impact on Clyne than anybody else I’d say, as it put more emphasis on him to be the sole attacking outlet on the right and he’s just not capable of it. It’s bloody hard playing full back for Klopp as not only do you need to continually be up with the attack providing the width, you’re also expected to be back in position any time it breaks down. Clyne and James Milner were expected to be wingers as well as full backs all season, and that takes a toll, not just physically but also mentally. 
 
Thankfully Clyne and Milner are two of the most durable, reliable players in the squad and neither missed much playing time. Clyne rarely gets injured and even when he does he often just plays through it anyway. 
 
All things considered, Clyne did a solid job for us this season and although much of the frustration with him late in the year was valid, it’s hard not to have some sympathy for Clyne. We complain about full backs who want to go forward but can’t defend *cough* Moreno *cough* but we’re not happy with those who are dependable at the back end but lack a bit in the final third either. Very few can do both, and those who can are usually playing for more successful teams than us. 
 
I do get the feeling there’s more to come from Clyne in an attacking sense and if he’s to retain his place there’ll need to be. We do see occasionally what he’s capable of but it just doesn’t happen often enough. He should benefit next year from not having to play every game and also from having Mané back in front of him. Increased competition for his place should also see him step up a level.  
 

 

Best Moment: 
 
Not too many memorable moments from him and I’m tempted to say nicking Wijnaldum’s phone during the lap of appreciation and posting “I’m the man!” on his Instagram, forcing an embarrassed Gini to apologise and explain that Clyne had stitched him up. 
 
He did produce a brilliant run and cross to create a goal for Coutinho at Arsenal, and a peach of a ball in to set one up for Lallana at Middlesbrough, so let’s go with one of those. 

 
Worst Moment:
 
I asked a few of the lads for suggestions on this and the first reply I got was"every time he crossed the half way line". In terms of specific moments, there was a sloppy pass at Burnley led to them going one up and we were unable to recover from it and eventually lost 2-0 after conceding one on the break.
 
He doesn't tend to make too many mistakes in general, which is why those he does make stand out.  
 
Rating:
 
6.5 / 10. Steady, reliable, durable, but ultimately needs to be much more assertive when going forward if he is to continue to be an automatic selection. 
 
The Future? 
 
Might be rotated a lot more than he’s used to next season, but will still feature prominently. Will definitely be under more pressure from Trent Alexander-Arnold next season and could even face competition from Milner too (more on that tomorrow though). Nevertheless, Clyne’s dependability makes him useful to have around and with the increased fixture load next year he’ll continue to be an important player, particularly in the more difficult fixtures.

Edited by tlw content


User Feedback

Recommended Comments

I would rate Clyne easily as 8.5/10.

 

It's not his fault that when Mane is out we don't play with width, so he's got far too much of the ball and its also not his fault that Klopp refuses to rest him, because he's terrified of what may happen.

 

Clyne is the exact type of signing we should be making more. Good price, seasoned player and huge potential.

 

Also, it's kinda nice not to have Southampton go balls deep in us without lubrication, as they're about to do again this summer with Van Dijk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just read the opening post, and at least, three different times Dave wanted to say, "he's young, black and a Rb, so I thought he'd be a lot better going forward" but had to diplomatically refrase that masses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also, Dave, what are you doing Gini's instagram?

 

I get that he's really handsome, still, though...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He coast me a fortune with my stupid first goal Clyne bet all season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was very frustrating, but there were certainly mitigating factors without any right hand support sans Mane, and nobody making any real effort to get in the box from Xmas onwards.

 

With no international tournament this summer and hopefully at least one player brought in who actually wants to score scruffy goals in and around the six yard box, I am expecting a good season for Clyne next season.

 

As for highlights, he put probably his best cross of the season in the Southampton game & watched on as Coutinho let it hit him in the face, go sideways and then bounce off Divvy out for a goal kick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm telling you, he needs to get a haircut. It'd be the like the anti-Samson.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think hes fine for next season, we need a bit more cover there in the squad as I reckon he'll start to burn out again, especially with European games, but think Milner (freed from the left and Flanno can provide that).  Would like to see TAA tried ahead of him a few times, encourage him to take responsibility a bit more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also, Dave, what are you doing Gini's instagram?

 

I get that he's really handsome, still, though...

 

I wasn't, I'm not on instagram. I only know about it because I saw a clip on LFCTV of Clyne laughing with Gomez telling him what he'd done, and then Gini having a go at him when he realised.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wasn't, I'm not on instagram. I only know about it because I saw a clip on LFCTV of Clyne laughing with Gomez telling him what he'd done, and then Gini having a go at him when he realised.

It worries me whether she can cope with the demands of LFCTV now that it's improved so much. Yesterday, in a Thursday night show previewing Saturday's match (which made so much better sense than it being on a Friday - another masterstroke of rescheduling), Claire Rourke had to oversee Didi Hamman trying to eat an apple off a bit of string, Dave Kirby trying to lob a ball into a dustbin and Davey Fairclough once again sounding as though he was trying to put on a brave face even though he, and only he, knew that his cat had been kidnapped and would be executed if he accidentally said one of a possible five trigger words. It was superb entertainment, superbly hosted by the anorexic Clurr, causing me to immediately get withdrawal symptoms as soon as she said that obligatory 'But from me, it's goodbye'. The whole channel now is at such a high level I fear that this bit of twiggy totty might spoil the delicate mix. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. That's my view, anyway. But from me, it's goodbye.

