Cafe Sports

Asda
Next
GAME
Next

Home | Forums | Shop | Blog | Gallery | Arcade | Livescore | TLW Live | Travel
Go Back   The Liverpool Way > TLW Discussion forums > FF - Football Forum


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Sponsored Links
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 10:03 AM
Forumite
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 35
vCash: 500
9999 is an unknown quantity
AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Consecutive convincing wins against two of the more esteemed and cash-rich clubs, and suddenly a wave of pessimism is swept away by a tide of belief.

http://www.liverpoolfc.tv/news/drill...60927-0819.htm

Last season it took until mid-October to get the league form in full flow. Now the Reds appear to be fully up and running a whole month earlier. Clearly the idea that the season was over after four games was ludicrously premature. The Reds have plundered six points in the last two games, while Manchester United, the early pacesetters, have dropped five points in a week. That's how quickly things change.

This is now Benítez's squad, but it could still be a couple more months before the newly-assembled team is at its best. In the meantime it's important to get as many points on the board as possible, and continue to build some momentum. Squad rotation, and the fitness preparation of the players, will lead to benefits in the new year; rather than be out in the lead at the halfway stage the Reds merely need to be well placed.

Most of the new players continue to show signs of settling in well, and even those who have yet to find their best form have added an extra dimension in some form or other; they've helped change the style of play.

I don't think there's ever been a time in the history of the club when just getting into the squad of 16 was such a challenge. People talk about not knowing what the best XI is, and indeed, some even suggest that Rafa himself does not know his best team. But when such assumptions are because there are so many good options, that's a nice problem to have; it's not like he's struggling to find eleven decent players.

And with fitness, form, freshness and injuries all to be taken into account, is there ever a definitive 'best team' anyway? Is it better to play your best player when he's unfit and lacking confidence, or a slightly inferior player who's in the form of his life? Or is it so wrong to pick a player to exploit an opponent's glaring weakness? Rafa picks teams that can win games, and therefore win trophies, and over the past five years he's proved as good as anybody at doing so.

Some fans wanted to know where Crouch, Gonzalez, Fowler and Garcia were during the Chelsea game; had they played, it would have been four others whose absence was being pondered. The truth is some very good players will be in the stands, in suits, on match days. Crouch will be disappointed at not having started the last four games, and Fowler will be frustrated at not being in the squad. But their time will come. No one is excluded for too long.

Rafa clearly likes flexibility, options. It's not just the number of players at his disposal who could walk into most Premiership teams, but the sheer variety of their talents. No two players are stylistically akin. They may share some traits, but each offers something different, to change the pattern of a game.

There are now two pacy wingers at the club, who are capable of hitting the byline. There's also Steven Gerrard, who can deliver sublime quality from the right flank, or drift infield from the left side onto his right foot, into goalscoring positions. But when Luis Garcia plays wide, it's a totally different proposition.

The shape of the team can be changed so radically from one game to the next; at times it may backfire, as can any team selection on any given day, but on the whole it adds two or three extra dimensions. In theory, every month this newly assembled squad spends together then so its effectiveness should grow. New players will develop understandings with the existing players, and everyone will understand his own role that bit better. Of all the top clubs, Liverpool are currently integrating the most key new players. And that even includes a January newcomer in Daniel Agger, who has yet to play a dozen games for the club, but at times looks like he's played 200.

One of the things I've been working on with statistician Oliver Anderson is something called 'goal effect'. It was developed for our book, The Red Review, but it's something we continue to monitor. Goal effect is something to measure how each player's inclusion in the team effects the amount of goals scored and conceded, when compared with the team's average over the course of the season. It's their own individual 'goal difference' rating.

For instance, when Didi Hamann played last season the Reds conceded fractionally less than the norm, but the team also scored 10 fewer goals than average during his total minutes on the pitch. Other players, like Peter Crouch and Harry Kewell, helped the team score a lot more than the average, but their inclusion coincided with the Reds conceding more.

