Cafe Sports
Next
GAME
Next
Sponsored Links
  #1 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 12:50 AM
Forumite
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 553
vCash: 500
liver bird is an unknown quantity
carragher to be englands plan B

Revealed: the Eriksson plan to cope with loss of Rooney
By Matt Dickinson, Chief Football Correspondent

Carragher will play in anchor role
Owen upbeat despite injury scare




SVEN-GÖRAN Eriksson must prepare for the World Cup finals without Wayne Rooney and, remarkably, his plan promotes Jamie Carragher to the starting XI. The Liverpool defender will be deployed as a defensive midfield player against Hungary this evening to allow the England head coach to throw Steven Gerrard into the attack.



It is an unexpected elevation for Carragher but the country will hope that it unlocks the talent of Gerrard and Frank Lampard, two brilliant midfield players who have rarely worked successfully in tandem.

If all goes well at Old Trafford — and the plans are not disrupted by Michael Owen’s tight thigh muscle — the Swede will field the same, novel team against Paraguay in England’s first match in Germany on June 10. By then, he should be wiser as to whether Rooney has any chance of coming back into the side.

After talks between Eriksson and Sir Alex Ferguson yesterday morning, another scan on the Manchester United forward’s broken foot was, sensibly, scheduled for June 7. Rather than wait another week, it will allow England to assess the speed of Rooney’s recovery before Fifa’s deadline for withdrawing injured players on June 9.

“This was at my request and United understood the situation,” Eriksson said. “I can’t change the list after June 9 so it’s good to have a better idea what the future will be.” Coming three days after it was announced that Rooney would definitely be going to Germany and not scanned until June 14, the earlier check-up provoked concerns that there had been a setback. Those fears were exacerbated by a statement from United, which said that the injury “involves the joint” and would take longer to heal than the initial diagnosis.

However, Eriksson insisted that he still believed Rooney would play at the World Cup and that there had been “no change” in the assessment of the doctors. Sources with England and United both claimed that the striker, who has begun light running, remained optimistic although he may now stay behind to continue his recuperation when the rest of the squad flies to Germany next Monday. Jermain Defoe and Andrew Johnson remain on standby.

The scan on June 7 raises the prospect of England’s preparations for their opening match against Paraguay three days later being overshadowed by the latest, and possibly the definitive, Rooney bulletin and Eriksson said yesterday that he was fed up with talking about the will-he won’t-he saga. “Please,” he said, “let’s talk about a lot of other good football players in the squad.”

In Rooney’s absence, there are few more important players than Owen and there was a scare when he pulled up near the end of training yesterday with a tight thigh. He was taken for a precautionary scan but should play unless there is any recurrence overnight. That will not ease the displeasure of his club, Newcastle United, however, who complained last night that they had not been informed of their player’s condition.

Owen will be the attacking tip to a new-look England with Carragher in the holding role. Lampard will play close to Carragher, driving forward from midfield as he does for Chelsea. Gerrard will be pushed forward behind Owen in the hope that England can harness his attacking power, with David Beckham and Joe Cole operating on each flank.

Eriksson would not discuss his selection yesterday but he did confirm that he would start with the team that he believes will play against Paraguay in Frankfurt. While Carragher, and hopefully Gerrard, should be the beneficiaries, the obvious losers are Michael Carrick and Owen Hargreaves, who had hoped to play the holding role, and Peter Crouch.

Eriksson is likely to try more than one formation against Hungary, and against Jamaica in the final warm-up game, also at Old Trafford, on Saturday. If that includes Theo Walcott, the teenager will become the youngest England international, breaking Rooney’s record of 17 years and 111 days.











Gerrard free to strike fear into opposition
By Matt Dickinson, Chief Football Correspondent



THE clamour for Steven Gerrard to be given a more attacking role appeared to irritate Sven-Göran Eriksson last week and he even demanded of his inquisitors: “What, do you want him to play centre forward?” Perhaps he has been swayed by The Times campaign to “Unleash the G-force”, because he will free the Liverpool One and use him as an auxiliary striker against Hungary at Old Trafford tonight.