 

The phone-ins are spectacular outside broadcasts from Planet Stupid.. A typical call goes like this:

 

CLUR: Next up we've got Marvin on the line. What's your question, Marvin?

CALLER: Martin. It's Martin?

CLUR: Martin?

CALLER: Hello?

CLUR: Are you there, Martin?

CALLER: I'm not Marvin, I'm Martin. Hello?

CLUR: Sorry, Martin, What's your question Martin?

CALLER: [The echoey sound of him listening to his own TV]

CLUR: Martin, can you do us a favour and  turn your TV down?

CALLER: Hello?

CLUR: What's your question?

CALLER: Okay, I'll turn me TV down. Hang on.

CLUR: Quickly Martin, what's your question?

CALLER: Can you hear me now?

CLUR: Martin?

CALLER: Sorry about that, Clur. How are you?

CLUR: Fine Martin, what's your question?

CALLER: Hello Saint. Hello Aldo. I saw both of you lots of times. I saw you Saint-

CLUR: Martin, we're running out of time, what's your question?

CALLER: Er, yeah, sorry, I just wanted to say: Luis Suarez. What a player. I wondered what the Saint and Aldo have to say about that.

ALDO: ...Yeah, well, you know, I think Marvin's spot on, you know, er, Luis is a great player, you know, he really is, so I agree.

SAINT: Aye, yes, Soooaaarez is a top player. I don't think there's any doubt about that..So I have to agree with...er...what was his name?

CLUR: Does that answer your question, Martin? Martin? MARTIN??? MARTIN??? I think he's gone.

Coming up very soon on LFCTV in 2014:

 

Celebrity Kop Club: Another series of the must-see chat show with famous Reds. In this series, John Bishop will be interviewing that bloke off that show that got cancelled a while ago, that woman who used to be in Emmerdale, Pete Best, a dentist and Josemi. 

 

Cob on the Corners: Aldo's least favourite corners from the last four seasons.

 

Short Shorts: Fifty brief episodes featuring your favourite LFC shorts from the past 40 years, complete with authentic-sounding new commentary from Steve Hunter.

 

Pig in a Poke: Hidden camera show in which legendary Reds keeper Tommy Lawrence pokes people in pubs and then pretends it wasn't him. Much hilarity ensues in the confusion.

 

Oh My Word: John Bradley hosts LFCTV's first ever game show, loosely based on Call  My Bluff.

 

Claire's Game: Claire Rourke devises a stupid new studio game every week to make former players look incredibly pathetic.

 

Is Vic There?: A compilation of the most memorable  'Call LFCTV' phone calls, featuring idiots who try to listen to their own phone calls on their TV sets, idiots who call in and then appear to think that the show has called them, idiots who call in only to say how much they like the people in the studio whilst mispronouncing all of their names, and Darren from Thetford.

 

Hunter's Chicken: LFC commentator Steve Hunter is given a very dangerous task to attempt each week, which he fails to accept.

 

Operation Anfield: Whacky anatomist Dr Gunther von Hagens performs a live operation in the centre circle during half time  at each home game. First up: Alberto Aquilani.

  • Upvote 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think he was weaker defensively second half too. There were crosses coming in from his side more regularly and he was caught out on the break a few times too.

 

Matip being in and out can;t have helped either, as he often looks much better alongside him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I wasn't, I'm not on instagram. I only know about it because I saw a clip on LFCTV of Clyne laughing with Gomez telling him what he'd done, and then Gini having a go at him when he realised.

It worries me whether she can cope with the demands of LFCTV now that it's improved so much. Yesterday, in a Thursday night show previewing Saturday's match (which made so much better sense than it being on a Friday - another masterstroke of rescheduling), Claire Rourke had to oversee Didi Hamman trying to eat an apple off a bit of string, Dave Kirby trying to lob a ball into a dustbin and Davey Fairclough once again sounding as though he was trying to put on a brave face even though he, and only he, knew that his cat had been kidnapped and would be executed if he accidentally said one of a possible five trigger words. It was superb entertainment, superbly hosted by the anorexic Clurr, causing me to immediately get withdrawal symptoms as soon as she said that obligatory 'But from me, it's goodbye'. The whole channel now is at such a high level I fear that this bit of twiggy totty might spoil the delicate mix. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. That's my view, anyway. But from me, it's goodbye.

 

The phone-ins are spectacular outside broadcasts from Planet Stupid.. A typical call goes like this:

 

CLUR: Next up we've got Marvin on the line. What's your question, Marvin?

CALLER: Martin. It's Martin?

CLUR: Martin?

CALLER: Hello?

CLUR: Are you there, Martin?

CALLER: I'm not Marvin, I'm Martin. Hello?