Of course a lot depends on which games these players featured in, and what their role was (for instance, Hamann's was often to come on late in games to help shut up shop). But it's another way to look at the players who might not be grabbing the headlines, but whose inclusion in the team has positive effects.

As with all stats, the smaller the sample period, the more likely it is to be skewed; longer periods start to show genuine trends. Last season Agger, in his mere four league games, possessed one of the top rates for the Reds. He had by far the best average when it came to the amount of goals the Reds scored in his games; the team also won a far greater number of points than they averaged over all 62 games (based on three points for cup wins). Over the course of the season, the team averaged 2.09 points per game; in Agger's four that went up to 2.50.

But of course, that was such a small sample. The interesting thing, however, is that it is a trend that has only strengthened this time around. The sample is still fairly small, but Agger's presence in the team certainly seems to be having a positive effect. Is it merely coincidental?

Luis Garcia is another player who continues to show up impressively; his minutes may have been limited over the past 14 months, but in those minutes he has been directly involved in more Premiership goals than any other Liverpool player.

For the book, Oliver and I developed an assist system that takes into account the last two passes, not just the final ball. It's not designed to measure the 'killer' pass, as that could be any in the move: final, penultimate (like Alonso's for Kuyt's goal against Newcastle), or even earlier. It's more a measure of those players who have a direct involvement in goals; those who help provide a cutting edge.

Last year, the top player when adding together assists and goals-per-minute in Premiership play was Luis Garcia. While he is yet to open his scoring account this season, he is already 'assisting' goals at a phenomenal rate: nearly 1.4 for every 90 minutes of league football. (Last season he was top of the Liverpool chart in this category, with 0.51 assists every 90 minutes. His current rate is nearly three times as prolific).

Say what you like about stats, but findings like these highlight the belief many fans hold: Luis Garcia makes things happen.

Another facet of play mentioned in this column is the number of long range goals the Reds score, and how few they concede. John Arne Riise's goal on Saturday was the 50th scored by Liverpool from outside the box since Benítez arrived. But at the rate Xabi Alonso is going, we might have to start measuring goals from even further out.

Precious few players score one goal from inside their own half in their entire careers, let alone two consecutively: one with the left foot, the other with the right. (What next, a header from the halfway line?)

While Alonso's goal rightly won the headlines last Wednesday, Dirk Kuyt's was the more important. Not only did it end the club's barren spell of three games, and ultimately decide the match, it also got the Dutchman off the mark in English football. The first goal for any striker is nearly always the hardest, especially when going up a level in quality or competitiveness.

There may be more technically gifted strikers in the game, but few who work as hard, and who are as mentally and physically tough. I have seen comparisons with Kevin Keegan and Mark Hughes; Kuyt certainly possesses Keegan's energy and ability to make the most out of his talent, while he has Hughes' physique and hold-up ability. But there's also a more predatory nature than either of those two luminaries.

I'd always prefer to see someone like Kuyt in the side – an up-and-coming, hungry team player – than an older superstar such as Ronaldo. Kuyt's enthusiasm and perfect attitude lifts his team-mates. He is the kind of player who unites a team. But he can still get the goals that win games.

The more players like Kuyt, Carragher, Gerrard and Sissoko you have in your side then the greater that indefinable extra amount of effort you get from the whole: when the team exceeds the sum of its parts. Hard work becomes infectious. Peter Crouch is similar, in that he plays for the team, and Craig Bellamy's style involves never letting up and taking a rest. There's not one 'passenger' in this squad. Whatever team Rafa picks will contain match-winners and, frankly, just winners.

