[philyburkhill]

Howard vs Reina - Close one too close to call
Neville vs Finnan - the latter is vastly over-rated but has the edge over Phil
Yobo vs Agger - Yobo by far
Lescott vs Carragher - Again Joleon no contest, Carragher is slow and has poor technical ability
Baines vs Riise - Baines is younger, quicker and less prone to concentration lapses
Arteta vs Alonso - Mikel by a country mile, best creative mid in Prem
Cahill vs Gerrard - Gerrard is class, but would you really swap Cahill? i wouldn't
Pienaar vs Babel - again very close, maybe Babel has the ede but Pienaar is amazing
Carsley vs Mascherano - Mascherano by miles
Osman vs Kuyt - the later is headless chicken with sily ears, Ossie is in-consistent
Yakubu vs Torres - te yak is better goalscorer but you cant deny the spics class