CLUR: Sorry, Martin, What's your question Martin?

CALLER: [The echoey sound of him listening to his own TV]

CLUR: Martin, can you do us a favour and  turn your TV down?

CALLER: Hello?

CLUR: What's your question?

CALLER: Okay, I'll turn me TV down. Hang on.

CLUR: Quickly Martin, what's your question?

CALLER: Can you hear me now?

CLUR: Martin?

CALLER: Sorry about that, Clur. How are you?

CLUR: Fine Martin, what's your question?

CALLER: Hello Saint. Hello Aldo. I saw both of you lots of times. I saw you Saint-

CLUR: Martin, we're running out of time, what's your question?

CALLER: Er, yeah, sorry, I just wanted to say: Luis Suarez. What a player. I wondered what the Saint and Aldo have to say about that.

ALDO: ...Yeah, well, you know, I think Marvin's spot on, you know, er, Luis is a great player, you know, he really is, so I agree.

SAINT: Aye, yes, Soooaaarez is a top player. I don't think there's any doubt about that..So I have to agree with...er...what was his name?

CLUR: Does that answer your question, Martin? Martin? MARTIN??? MARTIN??? I think he's gone.

Coming up very soon on LFCTV in 2014:

 

Celebrity Kop Club: Another series of the must-see chat show with famous Reds. In this series, John Bishop will be interviewing that bloke off that show that got cancelled a while ago, that woman who used to be in Emmerdale, Pete Best, a dentist and Josemi. 

 

Cob on the Corners: Aldo's least favourite corners from the last four seasons.

 

Short Shorts: Fifty brief episodes featuring your favourite LFC shorts from the past 40 years, complete with authentic-sounding new commentary from Steve Hunter.

 

Pig in a Poke: Hidden camera show in which legendary Reds keeper Tommy Lawrence pokes people in pubs and then pretends it wasn't him. Much hilarity ensues in the confusion.

 

Oh My Word: John Bradley hosts LFCTV's first ever game show, loosely based on Call  My Bluff.

 

Claire's Game: Claire Rourke devises a stupid new studio game every week to make former players look incredibly pathetic.

 

Is Vic There?: A compilation of the most memorable  'Call LFCTV' phone calls, featuring idiots who try to listen to their own phone calls on their TV sets, idiots who call in and then appear to think that the show has called them, idiots who call in only to say how much they like the people in the studio whilst mispronouncing all of their names, and Darren from Thetford.

 

Hunter's Chicken: LFC commentator Steve Hunter is given a very dangerous task to attempt each week, which he fails to accept.

 

Operation Anfield: Whacky anatomist Dr Gunther von Hagens performs a live operation in the centre circle during half time  at each home game. First up: Alberto Aquilani.

 

 

I've repped this for GK Macca by proxy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He'd be lucky to get a 5/10 from me.

 

Terrible going forward and not even solid defensively. I lost count the number of times crosses would come in and he'd completely switched off and lost his man.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

He'd be lucky to get a 5/10 from me.

Ha, ha, ha! I love the sheer pomposity of the way you've phrased this; the implicit assumption that your rating is something he craves. Brilliant.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's no Steve Finnan.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ha, ha, ha! I love the sheer pomposity of the way you've phrased this; the implicit assumption that your rating is something he craves. Brilliant.

Yeah, that's exactly what it is.

 

Get over yourself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with Dave in that he has all the tools going forward, he just needs to believe in himself more.

 

No problem at all with him starting next season at right back, I would like to see some improvement in him though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He's no Steve Finnan.

Finnan was an average Joe, and he pisses all over Clyne.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's his decision making in the opposition half that lets him down.  This can be improved through coaching though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He hasn't kicked on as much as I would have hoped.  He's a solid right back.  Doesn't miss many through injury.  Doesn't do anything out of the ordinary.

 

Would think next season TAA will get the nod against smaller teams at home and Clyne to get the nod against the more difficult games

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to say I was disappointed with Clyne overall last season.

He appeared caught up with the general malaise that swept through the team after Christmas and throughout that killer January and he didn't really recover.

Too ponderous on the ball, causing loss of momentum at times when we needed him to bomb forwards, and caught ball watching on the back post when needing to defend sometimes.

Thankfully, he's got a decent close season to get his head right as he has shown on enough occasions he can cross dangerously, and defend with effectiveness.

As with all our defenders, an extended run together should get their understanding going and that will help their general play.

Having Alexander-Arnold in the wings will keep him on his toes and also give him a rest should he need it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think he needs a Fog On The Tyne chant.

 

Nathaniel Clyne all mine, all mine

Nathaniel Clyne all mine

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think he needs a Fog On The Tyne chant.

 

Nathaniel Clyne all mine, all mine

Nathaniel Clyne all mine

 

That's absolutely horrendous, but I like the fact you didn't care about that and posted it anyway.

 

*high five*

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think he needs a Fog On The Tyne chant.

 

Nathaniel Clyne all mine, all mine

Nathaniel Clyne all mine

Don't ring us, we'll ring you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Repped for sheer audacity.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...