It just needed those two home games to give the league a more realistic appearance, and to even out the home and away fixtures. Now there is clearly some momentum, and with three clean sheets in four games, some of the familiar stability at the back, too. There's a long way to go, but the race is underway.
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 10:06 AM
DT's Avatar
DT DT is offline
made guy
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Copenhagen
Posts: 17,592
vCash: 900
DT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the ProclaimersDT rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Spam
__________________
Goddamnit Alexis, I want that pipeline!
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 10:17 AM
The Bugged Out's Avatar
Forumite
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: lark lane
Posts: 757
vCash: 500
The Bugged Out is likedThe Bugged Out is likedThe Bugged Out is likedThe Bugged Out is liked
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Quote:
Originally Posted by DT
Spam
Spamalot!
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 10:26 AM
Kurt's Avatar
Kurt Kurt is offline
Another prick on parole
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 6,538
vCash: 500
Kurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the ProclaimersKurt rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Quote:
Originally Posted by DT
Spam
*Adopting Ford Fairlane voice*

"No, you`re a piece of spam, cos that`s what i think of you"

__________________
--- Torres is the kind of guy had I found him in my bed with my missus, I would have tucked him in so he would`nt freeze--- Kurt

---To do stepovers, or not to do stepovers, that is the Quarestion--- Hamlet

--- To think before you speak, is like wiping your arse before taking a shit--- Arne And
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 10:44 AM
MLB MLB is offline
Forumite
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 6,833
vCash: 500
MLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud ofMLB has much to be proud of
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

God almighty, I glaze over EVERY TIME. He seriously has the most boring, pompous style of writing EVER.
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 11:09 AM
wiiksie's Avatar
Hermano
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Seasider
Posts: 8,109
vCash: 25
wiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Quote:
Originally Posted by MLB
God almighty, I glaze over EVERY TIME. He seriously has the most boring, pompous style of writing EVER.
True, but he does come out with the odd 'did you know' pub fact that blokes love to talk about. Such as:
Quote:
For instance, when Didi Hamann played last season the Reds conceded fractionally less than the norm, but the team also scored 10 fewer goals than average during his total minutes on the pitch. Other players, like Peter Crouch and Harry Kewell, helped the team score a lot more than the average, but their inclusion coincided with the Reds conceding more.
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 11:26 AM
Original202's Avatar
New Avatar Wanted
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Wavertree
Posts: 2,182
vCash: 500
Original202 is an unknown quantity
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

He's wrote another book? Based on this sort of shite? Fuck me, who buys this drivel?

It's nothing personal against him as I don't know him, but his style of writing is awful. I've read through all that and he hasn't told me anything I didn't already know bar a fact about us conceding less when Hamann plays. Well thank fuck for that, I'll sleep well knowing that now! I don't really care for stats, and everyone knows 64.65% of them are meaningless anyway.

This guy has sold thousands of books. Makes me wonder why a certain fanzine editor doesn't have a go, if someone as boring as him can write 2 books then I think it's safe to say a knowledgeable red with a humourous and interesting writing style could do the same. Although I suspect Tomkins books are bought by your average mainstream red, not your fanzine type.

Anyone on here ever read his book(s)? Is it the same type of stuff?
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 11:28 AM
molbyscorchio's Avatar
(please custom set title)
 
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 1,168
vCash: 500
molbyscorchio is an unknown quantity
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

always going to be a difficult sell, a new view on stats. Well, strictly speaking, not new, as Daniel Finklestein has already done this for the Times a long time ago as one of his tactical column fillers. A more interesting read than normal from PT.
__________________
Go! And never darken my towels again!
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 11:33 AM
Al Campbell's Avatar
*****
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Holyhead
Posts: 2,189
vCash: 500
Al Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well likedAl Campbell is well liked
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

I bought the book he brought out after our European Cup win. It's okay, a bit hard going in places and nowhere near as good as 'The Miracle of Istanbul' or Guilliem Balague's book.
__________________
I don't think it ought to be blasphemy, just saying Jehovah
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 01:05 PM
mht1892's Avatar
Forumite
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Woolville
Posts: 1,013
vCash: 500
mht1892 is an unknown quantity
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

hes a boring as fuck..... he has a strange obsessesion with stats, I dont mind reading articles by decent reds but hes on the make bringing a fuking booking out every week, anyone who would consider reading or purchasing that drivel must be an insomniac end of.