It is a formation, with Jamie Carragher thrust into the holding role, that had never been worked on before yesterday’s training session under Manchester drizzle. On the eve of the World Cup finals, Eriksson is still searching for his strongest line-up, but better late than never if it proves effective in coaxing the best club form from Frank Lampard and, in particular, Gerrard.

The Liverpool captain complained recently that he had only ever played 45 minutes in his preferred attacking role during more than six years and 40 appearances for England. Given Eriksson’s declaration yesterday that the starting line-up this evening is the one he has in mind to face Paraguay on June 10, Gerrard can be optimistic that, finally, he has been given the licence to rampage.

It is an exciting prospect, but if the system has an obvious flaw, it is that Michael Owen (provided that he is fit to start) could become isolated when England are under pressure. The Newcastle United striker is not built to be a lone forward and he cannot be expected to fend off defenders until the cavalry arrives.

England must also work hard to ensure that Gerrard is not continually taking the ball with his back to goal. If he is to add to his remarkable haul of 23 goals in this marathon season of 59 games (and counting), he needs to play as an attacking midfield player rather than a makeshift striker.

There are reasons to hope that it will work, even if the last time Eriksson burst out of his 4-4-2 tactical straitjacket, England lost 1-0 to Northern Ireland. Such a humiliating defeat might have put a man off experiments but, having failed so far to bring out the best in Gerrard and Lampard, it has to be worth a try. It seems fair to assume that the Swede would have persevered with his regular midfield pair in uneasy tandem had Rooney been fit, but the injury has forced a rethink and, if anyone should benefit from the Manchester United striker’s misfortune, there are few more deserving cases than Carragher. Eriksson had previously referred to the Liverpool stopper only as a reserve centre half and as a deputy for Gary Neville at right back, but he now has a chance of cementing a place in the World Cup starting XI.

A steadfast character, Carragher played regularly as a defensive midfield player in his younger days for Liverpool and for England Under-21. He is not the quickest but, as he demonstrated when playing with cramp in the 2005 Champions League final, there could be no more dogged and resolute figure to shield the back four while Lampard and Gerrard join the attack.

Asked this season if he regarded himself as a contender for the holding role in the England team, Carragher replied that he was “not good enough to do that for England. There are better players than me who can play there.”

It is a quote that could be used against him, and Eriksson, but Carragher’s modesty is one of his many qualities. He is not flash and will instead happily set about the dirty jobs this evening, the tackling and the mopping up, before passing the ball on to the more expansive Lampard and Gerrard.

The holding role had previously been set aside for Ledley King, but the Tottenham Hotspur captain was struck by the curse of the metatarsal. Michael Carrick might have been playing there but, in the B international defeat by Belarus last week, he fluffed too many of his lines. For him, the selection of Carragher is a hefty knockback. There was an expectation, too, that Peter Crouch might be thrust into Rooney’s position, but Eriksson did not exactly seize an invitation to extol the lanky forward’s virtues yesterday. The Swede appears more comfortable using the Liverpool man off the bench. All eyes tonight will be on his club-mates.


hmmmm ,strange
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:06 AM
LiverpoolFreak's Avatar
Forumite
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Posts: 1,203
vCash: 500
LiverpoolFreak is an unknown quantity
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Happy for Carra. Hope he does good enough to get a starting place in the WC.
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:28 AM
snez1's Avatar
snez1 snez1 is offline
(please set custom title)
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Ormskirk
Posts: 2,647
vCash: 500
snez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud ofsnez1 has much to be proud of
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Nice for Carra, not so much for Crouchy. Not sure if Carra has enough on the ball or nous tacically to play against the likes of Riquelme or Ronnie Dingo in that position though, seen as he's not played there for a decade like.
__________________
"You're not gonna believe this. The guy killed 16 Czechoslovakians. He was an interior decorator."
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 07:15 AM
Paul's Avatar
Come on Rafa, lad!
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Oxtonia, the cultural heart of the leisure peninsula.
Posts: 22,349
vCash: 0
Paul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

