Jermaine or Yossi?

[aws]

Both have done OK and are worth a squad place. I'd only sell them if we were going to bring in someone clearly better.

[109_ultra]

JP started really well, and i think he was MOM more than once in the early part of the season. Was unlucky with the injury as he never rediscovered his early season promise. Would have to go for Yossi overall though as his end product is better.

[Judge]

Originally Posted by shanks59

Yossis 100% works against dross, we don't need him, he simply isn't good enough.

Sunday was typical , he came on for 20 minutes, can anyone remember him doing anything? Ditch both

Like the brilliant set up of the goal against Chelsea? Or his terrific performance in the FA cup final for West Ham against Liverpool?

[Faustus]

Keep them both.

Obviously neither are world beaters but they're both good squad players and have different qualities.

As Rafa would say, "they give us posshibilities, no?"

[benolad]

I'd sell them both if possible, we need better players it's a simple as that, however I've voted for Pennant simply because Pennant in best form is better and more dangerous than Yossi at top form in my opinion.

[MLB]

If we had to sell one it'd be Yossi. If we can keep them both though I would as they'll be good squad players, and for me Pennant has the ability to force himself into the side more regularly - certainly for as long as Kuyt is in the position.

[shanks59]

Originally Posted by Judge

Like the brilliant set up of the goal against Chelsea? Or his terrific performance in the FA cup final for West Ham against Liverpool?

Pity he did nothing else all game?

We effectively played with 10 men in the first half. Essien swatted him like a fly .. it was fuckin pathetic

He isn't upto it. West Ham is where he belongs

[Liam]

I would sell them both but only if two better players became available. Neither are consistent enough although when they are at their best they can be very good. I would offload Pennant first as he doesnt fit in to our new system.

I can see Pennant linking back up with Bruce at Wigan.