to sum it up ?? ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
Reply With Quote
  #11 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 01:12 PM
Chris's Avatar
Rivers
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Pinkerton
Posts: 13,360
vCash: 1400
Blog Entries: 1
Chris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the ProclaimersChris rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

sorry, I don't have seven spare hours to read a website column.
__________________
Back in 1991,
I wasn't havin' any fun,
'til my roommate said
Come on and put, a brand new record on,
Had a baby on it, He was naked on it,
Then I heard the chords that broke the chains
I had upon me.
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 01:14 PM
Scouse Missionary's Avatar
Oh Mannn!
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: A Long Time Ago, In A Galaxy Far Far Away...
Posts: 6,740
vCash: 500
Scouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the ProclaimersScouse Missionary rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Tomkins could be a good writer as he knows his stuff, but he takes too many words to say what he wants to say, and his humour is anything but. It's nothing a good editor couldn't sort, but he's losing a wider audience without one.
__________________
You’ll never find it now! Ha, ha, ha!!
Reply With Quote
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 01:58 PM
El Rojo's Avatar
El Rojo El Rojo is offline
Dutch Master
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 3,668
vCash: 500
El Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the ProclaimersEl Rojo rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

I think he should be commended for taking on and beating the global pharmaceutical industry in producing a cheap, holistic remedy for insomnia.
Reply With Quote
  #14 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 02:45 PM
Mark P's Avatar
Mark P Mark P is offline
Cutting the mustard
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Leeds
Posts: 2,865
vCash: 500
Mark P is liked
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Quote:
Originally Posted by El Rojo
I think he should be commended for taking on and beating the global pharmaceutical industry in producing a cheap, holistic remedy for insomnia.
Meowww!!
__________________
"It's not easy to juggle a pregnant wife and a troubled child, but somehow I managed to fit in eight hours of TV a day"
Reply With Quote
  #15 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 02:46 PM
Nunavut Patrick's Avatar
Tapir for Rafa! Viva!
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Nunavut
Posts: 12,195
vCash: 145
Blog Entries: 1
Nunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the ProclaimersNunavut Patrick rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Quote:
Originally Posted by Al Campbell
I bought the book he brought out after our European Cup win. It's okay, a bit hard going in places and nowhere near as good as 'The Miracle of Istanbul' or Guilliem Balague's book.
The Miracle of Istanbul was a decent read but went off the rails near the end when it tried to blend the music scene in Liverpool with football.

It's always interesting to read aboot the six minutes of madness (as Ancelotti desribed it) but I hope in future biographies, autobiographies they do not compare the time it takes to a) have an IBS attack b) order a Big Mac in the drive-through c) take a phone call from the mother-in-law and make an excuse ..... takes the same amount of time from Gerrards goal to Alonso's missed penalty and subsequent goal.
__________________
Tragedy of the Commons
Reply With Quote
  #16 (permalink)  
Old 27th September 2006, 05:36 PM
G Richards's Avatar
Carpe Deum
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,206
vCash: 500
G Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the ProclaimersG Richards rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: AUTUMNAL OPTIMISM: REDS ON THE UP by Paul Tomkins

Tomkins attempts to offer a wider statistical analysis than the norm, and for this he is to be commended. Whoever mentioned the Fink Tank from the Times also has a point, but I thought the Fink Tank was to do with probability of winning games, with the occasional Prozone analysis thrown in.

Anyhow, I thought Tomkins' latest article was a decent effort at a deeper kind of statistical analysis. Not everyone's cup of tea, but at least a departure from the sameness that afflicts most fan-generated football writing.

His writing style is too flat, and this has been said over and over on here, but I found this article fairly interesting.
Reply With Quote