I think this is weird. He's going to play his best centre half out of position and play Ferdinand, whose game is more suited to a midfield role, at the back instead. I can't think of a more deserving player to be in England's first eleven, but I wouldn't do it like this. However, Carra always rises to a challenge and I've no doubt he'll prove himself invaluable.
__________________
Check the writing skills forever coming tight with the quill.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 07:44 AM
wiiksie's Avatar
Hermano
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Seasider
Posts: 8,084
vCash: 25
wiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul
I think this is weird. He's going to play his best centre half out of position and play Ferdinand, whose game is more suited to a midfield role, at the back instead. I can't think of a more deserving player to be in England's first eleven, but I wouldn't do it like this. However, Carra always rises to a challenge and I've no doubt he'll prove himself invaluable.
Very weird...like you say, why not replace ferdinand with our lad? And why isnt he playing carrick in the holding midfield role, which is his position after all? Maybe this is still just media speculation...

But the bottom line is if Cara is in the team, then im fucking chuffed for him.
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 08:33 AM
Mav's Avatar
Mav Mav is offline
The Oncoming Storm
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Wirral
Posts: 2,233
vCash: 500
Mav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud ofMav has much to be proud of
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Yet another Liverpool player played out of position to accommodate an inferior version.

I worry about this - as can anyone else spell scapegoat.

Good luck though Carra - if anyone deserves it it's you.
__________________
Count the shadows
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 08:45 AM
bri's Avatar
bri bri is offline
Rafa's Gold Diggers
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: On a Couch
Posts: 7,444
vCash: 500
bri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud of
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Didn't carra start out as CM and then moved to the back.

Anyway yep typical Ericcson plan b at the death. We know carra will step up but in reality he shouldnt have to as we already have 8/9 midfielders in the team. Being able to step up on a sunday morning is a bit different to stepping up for the world cup. Carrick should allowed to play this role more often to develop him, not fuckin around with it.

You could say Erriccson is experimenting with a style of play but he should of done that 6 months ago.

And Owen is set to play tonight despite this morning paper reports.
__________________
www.s2as.com-&-www.session1.com

for all your summer and winter sports needs.
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 09:05 AM
wiiksie's Avatar
Hermano
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Seasider
Posts: 8,084
vCash: 25
wiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Quote:
Originally Posted by joeyb
Didn't carra start out as CM and then moved to the back.

Anyway yep typical Ericcson plan b at the death. We know carra will step up but in reality he shouldnt have to as we already have 8/9 midfielders in the team. Being able to step up on a sunday morning is a bit different to stepping up for the world cup. Carrick should allowed to play this role more often to develop him, not fuckin around with it.

You could say Erriccson is experimenting with a style of play but he should of done that 6 months ago.

And Owen is set to play tonight despite this morning paper reports.
so a formation of 1-10 then. oh dear.
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 09:24 AM
Paul's Avatar
Come on Rafa, lad!
 
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Oxtonia, the cultural heart of the leisure peninsula.
Posts: 22,349
vCash: 0
Paul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the ProclaimersPaul rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

The other strange thing in all of this is playing Gerrard as a second striker. Why doesn't Eriksson look at what works for Liverpool? If he's going to play Cara as the holding player, he'd be better playing Beckham next to him in a bastardised Momo/Xabi combination with Gerrard in the free role from the right he's played for us and Lampard in an attacking role that suits his goal-scoring ability.

Beckham Carra

Gerrard Lampard Cole

Owen

However, I'd play this:

Robinson

Neville Carra Terry Cole

Beckham Ferdinand

Gerrard Lampard Cole

Owen
__________________
Check the writing skills forever coming tight with the quill.
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 09:28 AM
hamstrung's Avatar
TLW Howard Donald
 
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 10,599
vCash: 1265
hamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimershamstrung rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

If it means Carra gets a chance to play, I am pleased for him but he should be in the team at centre half. He'll have no problems in the group stages in that position.

However, it just shows what a nob Sven is. What's the point in even bothering to take Carrick and Hargreaves if you don't trust them to play?

He's a very odd manager.
__________________
"NNNNEEEEEVVVVEEERR Forget where you're comin' from"
Reply With Quote
  #11 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 09:31 AM
wiiksie's Avatar
Hermano
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Seasider
Posts: 8,084
vCash: 25
wiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimerswiiksie rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul
The other strange thing in all of this is playing Gerrard as a second striker. Why doesn't Eriksson look at what works for Liverpool? If he's going to play Cara as the holding player, he'd be better playing Beckham next to him in a bastardised Momo/Xabi combination with Gerrard in the free role from the right he's played for us and Lampard in an attacking role that suits his goal-scoring ability.

Beckham Carra

Gerrard Lampard Cole

Owen

However, I'd play this:

Robinson

Neville Carra Terry Cole

Beckham Ferdinand

Gerrard Lampard Cole

Owen
I like that formation a lot. And beckham started playing in that role when he joined Real didnt he?

But I think sven is going with:

Robinson

Neville Ferdinand Terry Cole

Cara

Beckham Lampard Cole

Gerrard

Owen


And frankly, I think this is better than playing crouch up top with michael.
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 09:37 AM
Thants's Avatar
Dirk, actually
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: You are
Posts: 15,480
vCash: 381
Thants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the ProclaimersThants rules harder than the Proclaimers
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

I suppose SGE does need to see how many positions his players can play in so he can have many possibilities with his subs but to have Carra at DM is going a bit too far. He played against a dutch side for england at that position and totally looked out of depth.
__________________
Well I hope I make more money than this in the next world

Degen To Barry . . . Barry finds Kuyt . . . Milner on the overlap . . . oh beautiful cross from Milner . . . Keane at the near post GOOOOAAAAALLLLLLLLLLL
Reply With Quote
  #13 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 11:53 AM
reder's Avatar
TLW Season Ticket Holder
 
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 678
vCash: 624
reder is likedreder is likedreder is likedreder is liked
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Delighted for Carra but personally I still believe he should be CB on form alone. However this all shows what a completely inept sh1t manager SGE really is. The WC is almost upon us and he is still fucking around with formations. In the next 2 games he is going to play players in positions and use systems that he has never done before. This should be the fine tuning stage not the experimental stage.

Also Beckham has to play wide, he never could and never will cut it playing centrally and the top level of international football.

I dont know how people can possibly think england will win the WC with a manager like SGE.
Reply With Quote
  #14 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:19 PM
Roast Beef's Avatar
Forumite
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Japan
Posts: 595
vCash: 500
Roast Beef is likedRoast Beef is likedRoast Beef is likedRoast Beef is likedRoast Beef is liked
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Quote:
However, I'd play this:

Robinson

Neville Carra Terry Cole

Beckham Ferdinand

Gerrard Lampard Cole

Owen
That's the formation Australia use under Hiddink and it works wonderfully from what I've seen. But that's with a big target man up front (Viduka) rather than a speedy midget like Owen.
Reply With Quote
  #15 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:23 PM
Fink's Avatar
Fink Fink is offline
Socialismo o muerte
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Sheffield via L31
Posts: 3,019
vCash: 500
Fink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud ofFink has much to be proud of
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Isnt Owen crocked again?
Reply With Quote
  #16 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:29 PM
bri's Avatar
bri bri is offline
Rafa's Gold Diggers
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: On a Couch
Posts: 7,444
vCash: 500
bri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud ofbri has much to be proud of
Re: carragher to be englands plan B

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fink
Isnt Owen crocked again?
I guess we'll find out tonight. It's all just a crock of shit to me.

Yeah we'll go with 2 injured strikers, 1 bit part one and one who's never played before. Now we'll start experimenting with midfield formations. If were not careful we could see quite a shambolic English world cup.

But then again all this could actually work for England, backs to the wall and all that
__________________
www.s2as.com-&-www.session1.com

for all your summer and winter sports needs.
Reply With Quote
  #17 (permalink)  
Old 30th May 2006, 01:33 PM
Mr T's Avatar
Forumite
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: York
Posts: 1,550
vCash: 500
Mr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well likedMr T is well liked